Around the Block

I don’t know where I first heard the phrase “Dark Night of the Soul,” but given my personal history and education as a philosopher it could have been in any number of the untold books I’ve read in my 49 years. I wouldn’t even know how to begin to calculate how many books I’ve read, in a vain attempt to at least narrow down the possibilities of what book it could have come from. But we have the internet, and I can know more than I need about that phrase in a matter of seconds. And from that simple Wikipedia page, most times I can reconstruct when and where I was—roughly—when I must have read the book or text in question. The internet has improved our personal memories in innumerable, inscrutable, ways. To my delight, the Wikipedia page shed no light for my origin story with this phrase. The context sounded vaguely familiar, and no doubt I would have run across the phrase in my study of Religion as an undergrad. A wisp of an idea existed in my head that the phrase was actually from dear Plato, something poetic he wrote in the Republic, perhaps. That was wrong, but would have been my best guess. A quick skim and check of the endnotes and references showed the entry could be taken as reliable, and I learned that:   “The Dark Night of the Soul (La noche oscura del alma) is a phase of passive purification of the spirit in the mystical development, as described by the 16th-century Spanish mystic and poet St. John of the Cross in his treatise Dark Night (Noche Oscura), a commentary on his poem with the same name.”   And meant:   “The term ‘dark night (of the soul)’ is used as referring to spiritual dryness, the absence of experiencing the presence of God, but also more generally ‘to describe an extremely difficult and painful period in one’s life.’”   So, that was that. Well, why was I searching for my personal history with this phrase? Very simply, I felt like I had a “Dark Night of the Soul” recently, alone with myself in a room—not dissimilar from the philosopher Descartes—a cacophony of celestial thoughts clanging around in my head, a wonderful evening of being alone and taking in the big picture. It was a high-minded night full of the more metaphysical concepts in philosophy—the bigger questions—and I have to admit I normally dislike such pablum. But as I sat alone in my apartment one dark night (very early morning) with my dog as the nearest sentient being, I really leaned in and dug into the biggest questions of philosophy. But as I read the Wikipedia entry, I learned the Dark Night is not a pleasant experience, it would seem, as just a few lines above it was described as “an extremely difficult and painful period in one’s life.” My Dark Night was fun. Let’s make abundantly clear that I am one of those truly bent people who enjoy philosophy to a degree that in their spare time when they can do literally anything else they will choose to think about difficult subjects. I’ve lived both the academic life and out here, and I fervently prefer it out here; my problem is that I want to do what they are doing in there, out here instead. So, I have my occasional Dark Night, named so by me simply because they occur when it is dark out. There is something pregnant in the night that engenders philosophical talk. Even though I’m a philosopher comfortable talking about the Transcendental Faculty of Apperception I’m not above naming a deeply philosophical night something as simple as “Dark Night.” I’m complex. But as I said above, I am not attracted to the musings of the Metaphysicians. I never liked abstract philosophical concepts; in fact I to this day struggle with the more abstract sections of mathematics. I always had a predilection for empiricism: systems of impressions hitting our nerves in our eyeballs and sending literal impulses to the brain; photons impacting and reflecting; solid concrete objects that bounce. If philosophers are describing in concept their ideal world I’m the guy that wants to live in it first. (I would be a very naughty God, sneaking down all the time.) But this night (without a hint of irony the Universe has chosen now, as I type this, to play a song called “This night”) brimmed with gleaming concepts, sharp constellations of ideas, and logical proofs to what seemed like infinity. It ran completely against my philosophical grain and temperament, which in part made it so enjoyable. I was visiting a seldom-seen but well known place in my life, a place I don’t usually choose to spend time. It’s striking how I, at one point, learned what the “Dark Night of the Soul” properly meant, but over time forget and changed it into my own meaning, which was more positive. Even a fool could see that my personal journey away from religion played a part in that—the desert of spiritual absence replaced with a bounty of decidedly atheistic philosophy. Regardless, even though I don’t know where I first heard the phrase, it’s carried meaning and resonance for me throughout my life.