Same old, same old
DEFOREST — Maggie Hartwig hoped this would be the year that Sauk Prairie’s girls basketball team would burst through its annual postseason roadblock.
But for the senior forward — who surpassed the 1,000-point mark in her final prep game — and her teammates, it wasn’t meant to be.
Hartwig finished with a game-high 28 points and 14 rebounds. But fourth-seeded and host DeForest edged fifth-seeded Sauk Prairie, 57-54, in a WIAA Division 2 regional semifinal game last Friday night.
“It really sucks that we lost all four years in the first round at regionals,” Hartwig said. “That was my main goal, to make it past the first round, which obviously we couldn’t execute.”
Sauk Prairie grabbed a 46-43 lead when Hartwig scored on a baseline drive with just under 6 minutes to play.
But the Norskies, who had switched to a 1-3-1 trapping zone defense, capitalized on back-to-back turnovers to ignite a 7-0 run and grab the lead for good at 50-46 with 4:32 to play.
Sophomore Jada Kelliher scored off an offensive rebound and followed it up with a three-point play off a steal, layup and free throw with 4:50 remaining.
Junior guard Rylan Oberg then converted a fastbreak layup to cap the surge.
“They came out in that 1-3-1 (zone) and as much as we’ve worked against it this year, we played a little nervous or complacent at times and didn’t make the right read that we needed to,” Sauk Prairie coach Jacob Breunig said. “We forced a couple of bad passes that weren’t there. It’s disappointing that we were capable of winning that game.”
Senior Aspin Kelliher made two free throws with 1:09 to play extend DeForest’s lead to 57-52. Kelliher, along with her sister Jada Kelliher and senior Jaelyn Derlein, a UW-Parkside commit, all had 15 points for DeForest.
Sauk Prairie junior guard McKayla Paukner, who finished with 15 points and a game-high four steals, answered with a driving layup to make it a one-possession game at 57-54 with 42.6 seconds remaining.
Following a Sauk Prairie timeout, Eagles’ junior guard Ava Andres stole the ball in the front court.
But Hartwig had a pull-up jumper in the lane rim out with 18 seconds left, and junior Alexis Atkinson’s follow-up floater in the lane refused to fall.
DeForest sophomore Ally Armstrong snatched the rebound and handed it off to Aspin Kelliher, who threw an outlet pass to the left sideline, and DeForest was able to run off the game’s final seconds.
Jacob Breunig said the Eagles opted not to call a timeout following the Norskies’ final turnover to prevent DeForest from re-setting its defense.
“Our goal was to get a quick two-pointer and take a time out and set up our press and try to get a steal,” Breunig said. “Otherwise, we were going to foul to try to draw the game out a little bit. We had two good looks. We just couldn’t put the ball in the hole. Both were good looks for both girls. But that was the story of our season.”
DeForest coach Jerry Schwenn said the Norskies’ defense made it tough for the Eagles to attempt a 3-pointer in the closing seconds.
“Sometimes you’ve got to let them play out and not allow the other team to set their defense, too,” Schwenn said. “But I liked the way we were moving defensively, overall. Every time they got close, we had an answer.”
Sauk Prairie (16-9) got off to a 1-5 start this season, but finished strong winning nine of its final 11 games.
Meanwhile, DeForest (18-8) advanced to the regional final at Monona Grove last Saturday, where the Norskies lost to the Silver Eagles, 46-45.
Jacob Breunig said he couldn’t have been prouder of Hartwig, who helped lead the Eagles’ volleyball team to a runner-up Division 2 state finish last fall and will play basketball at the University of Evansville next year.
“Maggie played like a senior. She played like someone who was not going to be stopped in her last chance at this,” Breunig said. “I feel bad for her and for the other seniors. We had expectations that our season was going to continue.
“But she had a great year. That will be a lot to replace, going out with 18 points a game and 12 to 13 rebounds a game. She really stepped up her game this year and her leadership. The whole staff is really proud of her as are her teammates.”
Breunig said his only regret was that the Eagles weren’t able to properly recognize Hartwig becoming just the sixth Sauk Prairie girls’ basketball player to surpass 1,000 points.
“I’m glad she got it,” Breunig said. “I wish she had gotten it earlier in the year so we could have had a little formal celebration during the game. But you couldn’t take a time out during regionals for that.”
Hartwig, who scored 20 of the Eagles’ 28 points in the paint, also had three steals.
“The feeling hasn’t sunk in for me yet. I feel like we’re going to have practice on Monday,” Hartwig said. “Another one of my goals as a player was to score 1,000 points. My little freshman self would be proud of me now.”
There were seven lead changes in the first half, but Hartwig sank the first of two free throws in the final minute to send the game into halftime tied at 28-28.
