Wisconsin Heights to send $3.2 million operating referendum question to the voters in the spring
The Wisconsin Heights School District wrestled with, among other things, an upcoming $3.2 million operating referendum at their meeting November 27th. In a two-hour meeting with discussion topics ranging from the raw horserace calculus of electability—in this case, the passage of a referendum—to projecting $10 million budgets four years into the future, to an interim Superintendent grimly telling the board “We can’t afford to fail this,” the board ultimately settled on the $3.2 million referendum question for the for the spring election.
The final vote was uneventful and unanimous at their Monday, December 11 meeting. The ballot question will be for $3.2 million each year for four years.
Referenda are not simple creatures. School districts need to predict what their budget needs will be years into the future in order to use the referenda process. The budget needs of any school district, regardless, of size, are not an easy thing to predict, especially when demographics are changing. Budget forecasting, something Wisconsin Heights brought on staff to help with, is a critical part of any referendum.
But you can’t discuss budget forecasting for a school district in Wisconsin without first tackling something called the “revenue limit.”
Mary Blaha, from Baird, a school finance specialist with real-world experience in a school district in northeast Wisconsin, briefed the school board on the basics of the revenue limit and the byzantine laws and regulations behind school district funding in Wisconsin. The revenue limit was put in place by the State Legislature in 1993-94. Among other things, the new law froze district spending at the 1993-94 level. Some districts across the state, tipped off to the new law, spent at higher levels before the freeze in order to lock in higher limits. Wisconsin Heights was a financially responsible district and was therefore frozen at a lower level.
But Heights’ mill rate--$10.21 for 2024--exceeds the state average of $7.18 and is among the higher mill rates in the area. Compare it to Cambridge’s $8.72, Marshall’s $8.40, Belleville’s $7.83, and Waterloo’s $7.58. Notably, New Glarus’ mill rate is $10.48. The higher mill rate is due to, in part, paying off the debt for the single campus, which accounts for $1.40 of the total.
Wisconsin Heights is a “property rich” district. This means property values are higher in the Wisconsin Heights area—although as Interim-Superintendent Craig Gerlach quipped, “no one wants to admit they live in a wealthy area until they’re selling their house.” The way the revenue limit works, the higher the district’s property values—and therefore revenue from local taxes—the less state aid the district gets. It is a “land wealthy” district with few kids, according to Gerlach. Roughly 80 percent of Heights funding comes from local taxes; 20 percent comes from state aid. That lack of state aid is why Heights—property rich as it is—needs to ask for money.
Wisconsin Heights also conservatively spends the money it gets. According to Gerlach, Wisconsin Heights is a low-spending district. It spends the state minimum amount per student, at $11,000. Other, wealthier districts spend as much as $19,000 per student. The state continues to increase the minimum amount a district must spend on students—it was closer to $10,000 last year—and Wisconsin Heights has to adjust accordingly.
There are actually two types of operational referenda that Heights could consider right now. The first is called a “recurring” referenda; the second, a “non-recurring” referenda. Wisconsin Heights has historically successfully passed non-recurring referenda, which entail a vote for a single set amount per year for a number of years. This extra amount sunsets after four or five years. Therefore, non-recurring referenda must be brought back up for vote after they expire.
Conversely, a recurring referendum is a single vote for a revenue increase that lasts indefinitely. Board member Dylan Helmenstine made the argument that these types of referenda are more “accurate” because voters see how the money they voted for goes towards a new or dedicated program, permanently. Gerlach noted that Helmestine’s argument for a recurring referendum made sense—except for the risk. Every expert in the room said unequivocally that recurring referenda are harder to pass with the voters. But Gerlach acknowledged it might be something to try.
“Do it in a year without an interim superintendent,” he said. “We can’t afford to fail this.”
“People are much more comfortable with non-recurring referendum” said Gerlach. “’Tell us what you need right now because forever is a long time,’” Several board members nodded in agreement.
That ended Helmestine’s speculation on a recurring referendum and solidified the board behind what they had successfully done in the past, passing a non-recurring referendum.
Board chair Barb Statz, in commenting that the business experts present looked at the election result possibilities for the referenda with “glass half empty” perspective, did acknowledge the risk of voter fatigue. The district did just ask for $2.2 million per year four years ago . She said that’s always a concern. But Statz also said her “glass half full” perspective of Wisconsin Heights voters was warranted.
Board Member Mike Wager added that ultimately, most voters are simply looking at the final number, and don’t make the effort to look at the budget. He admitted he didn’t look at the district’s budget until he came onto the board. “People don’t care what’s in the number,” Wagner said, referring to the amount asked for. Gerlach agreed. Helmenstine noted those same people are the ones who don’t remember the last referendum, also.
The final tally for the referendum is $3.2 million over four years. Early predictions of the projected mill rate—“guaranteed to change”—are $10.53, a 22 cent increase over 2024.
The board also discussed the specific amount--$3.2 million—and whether they wanted to adjust it at all. A determining factor in that $3.2 million are things like the continuation of 4K, and adding new positions, particularly in special education. Gerlach said it was likely Wisconsin heights special education program will need to increase staff in the next four years.
The $3.2 million figure builds in flexibility for the district. In the first two years of the referendum payout, the district will realize a surplus. That’s balanced out by the last two years resulting in a deficit. All told, there will be about $550,000 in surplus in referendum funds over four years. That’s the flexibility Gerlach spoke of.
Gerlach also addressed the district’s fund balance, which he noted was large. A large fund balance allows Wisconsin Heights to have flexibility, because in an emergency, it can draw upon that fund balance to pay for unexpected expenses, or even staffing that will be funded in the future by another referendum. At the same time, he said it would be best for Wisconsin Heights to transfer some of the extra funds from the fund balance into a specially designed fund for repairs and other things. “The fund balance is not a savings account,” reminded Gerlach.
Reflecting on the past four months of work on the referendum and projected budget, Gerlach said “We’ve created a roadmap” for the next administration. “I think people will say we’re being [financially] responsible.”
Also at the December 11th meeting the school board voted to increase the support staff base salary by $1 per hour, retroactively starting at the beginning of the school year. “We need to continue to be competitive with our salaries,” said Gerlach. Last year support staff received a $1 increase as well, but depending on where they were in terms of seniority, some got less than a dollar. “We really need to take a look at support staff [salaries],” said Gerlach.
He noted that Wisconsin heights’ neighboring district were paying more, and it was becoming harder and harder to attract and retain staff. “We’ll look at increase [support staff salaries] again next year,” said Gerlach. “We’d like to do $3 [an hour], but we just can’t. He said it will take a “bit of time” for the pay increase to hit paychecks; he expects it to arrive in January 2024.
At the November 27th meeting, Gerlach introduced and discussed a bill that came a surprise to the district from Performance Services, who were in charge of the single campus project. The $583,000 bill was for something called retainage, which Gerlach was unfamiliar with, in this context. It’s a common practice written into the contract for services where Wisconsin Heights held back 15 percent of every bill. The $583,000 was the balance owed of those retainages.
As for the new Superintendent search, interviews are this week and final interviews will occur in the new year.
There is an election for two board seats in the spring: Cindy Buethin and Matt Crowe.
The districts solar project is “alive and well,” said Gerlach. It had been “understandably” delayed over the summer and work will begin in the next few weeks, weather permitting.


