Schlimgen's stepping down

For five months, Amy Schlimgen went back and forth, contemplating her next move.
The decision process was agonizing, excruciating.
In the end, though, family always comes first. So Schlimgen resigned as Sauk Prairie’s girls volleyball coach last week.
Schlimgen’s daughter, Alia, is just finishing her freshman year at South Dakota State where she plays college volleyball. It pained Amy Schlimgen to miss Alia’s games last season, even though Amy was in the process of leading the Eagles to the WIAA Division 2 state championship match.
So after months of deliberation, the most successful coach in school history stepped down.
“This was an extremely tough decision for me, as I absolutely treasure all of the relationships and memories created throughout my coaching career,” Amy Schlimgen said. “I have been very fortunate, as the good has outweighed the bad. I will have to see how this goes, but I would not be able to witness Alia’s college career again. So I feel that this is the right move.”
Eagles athletic director Josh Boyer said while losing Schlimgen was tough, he fully understood her decision.
“She is making the right decision to go enjoy watching Alia play,” Boyer said. “For us, she brought everything we were hoping for and more. She helped our girls play with such confidence and togetherness on the court.
“Amy had such a consistent and calming presence on the court and the girls fed off that. I am (so) pleased and impressed with how Amy helped elevate the confidence in our girls and believe in themselves and have high standards. We will miss that presence in the gym, but her impact will be felt for years to come.”
Schlimgen steps away as one of the most successful coaches in state history.
Schlimgen spent her first 24 years at Wisconsin Heights, where she built the Vanguards into a state power.
Schlimgen led the Vanguards to a 618-231 record that included 15 conference championships and 17 regional titles. Schlimgen also led Heights to state on four occasions and guided the Vanguards to a WIAA Division 3 state title in 2008.
Schlimgen left Heights in Feb., 2019, though, for the chance to coach Alia at Sauk Prairie. Alia was just a sophomore at the time, and Amy knew getting the chance to coach her could be a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.
“In my head for years, I kind of thought if the door opened, I would take it,” Schlimgen said of the Sauk Prairie opening. “I just feel like I have to.”
What followed was the finest four-year stretch of volleyball in school history.
The Eagles went 28-14 in Schlimgen’s first season and advanced to a regional final. Then, Sauk Prairie really cranked things up.
During the 2020 campaign in which many teams pushed their seasons from the fall to the following spring due to COVID, the Eagles were moved up from Division 2 to Division 1. The increased competition didn't slow Sauk Prairie down, though.
The Eagles had stunning regional wins over Arrowhead and Oconomowoc — the two teams that met for the 2019 state championship. Sauk Prairie then rolled through sectionals and reached the state tournament for the first time since 2009 and just the second time in school history.
Sauk Prairie followed that with a memorable 2021 campaign in which it went 36-3 overall and climbed to No. 1 in the state for much of the season. But the Eagles fell to McFarland in the sectional finals, which was also Alia Schlimgen’s final game with Sauk Prairie.
Amy Schlimgen contemplated stepping down after that 2021 campaign, but didn’t want to leave what she knew would be a gifted group of Eagles last fall. She was right, too, as Sauk Prairie went 44-4 in 2022 and reached the state championship match for the first time in school history.
The Eagles fell to Appleton Xavier, 3-1, in the state title match. And while Schlimgen didn't get the gold ball she craved, her time at Sauk Prairie was certainly memorable.
In Schlimgen’s four years, the Eagles went 129-26 — a whopping .832 winning percentage. Sauk Prairie reached the state tournament twice, reached the state finals once and won three straight regional championships from 2020-2022.
“I am very grateful to the Sauk Prairie school district, the staff, and the coaches and players there for welcoming me with open arms and for the support for the past four years,” Amy Schlimgen said. “I had a blast.
“It is tough to walk away from the current Sauk Prairie volleyball program, which I feel will be very successful for a long time. There are a lot of very talented players in all levels at Sauk Prairie. I wish them the best.”
Schlimgen, a 1987 graduate of Wisconsin Heights, admitted this might not be “good bye.” Instead, it could be “see you later.”
Alia has three years left at South Dakota State. And if anyone was ever born to coach, it’s Amy.
For now, Amy will do some club coaching, as well as private lessons. And down the road, she could certainly find her way back to a high school bench.
“Maybe we’ll just put it on pause for a few years,” she said.


