The agony of defeat
MCFARLAND — Amy Schlimgen saw the other half lived most of 2021.
And Sauk Prairie’s girls volleyball coach didn’t like it one bit.
Schlimgen and the Eagles compiled the best regular season in school history, posting a 45-3 record and earning the No. 1 ranking in Division 2. In Sauk Prairie’s WIAA sectional final against host McFarland last Saturday, though, the Eagles experienced the frustration they had been doling out for 2 ½ months.
The Spartans played faster, with greater efficiency and with tremendous defensive prowess. The result was a 25-22, 25-16, 25-20 win.
“I felt kind of helpless,” said Schlimgen, who just finished her third year with the Eagles. “And that’s how teams probably felt against us a lot of times this year.
“We were sending easy free balls over. You can’t do that to that kind of team and their offense was so nice and fast and their reactions were amazing. We just weren’t there tonight, which is not like us.
“We have played better than that. A lot better. I’m just at a loss.”
Sauk Prairie senior outside hitter Aida Shadewald, a Wright State recruit, agreed with her head coach.
“Their defense played amazing,” Shadewald said of McFarland. “We couldn’t stop them. There were some unfortunate errors on our side at bad times kind of helped them, too. Their serves kept us out of system and we weren’t able to swing and score.
“It’s awful. Words won’t even describe it. We’ve been working so hard all season and all four years. So to have our season end like this is hard.”
The top-ranked Eagles were trying to earn a second consecutive trip to state. Unfortunately for them, that meant defeating No. 3 McFarland on the Spartans’ home court.
The way McFarland dominated, though, the match could have been in Sauk Prairie — or on the moon — and the result wouldn’t have changed.
“McFarland’s a great team. They’ve always been really great. We could have done some things better, but you’ve got to give them so much credit because they such a great team. We are too, but it just didn’t show tonight.”
The first set was by far the most competitive.
McFarland used a 6-1 run midway through the set to take a 13-9 lead. But the Eagles answered with an 8-4 burst and tied the set, 17-17.
In that stretche, Shadewald had two kills and an ace, while Paukner had an ace and both Alexis Klemm and Jenna Pistono had kills.
McFarland used a 7-3 burst to surge ahead, 24-20. The Eagles responded with back-to-back kills by Shadewald and closed to 24-22, but a Sauk Prairie hitting error allowed the Spartans to capture the set.
“They just came out really fast and playing on their home court helped,” Shadewald said. “And we kind of just couldn’t really get into system, couldn’t get our offense going. So we were a little slow and just could never really get back into the game.”
Thing went from bad to worse for the Eagles in the second set. McFarland raced to a 4-0 lead, and amazingly, the closest Sauk Prairie could come from there was three points.
Leading, 8-4, McFarland went on a 12-4 burst to grab a 20-8 lead and cruised home. And for the first time all year, Schlimgen admitted she was out of chess moves.
“I felt kind of helpless,” Schlimgen said. “I’ll beat myself up for a whole week, but right now, I don’t think I had any other options than the kids we played and the lineup we used.”
The third set was more competitive. Once again, though, Sauk Prairie never led.
Leading, 11-10, McFarland went on an 8-2 burst and grabbed a 19-12 advantage. Sauk Prairie pulled within 22-17, but couldn’t come any closer.
And moments later, McFarland was celebrating a huge win.
“Having us both in the same sectional and (No. 4) Edgewood — probably the top three teams in the state in this sectional — is tough,” Shadewald said. “Leading up to this, the energy and the anticipation was crazy. And we knew we had to show up on their court and play well. After the first game, I thought we were OK. But then after that it kind of fell apart.”
Shadewald finished with 15 kills, 10 digs, 11 good serves that included two aces and two blocks.
“I wish I had (Aida) for a couple more years,” Schlimgen said. “I love watching her hit. I love watching her block. She’s going to have a fun college.”
Alia Schlimgen gave a gutty performance and finished with 20 digs and eight good serves with no errors. Maggie Hartwig had seven blocks and a kill, while Anni Braund had four kills, 13 digs, two saves and an ace.
Alexis Klemm had 11 assists, 12 digs, four blocks, four kills and an ace, while Jenna Pistono had nine assists, seven digs and two kills. Paukner had three digs, two blocks, one kill and an ace, while Kaya Wilson added three digs and three blocks.
The seniors will leave behind a remarkable legacy after taking the program to heights it hadn’t reached in years.
Sauk Prairie took a major step forward in 2019 when it went 28-14 overall. The Eagles qualified for state in 2020, then had a remarkable run in 2021 before falling in the sectional finals.
“We definitely are very close and very tight,” Paukner said. “We’ve come so far as a group and a team and it’s just a great experience getting to go to state last year, then having the experience to come all the way to the sectional finals. We feel super lucky and super thankful.”
Shadewald agreed.
“Last year we proved it to everybody else, making it to state,” Shadewald said. “Now, people knew who we were.”
Amy Schlimgen, who fell to 5-14 in sectional finals during her brilliant career, admitted that she’s going to be lost for a week or two now that the season is over.
“It was so fun. Every morning I’d wake up and the first thing I’d think is I can’t wait to see them play,” Schlimgen said. “We had a lot of great moments this year. It was just phenomenal. It was really fun. I miss them already.”
• Sauk Prairie 3, Ripon 0 — The Eagles rolled past Ripon in the sectional semifinals, 25-14, 25-15, 25-19, on Oct. 28.
Shadewald led the way with 14 kills, 10 digs, six aces and two blocks, while Anni Braund added eight kills and 10 digs. Alia Schlimgen had 14 digs, two aces and one save, while Alexis Klemm had five kills, eight digs and 13 assists.
Jenna Pistono had 14 assists, one ace, one kill and four digs, while Olivia Paukner had four kills, three digs and one block. Maggie Hartwig had three kills and four blocks, Kaya Wilson had three kills and a block and Makenzie Breunig had a block.
“We were in complete control that night,” Amy Schlimgen said.


