The Book Nook

History buffs seeking a well-researched book that reads like a novel will be rewarded by trying “The Dark Queens” by Shelley Puhak.  It focuses on two queens who ruled different parts of the largest post-Roman kingdom in Western Europe. It’s unlikely you’re familiar with Queen Brunhild or Queen Fredegund, even if you studied sixth century history.  Both reigned longer than nearly every king or Roman emperor who preceded them and accomplished much, yet without recognition of their accomplishments.  At first the author could find little information about either woman, but by digging deeper she discovered evidence suggesting their obscurity was purposeful. The result is a careful reconstruction of the lives of these queens, helping us understand them and the time in which they lived.  The book’s subtitle is ”The Bloody Rivalry that Forged the Medieval World” and it was a truly bloody time.  Whether the rivalry that defined them was real or fabricated, it inspired a fictional story of the Valkyrie which was immortalized in Richard Wagner’s lengthy opera cycle. Both were considered outsiders in their own way.  Brunhild was a princess who traveled over a thousand miles to marry her prince, which invokes a sense of romance but in reality was a marriage arranged strictly for political purposes.  Her new husband had several brothers, so it’s possible she never imagined becoming a queen.  Her sister-in-law Fredegund was a serving girl who caught the eye of a powerful man willing to put his wife aside for her.  She would be accused of using witchcraft and even darker acts for her own gain. Both rose to sovereignty due to circumstances out of their control and, as queens, many events could occur to shift their status, creating a state of uncertainty for them and their offspring.  Obtaining and keeping the throne required fights on multiple fronts to retain any hope that their sons would someday rule.  Life became a constant game of strategy that was fraught with danger.  Betrayal, kidnapping and murder were common factors in their lives. Fredegund reigned for nearly thirty years while Brunhild acted either as regent or queen for forty six years.  Unlike their male counterparts, Brunhild and Fredegund commanded armies to defend or extend their territory, negotiated with popes and royalty and ruled vast areas.  They were supreme strategists who laid the foundation of what would someday be Charlemagne’s empire, yet instead of recognition, accusations of enchantment and crimes dogged both their lives.  Those denunciations may have basis in fact, although solid evidence has long since passed into dust.  There are strong arguments for beliefs that one of the queens plotted no less than six successful assassignations.  There’s a saying that history is written by the winners and there are many instances of facts being altered or omitted to shape opinion.  Ancient Romans believed it was important to be remembered, hence the proliferation of statues, biographies and monuments.  Punishment for tyranny or treason was the destruction of any physical reminders of those found guilty.  This practice often extended to deleting the offender’s name from public records so that no trace of that person could ever be found.  This lesson was repeated centuries later by those eager to expunge the queens’ importance. Puhak recreates their lives with clear writing, painstakingly-researched information and carefully thought-out scenarios to fill in the blanks of the protagonist’s life.  When referencing accounts from those who knew the queens, she presents it with the understanding that they likely had their own agendas that may have biased their narrative.  She provides the deductive reasoning used behind her theories and suppositions to make her points.  The maps, illustrations and a list of relevant characters act as crucial references in telling the dramatic stories of a turbulent time when the iron grip of Roman  rule had weakened and warring factions competed fiercely to fill the power void.  This plus the combination of academic facts and narrative nonfiction helps to bring history alive, giving us a feel for the times and the dangers facing those who aspired to rule.  Along the way there are palatable bites of information that not only inform but also remind us why it was called the dark ages.  Similar tidbits were embedded in the author’s notes, which I found helpful.  It set the stage for the story and linked these obscure queens to modern times via current cultural and political references.  It also acted as a springboard for thoughts on a few subjects readers might want to keep in mind after delving into the main story. The book’s title not only refers to the period of time in which the book is set – the Dark Ages, but also because the two names survived in spite of attempts to erase them from history.