Wisconsin Heights board hears report about District from search firm
As part of their Superintendent search, the Wisconsin Heights School Board heard a Leadership Profile Report from the company they’ve hired to lead the process, Hazard Young Attea (HYA) Associates. The Leadership Profile Report is a basic summary of the district’s qualities that the search firm creates to aid in the search process. Potential candidates will also use the report as a resource to determine if they want to apply.
The 20-page report was presented to the board at their November 13th meeting virtually by the lead of the search team, Mike Richie. It was the product of hours of meetings, with staff, administration, residents, and various other focus groups. Richie said public participation in the listening sessions was limited, but yielded a lot of information, which was presented in the report. The report notes:
“In addition, HYA conducted 11 focus groups. A total of 65 stakeholders, including high school students participated in the focus groups. Eight (8) individuals also replied via email responses to the questions asked. A total 78 individuals participated in either focus groups, individual interviews or email responses.”
The process followed by HYA was simple:
“The same questions were asked during each interview, focus group, and email response and were as follows:
1. What are the strengths of the Wisconsin Heights School District that the next superintendent can build upon?
2. What are the challenges facing the Wisconsin Heights School District that the next superintendent should be aware of, or you would like to see be addressed?
3. What characteristics or traits are you looking for in your new superintendent?
4. Is there anything else you would like to share with us or that we should know about the Wisconsin Heights School District.”
The physical report is mostly the responses to those questions. Richie’s presentation to the board followed suit. This article will focus on the responses to the first three questions.
In HYA’s summary of the District, this stood out:
“A deeply-ingrained trademark of WHSD schools is the personal attention that comes through small class sizes. A typical class size is 15-22, whether in kindergarten, sixth-grade science, or junior year American Literature. Smaller classes are offered to help ensure student success in special areas such as Advanced Placement classes and upper-level foreign languages. As a result of caring educators, committed students, and small class sizes, the district has a record of high levels of academic achievement as demonstrated by above-average standardized test scores.”
Strengths
The report reads:
“Numerous comments were made about Black Earth/Mazomanie/Wisconsin Heights School District being a great place to live. It was mentioned that there are alumni owned businesses in and around the district and they are very supportive of the school district and communities. It is a safe, close-knit community. The geographic location is an asset, it may be a small town but it is surrounded by large cities, great shopping and the airport is close by. The Wisconsin Heights School District is considered to be a more personal school district in southern Wisconsin, with amazing students, staff and community pride with a reputation of success. The district is just the right size and class sizes are small to allow for more personalized learning opportunities.”
And:
“The positive impact of having a small caring school district and community came up in all focus groups.”
Turning to the staff, the report reads:
“Overall the staff/employees really care about all students and know the students and families very well. The staff is passionate about the work they do and how they go about educating all students in the Wisconsin Heights School District. Staff goes above and beyond to help every student. They are connected to all students and want the best for them. The small school feel makes the
Wisconsin Heights School District feel very comfortable and homey, like a family. With being a smaller school district, everyone gets to know the students well. Not just the teachers but all employees are dedicated to the school district. It’s more than just a job, it’s a lifestyle. Team players and all employees will pitch in where needed. Amazing staff, committed and dedicated,
was a repeated theme. It was also a repeated theme that the support staff is phenomenal. An excellent staff supports students on their path to success. Students have numerous opportunities for learning and extracurricular activities. Parents have easy access to teachers. A response that summed up the district was ‘We are small but mighty!’”
Turning to academic achievement, class offerings and programming, the report continues:
“A common theme was that the academic achievement level is high across the district. This statement is backed up by looking at the State Report Card Scores (2021-2022 school year) from the Department of Public Instruction (DPI) website, it shows that the Wisconsin Heights School District has a District score of 77 which Exceeds Expectations. Students have the opportunity to participate in advanced and college classes. FFA, Youth Apprenticeship, Tech Ed and drama were mentioned as being very strong. It was stated that there is a value placed on the trades. Excellent Special Education programming across the district was mentioned as a strength. The district has a strong curriculum with regular updates and a focus on literacy. It was also mentioned that resources are provided, and devoting time for Professional Learning communities is important.
Students are able to play two sports per season if desired and there is a no cut policy. The district is academic and child focused and it was mentioned that administration values learning and growth. Someone summed it up best when they said, ‘continuity and focus is strong, we are not chasing bright shiny objects every year, we are focused on literacy.’”
The single campus was praised across the board by groups. The report notes:
“It was mentioned many times the One Campus concept has been a great benefit in many ways for students, staff parents and community. The district has outstanding facilities now and well into the future. This was a big change for the district, and it can be difficult to let go of old traditions, the community support is strong and this new concept has many advantages. It was mentioned in all focus groups (as well as the student focus group) the One Campus structure will enable the Wisconsin Heights School District to thrive.”
