Eagles’ spikers settle for third

MOUNT HOREB – Call it déjà vu or simply history repeating itself.
But last Saturday’s Homecoming celebration didn’t match up with what Sauk Prairie’s girls volleyball team wanted it to be.
Sauk Prairie, the top-ranked team in the last week’s Wisconsin Volleyball Coaches Association Division 2 poll, won the first set in its Badger West Conference tournament semifinal match over ninth-ranked rival Madison Edgewood.
But unlike the team’s prior two meetings this season, the Eagles came up short.
Edgewood rallied to sweep the next two sets and secure a 2-1 victory (18-25, 25-20, 15-9) over Sauk Prairie to relegate the Eagles to the third-place match.
Sauk Prairie swept Edgewood 3-0 in a conference dual on Sept. 8 and took two of three sets at the Crusaders’ tournament on Oct. 8.
But the third meeting favored Edgewood this time around.
“We are obviously capable of beating them,” said Sauk Prairie senior middle blocker Maggie Hartwig, who will play Division I basketball at the University of Evansville next year. “I feel we are a better team than they are, but they just outplayed us. They knew our weak spots and what we were going to do. We couldn’t get around that.”
Sauk Prairie, which posted a 7-0 record in league duals, closed out the day by sweeping Oregon 2-0 (25-11, 25-13) to take third place in the conference tournament.
“That proved we’re a tight team,” junior setter Ellery Apel said. “We still focused on staying together and that was the big takeaway from the day.”
But that left the top-ranked Eagles far from satisfied despite winning nine of 11 sets during the tournament.
“I can’t lie or hide it yet — too soon — but it was a very disappointing ending to a great conference season,” Sauk Prairie coach Amy Schlimgen said. “I feel bad for the girls. They have worked so hard all season and worked hard on Saturday and couldn’t attain one of their team goals.”
Meanwhile, Edgewood advanced to the championship match where it defeated Mount Horeb 2-1 (25-18, 16-25, 16-14) to repeat as conference champions.
Unlike a year ago, when Sauk Prairie won the league duals title and Edgewood won the tournament crown to share the Badger West championship, Edgewood won it outright this time based on the scoring system that combines both the league duals and conference tournament.
“If Mount Horeb could have beaten Edgewood again, we could have had a three-way title share,” Schlimgen said. “We made a lot of unforced errors, which hurt a lot. (Edgewood’s) front row is very good. They played very well against us.”
Sauk Prairie swept through pool play unbeaten, winning in straight sets over Monroe (25-7, 25-11), Baraboo (25-11, 25-14) and Oregon (25-16, 25-18). That gave the Eagles a 27-match winning streak against league opponents entering the conference tournament semifinals against Edgewood.
After rallying from an early 7-2 deficit, Sauk Prairie won its 28th consecutive dual in league competition before Edgewood rudely ended the streak.
The Eagles expected to see second-seeded Edgewood in the championship match. But Mount Horeb stunned the Crusaders in pool play, pulling out a dramatic 2-1 victory (25-21, 22-25, 16-14).
That set the stage for the two league powers to face off in a conference semifinal match.
“We were undefeated going into the conference tournament on another Homecoming weekend for us and can’t even get to the championship match because we ran into a very determined Edgewood team unexpectedly in the semifinals, after their unexpected loss in pool play to a very fired up Mount Horeb team,” Schlimgen said.
Edgewood jumped to a 7-2 lead in the opening set against Sauk Prairie, which stormed back to tie the set at 17-17 on senior outside hitter Anni Braund’s service ace.
Hartwig’s kill gave the Eagles their first lead at 19-18, and they were able to hold on with junior setter Ellery Apel sealing the 25-18 win with an ace.
“It was persistence,” Schlimgen said. “We started to play a little timid. We weren’t hitting and running as fast as an offense as we work on and try to run. It was too many tips and not well-placed.
“Their front row was just phenomenal. We kept hitting into the block and getting blocked and kept trying to get the ball down in front of the back row, and we weren’t successful enough.”
Just like in the opening set, Edgewood scored the first three points of the second set and used some strong serving from UW-Green Bay recruit Gillian Koning and Grace Lamb to open up a 14-9 lead.
“The earlier you can work ahead in a match, the better off you’re going to be” Edgewood coach Eliza Johnson said. “In all three (sets), we got an early lead. We started with some of our strongest servers and really took advantage of it. We did a good job.
“(Sauk Prairie) made some mistakes they don’t usually make. In those situations, we want to be able to get out there and finish what we set early. In set one, we were up and then we let them come right back and take it away from us.”
However, the Crusaders made sure that wouldn’t happen again, securing a 25-20 victory in the second set to set up a third and deciding set, where Edgewood quickly took control, scoring the first four points and opening a commanding 7-1 lead.
“Ella Weber started us off serving us to a 7-1 lead,” Johnson said. “That was just huge. At that point, all we had to do was get a side out. Each time they got a point on us, if we got a side out, statistically speaking, we were going to get to 15 (points) first.”
Schlimgen said the Eagles’ serving wasn’t up to par, which Edgewood was able to capitalize on.
“That’s how we beat Edgewood before, with tough serves,” Schlimgen said. “You have to try to keep them out of system as much as possible. If the serves aren’t tough enough, they’re going to set up that giant front row, which is going to hurt you.”
