Letters to the Editor
Dear editor,
Remember the Supremes – the top 1960’s vocal band in the country? Well voters in Wisconsin now have the chance to select a new member of our own Supremes – the Wisconsin Supreme Court. Our Wisconsin Supreme Court makes decisions that significantly impact our lives. Soon, they’ll decide cases that affect abortion rights, fair legislative voting districts, community safety, clean water, and other crucial issues. On April 4 we have the privilege of selecting our next Supreme. Our first responsibility is to vote! In the 2019 Wisconsin Supreme Court race, 1.2 million folks voted – but over 2 million eligible voters stayed home and didn’t bother. This race is too important to have it decided by only a third of us. Secondly, how should we make a decision as to the best candidate for this foremost job? As the Supremes pleaded, Come See About Me. Learn about the experience and positions of the candidates. Go to Vote411.org/wisconsin. Then, consider what other judges have to say. Judge Janet Protasiewicz has over 150 Wisconsin judges endorsing her candidacy. On the other hand, current Wisconsin Supreme Court Justices of all political stripes have criticized Judge Dan Kelly’s written opinions. On April 4, it’s your judgment that counts!
Janet Brandt
Arena
Dear editor,
In state Senator Howard Marklein’s February 24 e-update, he bemoans what he characterizes as Governor Tony Evers’ “spend, spend, spend” budget. Mr. Marklein, Republican co-chair of the legislature’s Joint Finance Committee, concedes that some of these budget ideas “might sound good,” that some were drafted by Republicans, and that he actually agrees with some of them. Nevertheless, he decries spending.
Under Governor Evers, Wisconsin has actually accumulated a huge surplus of $7.1 billion – revenue that is desperately needed to repair our crumbling roads and infrastructure, our closing schools, our social programs, our county and municipal services, our environmental programs. Mr. Marklein admits that Wisconsin programs and services are in a state of decline, although the only example he gives is what he claims are inadequately staffed prisons.
Mr. Marklein’s whining about a budget that may or will spend some of that $7.1 billion surplus is disingenuous and hypocritical, to say the least. Republicans in the legislature are pushing for a new “flat income tax” to replace Wisconsin’s longstanding progressive income tax, first implemented in 1911, that taxes people according to their income and results in wealthy individuals paying somewhat higher tax rates. The Republican plan would gradually implement a flat 3.25 percent income tax across every tax bracket by 2026 regardless of income, meaning that Wisconsin’s wealthiest residents would pay proportionately less of their wealth in taxes than would lower-income families. According to the Legislative Fiscal Bureau, the Republican flat tax would result in approximately $14.2 billion less in tax revenue over the first four years and lost revenue of about $5 billion in every subsequent year – a loss to Wisconsin that makes Governor Evers’ spending proposals pale in comparison.
By shifting this inequitable income tax burden to poor and middle class people who can least afford it, Republicans would once again be giving a handout to Wisconsin’s wealthiest who can most afford to pay their taxes -- particularly after Wisconsin’s eight billionaires got $11.1 billion richer during the first 10 months of the pandemic while over one million Wisconsin workers lost their jobs. Senator Marklein needs to be honest with Wisconsin voters about what’s really going on.
Marilyn Martin
Richland Center
Dear editor,
The statewide referendums: promoting or subverting democracy?
On your ballot for the April 4th election you will find a referendum question asking if able-bodied, childless adults should be required to look for work in order to receive taxpayer-funded welfare benefits. A common sense proposal, but it is already a requirement to receive unemployment benefits or food stamps. And only the federal government can impose a work search requirement for Badger Care, the state’s health care program for low-income people. So what purpose is served by having this referendum on the ballot?
The other referendum asks voters if they approve of an amendment to the state’s constitution regarding bail laws. Currently judges can set bail only to insure a defendant will show up for trial. In cases where a person accused of a violent crime, the proposed amendment would allow a judge, in setting bail, to consider a wide range of factors such as the seriousness of the crime, previous criminal record, and the need to protect the community from serious harm. Again, this is a common sense but needless proposal. In determining if a person is a flight risk, judges already take into consideration the factors mentioned in the amendment. If protection of the community is a concern, why not just require a judge to deny bail for a defendant who poses a danger to the community, rather than letting them go free awaiting trial just because they can afford a high bail fee.
The referendums are of so little consequence that it was easy for both candidates in the Supreme Court race, who agree on almost nothing else, to endorse them. These unnecessary referendums were placed on the ballot by the Republican dominated legislature not to gauge public opinion, but to manipulate it to serve their political ends. The referendums are worded in a way that plays to the outrage of extreme right-wing voters over what they perceive as “softness on crime” and “welfare fraud.” By implying that the proposed work search requirement law and the constitutional bail amendment could actually do something to address those grievances, the framers of the resolutions hoped to increase the turnout of right-wing voters in the highly politicized Supreme Court race.
Referendums should be used as intended, to gauge voters’ opinions on important issues facing the state, such as gerrymandering, abortion rights, recusal rules for Supreme Court Justices, and environmental protections. Subverting the purpose of referendums is just another way of subverting democracy.
Allen Pincus
Barneveld


