Twins fall in HTL showdown

SAUK CITY — The dream season for the Sauk Prairie Twins took a nightmarish turn Sunday afternoon.
For 11 innings, the host Twins and the visiting Stoughton Merchants stood toe-to-toe in a second-round battle for the Home Talent League Sunday championship at Chuck Hall Memorial Field.
But when the dust settled after three and half hours, it was Stoughton that stood tall.
Cleanup hitter Andres Moreno lined a tiebreaking single to center field, and Chris Lund added a grand slam later in the inning as Stoughton exploded for eight runs in the 12th inning to pull out an 11-3 victory over Sauk Prairie in a second-round game of the HTL round-robin amateur baseball playoffs.
“We were hoping our offense would explode a little earlier, we had our chances,” Sauk Prairie player/manager Lucas Koenig said after the Twins suffered their first loss of the season. “I’m going to go home and be disappointed that I didn’t come through when I could have.
“I know a few other guys probably feel the same way. We could have got that hit or made that play that got us the win that we didn’t today.”
Twins’ reliever Connor Leister tossed 6 1/3 innings of three-hit ball and struck out 12.
But as his pitch count surpassed 100 in the top of the 12th inning, Stoughton reached Leister for six straight hits, including Lund’s grand slam, to put the game away.
“I’m real impressed with Stoughton’s squad,” Lucas Koenig said. “Of all the teams in Home Talent, we pride ourselves on how we work and how we love baseball, and I think Stoughton’s right there with us.
“They were really working hard in batting practice. They weren’t just showing up to play recreational baseball. They were putting the work in to get better, just like we do.”
Yo Herdenez, whose solo home run in the eighth inning off Leister pulled Stoughton even at 3-3, took over on the mound for the Merchants in the bottom of the ninth.
When he was finished pitching a perfect three-inning stint, Herdenez was the winning pitcher, allowing no baserunners with five strikeouts.
“I’m very excited I got that hit, the home run. That inspired the team to come back,” said Herdenez through translator Andres Moreno.
Stoughton outhit Sauk Prairie, 14-7, and had five extra base hits, including three home runs vs. none for the Twins. That lack of firepower eventually was too much to overcome.
“It was a matter of time,” Herdenez said, referencing the eight-run, 12th inning explosion. “It was such a good game for a long time. But we knew we had to get the win.”
Stoughton manager Dale Steffens said the Merchants, who are averaging 13 runs per game in the Final Four championship round, made the plays when they had to.
But Steffens said Herdenez, who started the game playing third base, made the biggest impression.
“We’ve been saving him just for this,” Steffens said. “Yo did the job. He has all year when we’ve called on him.”
Alex Maier had three hits and scored two of the Twins’ three runs. Maier also drew a lead-off walk and stole second base with two outs in the bottom of the ninth to set up the potential game-winning run for Sauk Prairie.
Herdenez, who retired the first two batters he faced in Sam Koenig and Dylan Slotty on infield popups, then got the biggest out of the game when he struck out Lucas Koenig on a 1-2 pitch to force extra innings.
“It took 12 innings for that tie to get broken. It could have gone either way. It didn’t go our way,” Lucas Koenig said. “I was feeling pretty good when I came up and Maier stole second. I’m supposed to come through there for us, but I didn’t.”
Lund and Ryan Nyhagen each had three hits for Stoughton and each also fell a triple short of the cycle. Julian Edwards, Winder Fuentes and Herdenez all had two hits.
“We hit the ball hard early right at people,” Steffens said. “It killed us a few times, not being able to get a bunt down. We had three, four chances to get a bunt down to advance a runner and couldn’t get the job down.”
But after Herdenez retired the Twins in order in the ninth, 10th and 11 innings with five strikeouts, Steffens said it was only a matter of time before the Merchants broke through on the scoreboard.
“We knew he had been going for quite a few innings,” Steffens said of Leister, who threw 127 pitches, including 78 for strikes. “We just knew if we could shut them down at the plate, we’d have a chance.”
Nyhagen’s two-run blast to center field off Sauk Prairie starter Sam Koenig staked Stoughton to a 2-0 lead in the top of the second inning. Sam Koenig, though, retired seven of the final eight batters he faced and allowed just four hits with three strikeouts over five innings.
Sauk Prairie got one run back in the third inning when Maier singled and eventually scored when Dylan Slotty reached base on an infield error.
The Twins took the lead in the fifth inning after Lucas Koenig was hit by a pitch with the bases loaded. One out later, Benjamin Lenerz drew a bases-loaded walk to give Sauk Prairie a 3-2 lead.
“It felt like a championship game,” Maier said. “Our fans treated it like it. Their fans treated it like it. You could look at how chippy and how hard and how aggressive we played. Those were two good ballclubs going at it for 12 innings for a championship.”
However, that was all the offense that Sauk Prairie could muster. Adrian Montilva, Hernandez and Eric Sperloen allowed just three baserunners over the final seven innings.
“They’re a great team,” Leister said. “I’d rather pitch to their 1 through 4 hitters than their 5 through 8. They all can hit. We just played a really great team.
“The last inning, my fastball slowed down a little bit, and it seemed a little easier for them to hit it.”
• On deck: Sauk Prairie (15-1, 1-1) hosts Eastern Section champion Monona (12-3, 1-1) on Sunday at 1 p.m. Stoughton (13-1, 2-0), the Southeast Section champion, hosts Belleville (11-3, 0-2), the Western Section champion, on Sunday at 1 p.m. in the other third-round matchup in the round-robin Final Four tournament.
“It’s going to hurt right now. But we’ll be ready by the time we come here next week,” Sauk Prairie shortstop Alex Maier said.
Stoughton, which won the Night League championship last Thursday, can clinch its first Sunday League title since 2017 with a victory over Belleville.
“That’s a good ballclub,” Maier said of Stoughton. “We thought this would be the week to decide the Final Four. It was another good, fun atmosphere. There’s nothing better.”
Sauk Prairie still has a chance for the title if Belleville can upset Stoughton and the Twins defeat Monona. That would force a one-game playoff that would be held at Stoughton.
“It’s never over until they tell us it’s over,” Maier said. “We’ll keep playing. We get to come back here one more time. I expect a rowdy atmosphere just as usual because there’s still implications. We’ll have another fun Sunday.”
Sept. 5
Stoughton 11,
Sauk Prairie 3 (12 innings)
St .. 020 000 010 008 – 11 14 3
Sauk .. 001 020 000 000 – 3 7 4
Pitchers (ip-h-er-bb-so) – St.: Ben Riffle (4.0-6-3-2-3), Adrian Montilva (4.0-0-0-3-4), Yernando Herdenez (W: 3.0-0-0-0-5), Eric Sperloen (1-1-0-0-1). SP: Sam Koenig (5.0-4-2-0-3), Connor Leister (L: 6.1-9-8-3-12), Adam Ballweg (0.2-1-1-0-0).
Leading hitters – St: Ryan Nyhagen (3x6), (2B), (HR); Chris Lund (3x6), (2B), (HR); Yernardo Herdenez (2x6), (HR); Julian Edwards (2x6); Winder Fuentes (2x7). SP: Alex Mayer (3x5).