The closest the Eagles came was within 12-9 on junior outside hitter Jozie Braund’s kill.
But Edgewood closed out the 15-9 victory to advance to the championship match.
“Only in the first set were we able to fight back and win, thanks largely to some great serving by Ellery Apel,” Schlimgen said. “(Alexis) Klemm played amazing with seven kills, seven assists, five digs and a block. (Jenna) Pistono was also amazing with three kills, 14 assists, seven digs and two big blocks.”
The Eagles capped the day with a dominant victory over Oregon, sweeping the Panthers 2-0 (25-11, 25-13) to claim third place.
Anni Braund led the way with eight kills, three digs, two aces and two blocks. Pistono had 13 assists, Hartwig chipped in five kills, two aces and four blocks, and Klemm had three kills, seven assists and eight digs.
“We played really well against Oregon and shut them down,” Schlimgen said.
Edgewood was 6-1 in duals to earn six points and received seven points for its tournament title for 13 points to earn the outright league championship.
“I don’t think anyone expected that to happen,” Klemm said of the Edgewood victory. “We won the first set against them, but couldn’t close it out. Their offense was phenomenal. All of their hitters had great hits almost every single time.”
Sauk Prairie was 7-0 in duals for seven points and received five points for its third-place finish in the tournament for 12 points to finish second overall. Mount Horeb (5-2 duals and second place in the tournament) took third with 11 points.
“Both of those teams had great days and were playing at the top of their game,” said Schlimgen, who coached at Wisconsin Heights for 24 years and led the Vanguards to a Division 3 state title in 2008 before taking over at Sauk Prairie in 2019. “Hopefully this will fuel our desire to keep working hard for the rest of the month to improve our game and work to eliminate unforced errors and reach our other team goals.”
Anni Braund agreed.
“Our team has very clear goals,” she said. “At the beginning of the season, we all had a goal sheet asking what our team goal was for the year and what our individual goals were. Everyone’s team goal said either make it to state or win state and conference championships.
“I think the main takeaway from this was that while we did not win the conference championship, our end goal is still the same, to win state. This will benefit us. It will push us to improve our blocking or fix the little picky things that happened last game.”
Sauk Prairie will close out the regular season with the Badger Challenge on Thursday at home at 7 p.m. and a tournament at Randolph beginning at 10 a.m. on Saturday. Then the Eagles begin the journey of trying to earn a trip to the state tournament.
Hartwig said the loss will serve as motivation for the playoffs.
“We were upset about it, especially since most of the starters are seniors and it was our last chance to win conference,” Hartwig said. “It will push us to work harder in practice, just so we can redeem ourselves by hopefully going to state or at least going really far in the playoffs.”
Conference
tournament roundup
• Sauk Prairie 2, Monroe 0 — The Eagles swept the Cheesemakers 25-7, 25-11 in the first round of pool play. Maggie Hartwig led the way with six kills and an ace. Anni Braund had five kills and two digs.
Jenna Pistono handed out a team-best nine assists and had three aces, two digs and a block. Jozie Braund had a team-high five aces to go along with two kills and two digs. Ellery Apel sparked the defense with four digs and added an ace and an assist.
• Sauk Prairie 2, Baraboo 0 — Anni Braund finished with seven kills, three digs, two blocks and an ace to lift the Eagles to a 25-11, 25-14 sweep of the Thunderbirds in the second round of pool play. Jozie Braund added six kills, four digs and an ace. Jenna Pistono dished out 12 assists, Alexis Klemm had nine assists, and Ellery Apel had four digs.
• Sauk Prairie 2, Oregon 0 — Jenna Pistono led the Eagles to a 25-16, 25-18 sweep of the Panthers in the final round of pool play, finishing with nine assists, four digs, one kill and an ace. Anni Braund chipped in with five kills, six digs and an ace, and Maggie Hartwig had three kills, three blocks and an ace. Alexis Klemm totaled three kills, four assists and two digs, while Ellery Apel had five digs and three aces.
Oct. 8
Badger West Conference
Tournament
Third-place
Sauk Prairie 2, Oregon 0
Oregon ………........…… 11 13
Sauk Prairie …............... 25 25
SAUK PRAIRIE (leaders) — Kills: Anni Braund 8. Assists: Jenna Pistono 13, Alexis Klemm 7. Blocks: Maggie Hartwig 4. Aces: A. Braund 2, Hartwig 2. Digs: Klemm 8, Ellery Apel 6.
Semifinal
Madison Edgewood 2,
Sauk Prairie 1
Edgewood ………… 18 25 15
Sauk Prairie …..….. 25 20 9
MADISON EDGEWOOD (leaders) — Kills: Gillian Koning 6, Addie Schmotzer 5. Assists: Ella Weber 12. Blocks: Schmotzer 6. Aces: Peyton Forrer 1, Koning 1, Weber 1. Digs: Koning 7, Weber 7, Forrer 6. Victoria Rodriguez 6.
SAUK PRAIRIE — Kills: Anni Braund 7, Alexis Klemm 7. Assists: Jenna Pistono 14, Alexis Klemm 7. Blocks: Maggie Hartwig 4, Pistono 2. Aces: Ellery Apel 2, Jozie Braund 2. Digs: Ellery Apel 12, Pistono 7.


