Eagles’ spikers bucking the odds

Amy Schlimgen has built a powerhouse volleyball program at Sauk Prairie High School during her four seasons in charge of the Eagles. But with the graduation of three all-state performers last June, Sauk Prairie was expected to be in a rebuilding mode this season. Somehow, though, that message was lost in translation for the Eagles, who are unbeaten in Badger West Conference play and ranked second in the Wisconsin Volleyball Coaches Association Division 2 poll. Sauk Prairie, pure and simple, has reloaded and moved on. “I was a little worried after last season,” said 6-foot-2 senior middle hitter Maggie Hartwig, a returning WVCA Division 2 All-State second-team and All-Badger West Conference first-team selection. “We lost some key role players who were seniors. But how we ended at sectional finals was fuel for us. “A lot of my teammates worked hard in the off-season. We worked hard in the summer and that’s brought us to where we are today and has given us another chance at hopefully, going to state again.” Last Thursday, Sauk Prairie swept Reedsburg, 25-12, 25-16, 25-11, in a dominant performance to add further proof to the notion the Eagles are on course for a history-making season. “We only lost three players from last year. We had four all-conference players back, including Jenna Pistono, who was honorable mention,” Schlimgen said of the 5-8 senior setter, who is in her fourth varsity season. “We have a lot of multi-sport athletes. They are great athletes. “A couple of them don’t play volleyball year-round. But they are phenomenal. They have all improved so much from last year, even the kids who don’t play club volleyball. They are amazing.” Hartwig said the team bonding kicks into gear during tryouts but is built throughout the year. “Each year we go to Wizard Quest and then to Moose Jaw in Wisconsin Dells,” she said. “We get to know everyone a little better. At Wizard Quest, coach will make groups and put us with people we usually don’t talk to so we can get to know them.” Added senior 5-11 outside hitter Anni Braund: “We’ve built a lot of off-court chemistry as well as on-court chemistry, which really helps. We get along really, well, when we’re not playing volleyball which is really fun.” Built for success Following the program’s second state appearance in 2020, Sauk Prairie finished 46-4 a year ago, winning the Badger West regular season title before falling to Madison Edgewood in the conference tournament to share the league championship. The Eagles then advanced to the WIAA Division 2 sectional finals, where they lost in three sets to host McFarland. While the loss of first-team All-State selections Aida Shadewald (Illinois State) and Alia Schlimgen (South Dakota State) and All-State honorable mention pick Olivia Paukner (UW-Stevens Point) left a void in the program, the cupboard wasn’t bare. “Our bench is so deep. We have so many talented players,” Pistono said. “Even if they are playing or in practice, they make us a lot better. Everyone is fun to be around and has a great attitude. “We lost some main players from last year. But during the summer, we were winning consistently and had great chemistry on the team. So we could see this coming.” Leading the way has been Hartwig, who will play NCAA Division 1 basketball at the University of Evansville next season. A three-year performer, she was one of the league’s most dominant returnees. “She will be playing college basketball, but Maggie is also one of the very best middle hitters in the state,” Schlimgen said of Hartwig, who led the team with 103 blocks a year ago. “She brings outstanding energy on and off the court.” A pair of All-State honorable mention picks also returned in Anni Braund and senior 5-9 setter Alexis Klemm. “Anni has improved tremendously and is one of the best outside hitters in the state,” Schlimgen said of Braund. “She is the nicest and most polite kid. She talks the most out on the court.” Klemm agreed. “Anni’s very vocal on the court,” Klemm said. “She’s always using her voice and she always has a smile on her face. If we’re down, she always has a smile and we look to her to lead us through it.” Schlimgen said Klemm is one of only two players on the team who doesn’t play club volleyball. But her athletic ability shines through. “She’s a tremendous athlete, a soccer player who brings speed and a competitive drive to the team,” Schlimgen said. Rounding out the starting lineup are junior 5-10 outside hitter Jozie Braund — Anni’s sister — senior 5-10 middle hitter Kaya Wilson, senior setter Pistono and junior 5-7 libero Ellery Apel. With a solid corps of eight seniors returning for their last go-around, Schlimgen was hopeful that the program could remain among the state’s elite programs. “I didn’t expect to be the favorite in the conference,” Amy Schlimgen said. “We lost two Division I kids.” But after winning the season-opening Janesville Tournament and then sweeping conference rivals Oregon and Edgewood in back-to-back matches, the Eagles were poised for