The Book Nook

Finding hope in the ashes of tragedy   Best-selling author Susan Meissner links two of New York City’s most horrific events in her historical novel “A Fall of Marigolds”.   The first occurred in March of 1911 when the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire claimed nearly 150 lives while a century later the 9/11 attack killed almost three thousand people.  Despite the heartbreaking subject matter, Meissner gives us two personal journeys cleverly connected by a shared item. The story starts with Taryn Michaels, who works at a Manhattan fabric store and is raising her daughter alone.   She was on her way to the World Trade Center when the 9/11 attack prevented her from meeting a loved one.  With the help of a stranger she survived the day, but has been wracked by guilt that she could have saved someone she loved. Ten years later she’s content enough with her life until a long-lost photo raises distressing memories she thought were behind her.  The uneasy peace she’s made with what she saw and experienced that day is shattered because the photo will force her to share information she isn’t ready to reveal.  Taryn knows it’s the right thing to do, but fear of repercussions puts her in emotional limbo.   Jumping back one hundred years we meet Clara Wood, a nurse in Manhattan who is still numb months after witnessing the horrific event.  When a fire broke out on the eighth floor, those trying to flee discovered many of the doors had been locked to prevent theft.  It also prevented their escape and Clara watched helplessly as some jumped to their death rather than be consumed by flames. Unable to bear living near the disaster, she chose to move to Ellis Island, where immigrants with contagious diseases were confined until their either recovered or died.  Unbothered by the danger of contagion, Clara throws herself into her work and has come to think of Ellis as her in-between place.    Months later she’s still torn by guilt that she’s responsible for the death of someone she knew.  She can see Manhattan from a safe distance but her steadfast refusal to leave her refuge causes others to worry about her .As time passes, those close to her worry about her attachment to the past. While tending to the sick she meets a fevered man who lost his wife to scarlet fever and feels a kinship sparked by shared loss.  She’s pulled into his sad yet intriguing story and, in an attempt to help, makes some choices that bring unwanted consequences.  Anxiety and worry weigh heavily on both women, limiting their ability to do what’s needed to move forward.  Their experience moves slowly from the darkness of despair into the light of hope. Taryn and Clara give us insight into personal loss and the potential for learning to love again.  The author provides convincing looks at their inner turmoil as they move through the grieving process.  While the term “survivor’s guilt” wasn’t coined until the 1960s, it’s clear both women are dealing with symptoms following a traumatic experience.  Clara is fortunate to meet someone with the skills and patience to help her overcome self-imposed barriers.  Taryn’s narrative wasn’t fleshed out enough to provide background on how she dealt with the shock. A few minor complaints lowered my reading enjoyment, but not enough to give up on the fascinating stories.  The gap before returning to Taryn’s tale was enough to require me to backtrack and the handling of Clara’s character felt uneven in the second half.  I also questioned some of her actions, although they did provide reasons to explore her ethical dilemmas.  The storyline felt a little contrived, but other readers may disagree with my assessments On the positive side, there’s a strong message of human resilience and that it’s possible to love again, even after seemingly insurmountable loss.  Overall, the combination of historical and contemporary tales provided opportunity for comparisons between the two times.  The bulk of the story focuses on Clara and it provides background for the connection between these separate yet related heart-warming stories.  The author ably portrayed the self-doubt Taryn and Clara experienced and their regrets over not doing things differently. She also avoided the temptation to delve deeply into gory details of both catastrophes.  It’s unclear whether she intended this to be Christian fiction, but the scarcity of swearing and handling of the storyline point in that direction. While researching the 1911 fire, I learned that it’s still considered one of America’s worst industrial disasters.  The owners of the building were originally indicted but acquitted two months later.  They profited hugely from exaggerated insurance claims from the fire, which claimed mostly young European immigrants.  Public outcry led to investigations and the passing of several safety and health laws that included new fire codes.  So, some good arose from the ashes of disaster and likely prevented more deaths. The author explores the “What ifs” that often comes with the territory of negative outcomes, wrapping things up with emotionally satisfying endings for both protagonists and readers.  Meissner offers a bittersweet and virtuous story with a happy ending.