A final strength noted was the GROW scholarship. The report explains:
“The GROW Cooperative is a partnership of four school districts in South Central Wisconsin - Cambridge, Lodi, Sauk Prairie, and Wisconsin Heights. It offers seven (7) $10,000 scholarships to seniors who are student teaching or graduating in the spring semester. Students who are awarded these scholarships will sign an agreement with the GROW Cooperative to apply,
interview, and, if offered, accept a teaching position within one of the GROW districts (Cambridge, Lodi, Sauk Prairie, or Wisconsin Heights). Once hired, the teacher agrees to teach in that district for three (3) years.
With a focus on recruiting and retaining staff the Grow your Own program is a great way to encourage local graduates to come home to teach, work and live. This is a great opportunity and strength for the Wisconsin Heights School District.”
Challenges
Mentioned first in the report—no doubt indicating the seriousness of the issue—is the lack of housing in the district. The report reads:
“It was mentioned in most focus groups that housing within the school district boundaries is limited and expensive. It is very difficult for a new hire to find affordable housing in the district and this forces many new employees to live outside of the Wisconsin Heights School District. Staff would love to live within the district but many do not have this option and this can make it difficult to recruit staff.”
This is complaint will be familiar to readers from the Sauk Prairie are, as that school district faces the exact same issue. The fact of the matter is the entire area, stretching from Wisconsin Heights to the south to Sauk Prairie up north, lacks an adequate supply of housing in general, much less affordable housing.
A second challenge noted was:
“The ability to attract and retain staff was mentioned as a challenge in most focus groups. The Wisconsin Heights School District is forced to compete with larger area schools (Madison, Middleton and Verona were mentioned), in pay and benefits for all staff members. The feeling within the focus groups is that Wisconsin Heights pay and benefits seem to be much lower when compared to other area schools and in a time that the supply of staff members is limited the district needs to better compete to not only attract new staff but also keep existing staff members. There is an even larger gap in pay when looking at the support staff. To complicate the support staff situation even more, there are many non-educational jobs in the surrounding area that pay a higher hourly rate in which any support staff member could choose to leave the district for.”
The use and need of operational referenda were mentioned:
“Community support for the district was listed as a strength, and the district will be forced to pass operational referendums because of the way the school funding works in Wisconsin. In 2019, a 5-year non-recurring operational referendum was passed by a 1,299 yes vote to 583 no. This has allowed the district to exceed the revenue limits by $2.2 million for each year through the 2023-24 school year. A similar referendum will be placed on the ballots in April of 2024 as the 2019 referendum money will expire on June 30, 2024. It will be critical for this new operational referendum to pass so the district can maintain staffing and programming.”
Wisconsin Heights is not alone with this challenge. Area schools from River Valley to Sauk Prairie have had to make use of referenda recently. It is widespread statewide.
Diversity was a concern among those interviewed:
“It was mentioned that the district does serve a diverse population in terms of family socioeconomic and educational backgrounds. However, the district is lacking social cultural awareness and diversity. Individuals stated that the district needs to progress on social cultural awareness and diversity. It was reported that there are currently no staff members of color and the district has lost a lot of students of color because of a lack of diversity. Stakeholders stated they would like to see more diversity within the staff and student body. The district needs to focus on creating a culture that welcomes and is inclusive of families and students from all backgrounds. The district has an opportunity to go in a new direction and not be stuck in the past. It was stated that the district needs to have more than just an understanding of diversity, and need representation, so the district can grow in a new direction, and have more opportunities.”
“Communication, transparency and school culture” were the next group of concerns. The report reads:
“Effective communication and transparency is essential throughout the district. The community must stay informed. Team building will also be important to build upon. It will be a must that the new superintendent builds relationships, is open, honest and transparent. It was also mentioned that the district needs to improve in the area of school culture and staff morale. The district is in need of a new strategic vision. Other items that were mentioned in this area are as follows:
School culture needs to be looked at, use[d] to have strong co-curricular prior to COVID, feel there is a decline in quality of all co-curricular activities.
Unprofessional talk in the HS/MS office talking about students and parents.
Lack of confidentiality in HS/MS office.
Lack of support from high school office.
Limited privacy for medical situations and medications for students.
Favoritism.”
A final concern was school board governance. The report reads:
“It is important that School Board members focus on Board Policy and Board Governance. Board members must also understand the roles and responsibilities of the Board as a whole and the roles and responsibilities of individual Board members. It was mentioned that the Board is made up of good people, are supportive and work hard for the district but sometimes forget perspectives of running a district. The Board has the students’ best interest in mind when making decisions. However, comments were made in the focus groups that the school Board is very athletic focused and have some personal agendas that supersede the good of the district. It was stated that at times the Board struggles with the chain of command by taking phone calls, saying they will take care of it rather than passing it on to the superintendent to deal with and resolve the problem. There seems to be a struggle with just being a policy/governance board. The Board tends to get more involved in the operations of the district and certain programs, especially athletics. The new superintendent will need to build relationships with Board members and help develop the Board as a whole. The new superintendent and Board will want to develop a Board Governance model with a clear vision and expectations to help the Board stay on task.”
Looking for a good Superintendent
The report and presentation by Richie then moved on to the third question posed, “What characteristics or traits are you looking for in your new superintendent?”
