Eagles picked to win Badger West
Editors Note: This preview of the Badger West Conference was compiled by Wissports.net.
2021-22 Recap
Reedsburg went undefeated in the Badger West. The Beavers didn’t lose a game until the Division 2 state tournament when they fell to state runner-up Pewaukee, 73-43, in a state semifinal, finishing the year with a 28-1 record.
Edgewood (19-9 overall) took second in the conference, going 11-4, and reached a Division 3 sectional final, dropping a 63-37 contest to Waupun, which went on to win the D3 state title. Sauk Prairie (17-8) and Oregon (14-12) went 9-6 in the Badger West; Sauk Prairie won both meetings.
Mount Horeb (10-14) finished fifth with a 7-8 record, while Baraboo (5-20, 3-12), Mon-roe (2-21, 2-13), and Portage (3-22, 0-15) rounded out the Badger West standings.
2022-23 Preview
Predicted Order of Finish:
1) Sauk Prairie
2) Oregon
3) Edgewood
4) Reedsburg
5) Mount Horeb
6) Baraboo
7) Monroe
8) Portage
Players to Watch:
Sydney Cherney, jr., Reedsburg – Cherney, a 5-9 guard, was named unanimous first-team all-Badger West and Division 2 WBCA All-State as a sophomore. She averaged 18.2 points, 7.9 rebounds, 3.3 assists, and 3.5 steals per game for the D2 state qualifi-ers that finished the year 28-1 overall. Cherney, a quick and shifty guard, holds NCAA Division II offers from Maryville University, McKendree University, and Michigan Tech University. She enters her junior year with over 800 career points.
Taya Fernandez, jr., Edgewood – Fernandez, a 5-5 point guard, will look to build off her sophomore campaign in which she averaged 7.2 points and 2.5 assists per game for the 19-9 Crusaders.
Madison Foley, sr., Edgewood – Foley, a 5-9 guard, tallied 6.5 points, 3.0 rebounds, and 2.0 steals per contest as a junior for the D3 sectional finalists.
Maggie Hartwig, sr., Sauk Prairie – Hartwig, a 6-2 forward, was named first-team all-Badger West as a junior. She averaged nearly a double-double last season with 12 points and almost 10 rebounds per game. The NCAA Division I University of Evans-ville recruit is a versatile athlete who can score from the inside and from behind the arc.
Taylor Jacobson, sr., Monroe – Jacobson, a 5-10 guard, led the Cheesemakers in scoring last season and is committed to NCAA Division II Texas A&M International.
Delaney Nyenhuis, jr., Oregon – Nyenhuis, a 6-0 forward, collected 8.2 points, 5.0 re-bounds, and 2.0 steals per game as a sophomore for the Panthers.
McKayla Paukner, jr., Sauk Prairie – Paukner, a 5-9 guard, scored 9.7 points per game as a sophomore, receiving first-team all-conference for the Eagles.
Taylor Pfaff, sr., Baraboo – Pfaff, a 5-7 point guard, was voted first-team all-conference as a junior. She averaged 13 points, 3.8 rebounds, 2.6 assists, and 2.5 steals per game and connected on 46 three-pointers last season.
Sam Schmitt, jr., Oregon – Schmitt, a 5-6 point guard, averaged 11.8 points, 3.4 re-bounds, 3.3 assists, and 3.6 steals per game, earning first-team all-conference as a sophomore.
Myesha Thompson, sr., Mount Horeb – Thompson, a 5-7 guard, will move into a lead-ing role this season for the Vikings.
1) Sauk Prairie
The Eagles are the team to beat in the Badger West. Sauk Prairie returns seven let-ter-winners from last year’s team that finished 9-6 in the conference and 17-8 over-all.
Second-year head coach Jacob Breunig told WisSports.net their strengths are post-play, guards who can create, and team defense. He noted that consistency on outside shooting is a weakness.
Headlining the Eagles’ roster is 6-2 forward Maggie Hartwig, an NCAA Division I University of Evansville recruit, who averaged nearly a double-double last season with 12 points and just under 10 rebounds per contest. Junior guard McKayla Paukner provides them with another scoring option at the top, netting almost 10 points per game last season.
Rounding out the group of returning starters is junior guard Erelyn Apel, while fel-low junior guard Ava Andres is another notable returnee for the Eagles. Sauk Prai-rie is among the others to watch in the WSN Division 2 Preseason Rankings.
Their half-sectional includes McFarland, ranked No. 9 to open the season, which beat Sauk Prairie by two points in regional play last season. The opposite half of the sectional features No. 3 Union Grove and No. 8 Waukesha West.
