The Book Nook
Overcoming fateful secrets
In her moving novel “Unsettled Ground”, Claire Fuller pulls from multiple genres to give us a story of two people ill-equipped to handle the changes headed their way. The reasons they’re unprepared lend a mysterious element to this suspenseful drama that captures the experience of adults dealing with the loss of a parent.
Jeanie and Julius are fifty-one year old twins living with their mother Dot in an isolated area of rural England. A large garden and a few domestic animals provide food for them and while their ancient cottage is falling into ruin, it’s the only home they know.
When Dot dies suddenly the two face more than just the loss of their mother. Although saddened by her death, they see no barriers to continuing living as they had before. It’s what their mother would want them to do and what she’d led them to believe was possible. But fate and the secrets Dot took to her grave unleash a string of harsh realities as they scramble to resolve a quickly deteriorating situation.
Their hastily-created plan is thwarted on several levels and made more difficult because they’re so ill-prepared for dealing with the modern world. Daily survival becomes more difficult and, as expenses mount and resources dwindle, they frantically look for ways to hang onto the life they knew.
Another threat is the changing dynamics between the siblings. There are tense moments as Jeanie anxiously tries to provide a home for a brother who longs for his own independence. Each wants to help the other but are at odds about the details, especially when confronted with so much uncertainty.
As their mother’s past is slowly revealed, the twins wonder who she really was, which sparks introspective questioning of their own identities. It’s all very distressing, particularly when becoming homeless seems increasingly possible. Readers are taken on a roller-coaster ride as problems mount, some quite menacing. There’s a heart-wrenching disaster near the end after which their mother’s final secret is discovered.
This is one of those novels that’s difficult to classify. It’s a quiet contemporary tale that leans towards being a mystery, yet contains drama and frightening moments more characteristic of thrillers. There’s a dark feel that derives partly from information Dot kept from her children and partly from the remote setting. Positive aspects such as the sibling’s devotion to each other help to balance the dimness and bring a welcome buoyancy.
Julius and Jeannie’s differing goals produce tension, particularly with then changing dynamics in their relationship. They don’t always agree but try to do the right thing, which can’t be said of everyone in their life. The nastier characters provide scary moments that will keep the pages turning.
One thing that didn’t feel right is the pacing, particularly near the end which felt hurried as loose ends were resolved. I wasn’t sure if I liked how the large secret is revealed, but others may find the ending smooths over that aspect of the presentation.
What works well is Fuller’s skill at building and maintaining suspense as she adds twists and chilling moments that play on our emotions. As details of Dot’s life and her motives are slowly revealed, opinions of her will likely change. Likewise with Jeanie, whose progression as a character suggests that accepting change is possible.
Much more enjoyable is the language. It’s sparse and wonderfully subdued, enhancing the atmospheric sense while providing insight into the characters’ emotions. The twins know they don’t fit into mainstream society and tell us how they feel about being marginalized. While they live simply, they have complicated, fully-realized thoughts.
Their situation offers a forum for social commentary on Britain’s homelessness and withdrawing from civilization. The latter is a theme the author explored in her fascinating debut novel “Our Endless Numbered Days”, in which a young girl lives in a remote European forest after being told by her survivalist father that the world has ended. Keeping secrets from loved ones, isolated settings and dealing with death seem to feature in her other works.
“Unsettled Ground” has multiple layers and rich descriptions of both physical and emotional aspects, using simple language that invokes a literary experience. The clever title conveys multiple meanings as she gives us troubling glimpses of a changing Britain. This story will appeal to those seeking an introspective tale about reacting to and resisting change in the face of massive loss.
Fuller is an award-winning English author who started writing at the age of 40 and has penned five novels to date. “Unsettled Ground” won the Costa book award in 2021 and her next novel, “The Memory of Animals” is slated for publication in April 2023.