The report reads:
“The new leader will be one that is balanced and can advocate for the Wisconsin Heights School District in a challenging climate. The person will be able to articulate a systemic communication plan that is transparent, open, and builds trust through respectful and collaborative relationships within the school and across the community. The new superintendent will also need to be a great
Board facilitator, have Board governance skills, make difficult decisions and must be able to put things in simple terms when explaining things. The ideal candidate will have educational administrative leadership experience, be a strong instructional leader, have experience with school finance and be a people person.”
Further primary characteristics include:
A visionary, inspirational leader
An exceptional communicator and consensus builder
An experienced educational leader
Stakeholder comments ranged from: “Strong on anti-bullying,” “Politically savvy,” “Able to have those difficult conversations,” “Fearless,” “Face of the district,” “Put things in simple terms when explaining things to people,” “Understands small rural school politics,” “Bring back three minute Board recap following Board meetings,” “Students first,” “Community based,” and “Function authentically, leave politics out of the mix.” The report contains nearly two and a half pages of stakeholder comments.
Student feedback
HYA associates interviewed high school students as well. The report notes, “Overall the high school group of students were very friendly but quiet and reserved. It was difficult to get them to open up about their school and school district.”
They listed as strengths:
“The students spoke very highly of the staff and their dedication to helping all students meet their educational needs. In particular, staff was mentioned as welcoming and had a good handle on the mental health needs of the students. The students also stated that they felt safe in school and are well prepared for any type of school emergency/crisis.”
“The students felt that the school has a strong academic program supported by teachers that make students feel comfortable in their classrooms. Students specifically mentioned that they like how classes are taught, and thought that lessons are well presented. Test scores are very high across the district as indicated by the results shown on the DPI State Report Card, where the Wisconsin Heights School District Exceeds Expectations.”
“The students felt it was very easy to reach out to the teachers. Teachers are here to help students in any way possible. Students also felt that it was easy to talk to the teachers and feel they really care about their academic success and their personal interests.”
Students like the daily class schedule and were adamant that this schedule should not change. They feel they perform well academically and this has a positive influence on them in school as a result of a schedule they like.”
“Students like the One Campus learning environment. It is easy for students to transition from one grade level to the next with having all students on one campus. It is easy for parents and students that drive to be able to help transport siblings to and from school. The One Campus structure also allows for older students to help younger students and/or teachers.”
As challenges, the students listed:
“Students feel communication could be better throughout the district and specifically mentioned the high school office. It was said that if a student goes to the office to ask for something and they are too busy to deal with a situation they (office staff) tell you ‘we will find you’ but they never do; or say ‘I will deal with it later’ and never do.”
“The students feel that more custodian help is needed throughout the district for both indoors and
outdoors (grounds). When I asked what they meant by this the students commented just look at the fields outside, they are terrible.”
“Students feel if they speak up they are not listened to. They would like more of a voice in the schools. They believe they have some great ideas and insights on how to make the district better but they are upset that they are not listened to. A few items that were specifically mentioned were as follows:
Could have better food/choices for lunch
More class options would be better (world language was specifically mentioned)
Unable to do what helps us focus in class (example - listening to music)
Need to get more students involved in activities/district offerings
Bussing is either early or late”
“The students felt very strongly that they need more anti-bullying prevention discussions, presentations and awareness. They believe there is bullying going on across the school district and the consequences need to be enforced and be more strict for students that are bullies.”
“The students stated that there are some concerns in the way the overall athletic programs are run. They specifically mentioned that some sports are favored and that heavy emphasis is put on certain sports while others are left in the background. Students also mentioned that the sports programs in general are favored over the other extra-curricular activities and that the sports programs can be improved.”
As for preferred characteristics for their next Superintendent, the high schoolers listed such things as: “Common sense,” “Take the student’s needs into consideration and do something with it,” “Sit down with the students so they can get to know the new superintendent,” “Give reasons why things are done,” “Not favor people or activities,” and “Understanding, can come up with compromises.”
Richie said, overall, despite the low turnout and quiet students, “the results would have been the same,” and “this report overall is very good.”
District Report cards
At the same meeting the board heard about the Department of Instruction’s yearly report card for the district, which was released recently. One change this year is that there is no elementary school data or rating. This is because Wisconsin Heights a new elementary school with the one campus, and report cards require three years of data.
The district overall “Exceeds expectations.” Across the board Wisconsin Heights School District exceeds states averages by good amounts in the report card data. In terms of achievement, Heights tops 88.9 percent of all school districts in Wisconsin. Measured in terms of achievement growth, the district scores higher than 95.8 percent of the school districts in Wisconsin. Target group outcomes again find Heights scoring better than 92.5 percent of the districts in the state. The district’s On-Track to Graduation score is also high, at 87.2, or better than 71.8 percent of the districts in the state.
Middle school scores indicate “meets expectations,” with the middle school topping state averages in all categories.
The high school, like it was last year, is the standout. Wisconsin Heights High School, according to the Department of Instruction, “Significantly Exceeds Expectations.”