Starters Lost: Kassia Marquardt (7.8 ppg), Olivia Paukner (5.7 ppg)
Returning Starters: Maggie Hartwig (6-2, sr., 11.8 ppg), McKayla Paukner (5-9, jr., 9.7 ppg), Erelyn Apel (5-8, jr., 5.1 ppg)
Other Returning Players: Ava Andres (5-4, jr., 2.7 ppg), Jenna Johnson (5-6, sr.), Alexis Atkinson (5-7, jr.)
Newcomers: Olivia Schultz (5-2, jr.), Callie Brings (5-10, soph.), Carly Coy (5-9, sr.), Gracyn Meyer (6-0, soph.), Macee Gulden (5-9, soph.), Ava Brings (5-10, soph.), Kennedy Breunig (5-7, soph.)
2) Oregon
The Panthers figure to be in the mix for the Badger West title. Oregon welcomes back nine letter-winners from its 2021-22 squad that went 9-6 in the Badger West and 14-12 overall.
Adam Wamsley, who enters his 10th year as a head coach, has a 72-37 record in five years as the Panthers’ leader.
“Excited and talented group with good depth, lots of athleticism, quickness, and basketball intangibles,” Wamsley told WSN.
He noted they have no seniors on the squad and will need leaders to step up from younger classes, especially the juniors.
“Our size and strength may be issues, especially on the rebounding side of things,” Wamsley said.
Wamsley explained the Panthers will need to learn to play physically without foul-ing and improve their decision-making.
Highlighting the Panthers’ team is 5-6 junior point guard Sam Schmitt, who led the team in points (11.8), assists (3.3), and steals (3.6) per game last season. Fellow juniors Delaney Nyenhuis (6-0) and McKenna Carroll (5-11) also return as starters and will look to provide strength in the paint for the Panthers.
Additional returning contributors include Katelyn Studebaker and Brooke Bastian, both junior guards. Oregon, which moved up to Division 1 this season, opened the season at home against Stoughton on November 18.
Starters Lost: Emily Mortenson (7.6 ppg), Lily Eisele (7.4 ppg), Payton Lang (5.2 ppg)
Returning Starters: Sam Schmitt (5-6, jr., 11.8 ppg, 3.3 apg, 3.6 spg), Delaney Nyenhuis (6-0, jr., 8.2 ppg, 5 rpg, 2 spg), McKenna Carroll (5-11, jr., 5.1 ppg, 4.8 rpg)
Other Returning Players: Katelyn Studebaker (5-8, jr., 3.3 ppg), Brooke Bastian (5-6, jr., 3.2 ppg), Klara Tracy (5-6, soph., 3.1 ppg), Olivia Neis (5-8, soph., 2.9 ppg), Reese Evans (5-3, jr.), Carly Zych (5-6, soph.)
Newcomers: Teagan Schoenecker (5-9, frosh.)
3) Madison
Edgewood
The Crusaders (19-9 overall in 2021-22) return seven letter-winners from last year’s team that finished second (11-4) in the Badger West and one win away from the Division 3 state tournament. WBCA Hall of Fame coach Lora Staveness enters her 30th season at the helm, compiling a 446-245 record, and has guided them to two WIAA state tournament appearances, taking home the Division 3 state title in 2017.
Staveness told WSN their strengths are athleticism, leadership, team dynamics, and depth. She noted that shooting and interior post-play are areas for growth.
Heading up the group of returnees for the Crusaders are junior point guard Taya Fernandez and senior guard Madison Foley, who return as starters and will take on leading roles this season. Senior wing Grace Nwankwo is another key returning player who will take on an expanded role. Other notable players back include jun-iors Lilly Moschkau and Carly Menzel.
Starters Lost: Amber Grosse, Ally Barth, Maisy Andres, Ellie Meriggioli
Returning Starters: Madison Foley (5-9, sr. 6.5 ppg, 2 spg), Taya Fernandez (5-5, jr., 7.2 ppg, 2.5 apg)
Other Returning Players: Grace Nwankwo (5-8, sr., 5.1 ppg, 5 rpg), Lilly Moschkau (5-5, jr., 3 ppg), Carly Menzel (5-6, jr., 3 ppg), Addie Schmotzer (6-1, sr., 2.7 ppg), Elizabeth Jacques (5-8, sr.)
Newcomers: Zee Gnewuch (frosh.), Maren Schmotzer (soph.), Erin Schauer (Soph.), Mya Tomlinson (Soph.)
4) Reedsburg
The Beavers will need to fill the void left with the graduation of the majority of the team that went unbeaten in the Badger West and made a second straight trip to the WIAA state tournament. Four of the players are playing a college sport, including the Beavers’ all-time leading scorer Mahra Wieman, who is playing at NCAA Divi-sion III UW-Oshkosh.
Mark Simon has compiled a 273-113 record in 16 years as head coach, which in-cludes guiding them all three of the program’s state tournament appearances.
“We graduated 85 percent of our scoring and 10 seniors who led us to a state championship game,” coach Simon told WSN.