another successful season. Hartwig said the strong senior class laid a solid foundation for continued success. “We’ve grown up playing together. That really helps how close we are together,” Hartwig said. “Not only do we have fun together, but we can also hold each other accountable. We’ve been together so long that we’re comfortable enough. “That really helps us in certain situations, especially when we get to the bigger games, and having that accountability towards each other and having fun at the same time. We believe we can do anything.” Executing a plan Amy Schlimgen said following up on the past three years of success with another stellar season wasn’t rocket science. She has had a plan and simply stuck to it. “This summer, we did the same stuff I’ve set up for all my teams for decades,” said Schlimgen, who had a successful career at Wisconsin Heights before taking over at Sauk Prairie in 2019. “I open up the gym up once a week. I’ve got my five contact days for the whole program. Then we do a bunch of tournaments and a league. Usually, we do two leagues.” Schlimgen had a plan from the beginning that promptly bore fruit. “We won the Janesville tournament, going 11-0 my first year,” she said. “(Sauk Prairie) had never won it before so I said, ‘Whoa, let’s go.’ That was a nice start to the whole thing. “There are such great athletes here. They just needed a push and to believe in themselves. It was like they were just satisfied to go .500. But I knew they were better athletes than that. I just kept pushing them.” Pistono is the lone senior who made the varsity team out of tryouts her freshman year. But when Schlimgen promoted Anni Braund and Maggie Hartwig towards the end of that season, a solid foundation for the program took root. Rounding out the seniors on the roster are 5-8 outside hitter Abby Ballweg, 5-7 setter Kylie Craig, and 5-7 defensive specialist/libero Jenna Johnson, who provide a solid work ethic in practice and inspirational support as role players during matches.  “They are really tight, this group of seniors,” Schlimgen said. “I remember for regionals, I moved up Anni and Maggie as freshmen. Then we all took a trip to state just to go because I wanted them to experience and see it. I remember staying overnight at a hotel in Green Bay and you couldn’t keep those three away from each other. They slept on the same blankets on the floor. We’d have to separate them. “Then COVID came and it was even more difficult to physically distance them from each other. This is a really tight group of kids, they really are.” Hartwig said the Eagles’ bench, sparked by inspirational leader Ellie Setterlund, a 5-9 junior right-side hitter, has also played a key role in the team’s continued success. “Ellie Setterlund does a great job in that role,” Hartwig said. “She doesn’t get a lot of playing time on the court. But she is our hype man. When you look to her, you get a smile on her face. She always has the energy. We always look up to her to put you in a good mood.” Anni Braund seconded that emotion. “Ellie is a person who creates a lot of energy on and off the court,” Braund said. “She is always dancing and always cheering. The bench energy contributes a lot to our court energy. After a kill, the bench is on their feet screaming and clapping. That puts a smile on my face when I’m out there.”   Ample motivation Anni Braund and her teammates admitted that for as much success as the Eagles attained a year ago, they ended the season with a bitter taste in their mouths and a collective chip on their shoulders. After breezing through the conference season and advancing to the Badger West Conference tournament finals a year ago, top-seeded Sauk Prairie was stunned by second-seeded Madison Edgewood 2-1 (23-25, 25-21, 15-7). Schlimgen said coming up short of the tournament title, which was held during the Eagles’ Homecoming week, was one of the team’s biggest regrets. Yet a stinging loss just one step away from a return to the state tournament left the Eagles with a bigger chip on their shoulders. Sauk Prairie soared into the Division 2 sectional finals but was grounded by host McFarland, which earned a 3-0 sweep (25-22, 25-16, 25-20) and the coveted trip to the state tournament. “Everyone realizes we have so much potential and can use that to push us as far as we can go,” Anni Braund said. “Everyone was a little bummed when we ended last year when I feel we all knew we could have gone further.” Klemm agreed. “We’re going to want it even more this year,” Klemm said. “We didn’t lose conference, we tied last year, but we wanted to come out as total conference champs.” Sauk Prairie will try to put a stamp on a unanimous conference title when it closes out its league dual-meet season at Portage on Thursday and at the conference tournament hosted by Mount Horeb on Saturday. “We have conference this next week and it’s also Homecoming like it was last year,” Klemm said. “I’m really hoping we can stay focused and keep tracking what our goal is, to win conference and then to win state.”