The Book Nook
Optimism in the face of tragedy
Esther Earl wrote only one book during her lifetime because she was diagnosed with thyroid cancer at age twelve and died four years later. Her book is called “This Star Won’t go Out” and describes her life and thoughts.
The fact that she couldn’t catch her breath while engaging in sports or tired easily puzzled her family. After seeking medical help, she received her diagnosis and at first was told there was much cause for hope. That’s because thyroid cancer in children is normally an easily-treatable disease with nearly a ninety percent survival rate. Unfortunately, Esther’s cancer had already spread to her lungs, requiring additional treatment.
On the heels of her diagnosis was a long series of treatments with varying results. What makes this book special is that instead of a litany of complaints about her situation, Esther’s positive attitude repeatedly rises to the surface, providing an amazing and inspiring story.
While she does share some of the darker aspects of her journey, she doesn’t dwell on the negative, which readers will discover from the opening description. She feels guilt that the illness thwarted her parent’s plans to have their family live in different parts of the world. There are also moments when she vents very understandable frustration at her situation, but time after time she overcomes the negative with grace and wit.
The introduction was written by John Green, a prize-winning author who dedicated his most popular book “The Fault in our Stars” to Esther. He and his brother Hank gained notability via their Vlogbrothers channel and went on to create Crash Course – an educational YouTube channel for their science and humanities courses. The book starts with his touching description of how he met Esther and the measure of their friendship.
He notes disliking the phrase “Internet friends” because of its implication that online relationships are less meaningful than those conducted face-to-face. This is a salient point because the people Esther met online provided her with acceptance and steadfast friendships. The high level of rapport led to them forming a group they called “Catitude”. She turned to these friendships as source of comfort when she was feeling low.
Her story is told in a variety of formats, including her blog and journal entries, artwork, letters and texts. It’s clear that she enjoyed developing her artistic talent by doodling and drawing. This creates lots of eye appeal that reflects her bubbly personality and sense of fun. One of the most reflective moments comes via a letter to her future self, in which she encourages the older Esther to help others with cancer.
While most of the narrative comes from Esther, there are also entries from her family, friends and medical staff. The contributions from her parents help fill in some of the story gaps and give us a sense of what must have been a parent’s nightmare. The love and dedication of her family is clear, although heartbreaking at times as they describe dealing with their situation and feelings. Through them we learn where Esther got her optimism and religious faith. Although we know the outcome from the beginning, her acceptance and positive feelings almost radiate off the pages.
Esther had been asked to provide ideas for the “Make A Wish Foundation”, a non-profit organization that grants life-changing wishes for kids dealing with critical illness. Although she couldn’t think of anything specific at first, she expressed a desire to meet her Catitude friends in person and attend a Harry Potter convention. That sparked a plan to combine both wishes which brought the friends together in time to attend the 2009 Harry Potter convention as a group. This provided something they looked forward to for months and the happy anticipation is clear from details shared in their communications.
The convention occurred when Esther was losing ground physically, but being part of a great shared experience was a joyous milestone. While obviously weakening, she was able to celebrate a memorable event with those she loved.
It was here she meet John Greene. At the time he was unaware that chat rooms associated with his Vlogbrothers channel provided the forum where Esther met people in her online family. He provides a description of their serendipitous meeting that’s as delightful as her account of Catitude’s formation and history.
There’s a bit of a mix-up with photos not matching entry dates, which I found a bit confusing. However, it didn’t detract much from the overall picture. Readers can expect a book that lets us into the mind of a wonderful young woman who didn’t get the chance to become an adult. You’ll likely agree she made the best of what she had.
Esther’s ability to turn her vision outward to help others, combined with her strength and optimism is an inspiration as she consistently chose to focus on the positive. Her YouTube videos and blogs are still generating loving responses years after her death. She made an impact on nearly everyone who met her, and although her life was short, she left a lasting legacy by touching the lives of many.