“The seed definitely played out,” Jacob Breunig said. “Both Jerry (Schwenn) and I knew going in it was going to be a battle. I didn’t expect either team to win by 20. It was a game where you knew it was going to come down to the last couple of possessions and there were a couple of possessions here and there that changed the game.”
DeForest had the hotter hand from beyond the arc, sinking 8-of-20 3-point attempts compared to 3-of-12 for Sauk Prairie.
“They shot the lights out in the first half, which was huge, but we stuck with them,” Hartwig said of the Norskies, who shot 40% from 3-point range.
But Paukner said it came down to something the Eagles struggled with at times during the season, taking care of the basketball.
“We just tried to be more aggressive and trap them,” Schwenn said of the Norskies’ second-half surge. “We don’t have a lot of size, so we have to try to get teams to play a little faster. That was effective.”
The Norskies were able to outscore Sauk Prairie, 20-7, on points off turnovers.
“It was turnovers that hurt us,” Jacob Breunig said. “We had a few possessions where we lost what we were doing. We tried to make some passes that weren’t there. It ended up killing us. We’ve got to be better moving forward continually taking care of the basketball.”
Hartwig said while it was disappointing to end the season, she was most proud of the progress the Eagles made after their inauspicious start.
“It was hard how we started the season,” she said. “We lost a lot of seniors from last year and thought it would be a difficult year. But we had the mindset of wanting to work hard in practice every day. A lot of the girls, especially the sophomores have improved a lot and will step up next year. It makes me proud to see how they’ve grown just in the past three months.”
Building for
the future
Hartwig said the Eagles’ future, which includes the return of fellow co-captains Erelyn Apel and Paukner, along with starter and defensive standout Ava Andres looks bright.
“They need to keep doing what they’re doing,” Hartwig said of Apel and Paukner. “They’re great leaders on and off the court. They really helped bring the team together with me this year.”
Apel said replacing Hartwig’s presence in the program will be the Eagles’ biggest challenge facing them in the off-season.
“She has scored half the points in most of our games,” Apel said of Hartwig. “She’s been a major leader on the court in practice and in our games. She’s always been someone we can rely on to help the team on and off the court. It was great to have another year with her and for her to get to 1,000 points.
“Maggie’s shoes are going to be hard to fill. But we’ve got some girls who will come up to try and fill that role. We have to figure out who we are without her on the team anymore and see what we can do with that.”
Jacob Breunig said it will take some time for the hurt to go away after suffering such a heartbreaking setback.
“If everyone comes back, we’ve got a great nucleus,” he said. “We’re still trying to grow into a basketball program. But we have a lot of girls coming back who have a lot of basketball experience on the court in varsity games. Filling Maggie’s role in the post will be a big thing.
“But we have three sophomores in Macee (Gulden) and Gracyn (Meyer) along with Callie Brings, who didn’t play a lot but really grew a lot in practice, who can fill that post role for us next year. We’ll continue to grow as a program and set our goals high, which is something we can do. We could be a tough team.”
Jacob Breunig pointed to the improved scoring output from Paukner as something to build on.
“She stepped up her offensive game this year a ton,” he said. “She does a great job getting to the rim and either finding a way to finish or finding the right girl or drop it down to the post.”
Breunig also liked the progress the Eagles made on defense this season.
“We did a great job of keying on their main scorers,” he said of the Norskies. “For the last month, Ava (Andres) has been playing phenomenal man-to-man defense. It was great knowing if the other team had a guard who could score, we had someone who could shut them down a little bit.”
Feb. 24
WIAA Division 2 regional semifinal
DEFOREST 57,
SAUK PRAIRIE 54
Sauk Prairie ….. 28 26 — 54
DeForest .....…… 28 29 — 57
SAUK PRAIRIE (fg ft-fta pts) — Alexis Atkinson 0 0-0 0, Kennedy Breunig 0 0-0 0, Ava Andres 1 0-0 3, Erelyn Apel 2 0-0 5, Maggie Hartwig 10 8-10 28, Gracyn Meyer 1 0-0 2, McKayla Paukner 7 0-2 15, Macee Gulden 0 1-2 1. Totals 21 9-14 54.
DEFOREST — Jordyn Derlein 0 0-0 0, Maci Bartels 2 0-0 4, Ally Armstrong 0 2-4 2, Jada Kelliher 5 2-8 15, Aspin Kelliher 5 3-4 15, Sophie Eiselt 0 0-0 0, Jaelyn Derlein 5 2-2 15, Rylan Oberg 3 0-0 6. Totals 20 9-18 57.
3-point goals: SP 3 (Andres 1, Apel 1, Paukner 1); D 8 (J. Kelliher 3, A. Kelliher 2, J. Derlein 3). Total fouls: SP 12, D 12.