The Beavers will build around 5-9 junior guard Sydney Cherney, who was second in the conference in scoring last season. Other notable returnees include seniors Ruby Olson and Kate Cherney, who will move into key roles this season.
Starters Lost: Mahra Wieman (23 ppg), Trenna Cherney (13.7 ppg), Grace Benish (5.9 ppg), McKenzie Bestor (5.8 ppg), Macie Wieman, Melissa Deetz,
Returning Starters: Sydney Cherney (5-9, jr., 18.1 ppg, 7.9 rpg, 3.3 apg, 3.5 spg)
Other Returning Players: Ruby Olson (5-8, sr., 2.7 ppg), Cate Cherney (5-7, sr.), Ni-cole Riberich (5-6, sr.), Lauren Belk (5-6, sr.)
Newcomers: Addison Meister (soph.), Naomi Benish (soph.), Kylee Molitor (soph.), Maddie Casey (soph.), Maddie Crary (jr.), Jessica Laffey (jr.), Brynn Mikonowicz (jr.)
5) Mount Horeb
The Vikings graduated four starters from last season’s team that went 7-8 in the Badger West and 10-14 overall. Mount Horeb also had a coaching change right before practice started as Bart Leibfried and Dana Showers were named interim head coaches after Tom Lesar stepped down.
Their lone holdover from last year’s starting five is senior Myesha Thompson, who will help provide leadership for the young squad.
Starters Lost: Grace Vesperman (11.9 ppg), Emma Anderson (11.3 ppg), Zoe Par-ker (5 ppg), Leah Leibfried (5 ppg)
Returning Starters: Myesha Thompson (5-7, sr., 3.6 ppg)
Other Returning Players: Delaney Duckett (5-7, sr.), Rowan Johnson (5-6, jr.), Ella Fager (5-8, jr.), Lily Post (5-6, jr.)
Newcomers: Jada Matthews (5-5, jr.), Ava Kolb (6-0, jr.), Katie Smith (5-5, jr.), Lela Markhardt (5-8, jr.), Morgon Monroe (5-9, soph.), Hallie Klein (5-4, soph.), Oumou Dowling (5-8, soph.)
6) Baraboo
The Thunderbirds welcome back four starters from their 2021-22 team that finished 3-12 in the league and 5-20 overall.
Michael Behl, who enters his ninth year as head coach, told WisSports.net that this will be their most competitive team since the 2016-17 season, with the return of most of their scoring and rebounding.
“Our strengths include quickness, perimeter shooting, experience, and continuity,” he said.
Leading the way for Thunderbirds is senior point guard Taylor Pfaff, who led the team in scoring and assists per game last season. Other top returnees include jun-ior Caitlyn Frank and senior Jayden Ross, while Sarah Palacek also returns as a starter.
Behl indicated that 6-3 junior Daesha Whyte, originally from Jamaica, will also play a key role this season.
Starters Lost: Emma Fluette (6.5 ppg)
Returning Starters: Taylor Pfaff (5-7, sr., 13 ppg, 46 3PM, 2.6 apg, 2.5 spg), Caitlyn Frank (5-7, jr., 11 ppg, 47 3PM, 5.1 rpg, 3.2 spg), Jayden Ross (5-6, sr., 6.4 ppg, 6.3 rpg), Sarah Palacek (5-6, sr.)
Other Returning Players: Rachel Wieczorek (5-6, sr.), Jaedynn Donahue (5-7, jr.), Bianca Brown (5-8, jr.), Kadence Funmaker (5-5, soph.)
Newcomers: Daesha Whyte (6-3, jr.)
7) Monroe
The Cheesemakers went 2-21 overall last season with their two victories coming against league foe Portage. Monroe is led by senior guard Taylor Jacobson.
Top Returning Players: Taylor Jacobson (5-10, sr.), Sydney Conway (5-9, sr.), So-phie Golembiewski (5-11, soph.)
8) Portage
The Warriors went winless in the Badger West and 3-22 overall last season. Sixth-year head coach Jessica Howe told WSN they have a mix of deep varsity minutes and some inexperience.
“Our strengths include team speed and quickness, outside shooting, and active hands and hustle on defense,” she said.
Their top returnee is junior Estella Brees, who led them in scoring last season.
Starters Lost: Cameran Ratz (8.4 ppg), Elizabeth Fick
Returning Starters: Estella Brees (5-5, jr., 11.2 ppg), Asja McCall (5-6, sr., 5.6 ppg), Malia McCall (5-6, sr., 4.2 ppg)
Other Returning Players: Greta Shortreed (5-6, sr.), Mya Bolgrien (5-9, jr.), Hannah Kallungi (5-9, jr.), Chloe Schultz (5-7, jr.)
Newcomers: Chloe Hibner (jr.).


