The Book Nook
Can this secret be forgiven?
In “The Museum of Failures” by Thrity Umrigar, readers will find a moving story of a man who discovers a shocking skeleton in his family’s closet and his emotional journey.
Growing up, Remy Wadia had a difficult relationship with his mother and couldn’t wait to escape her distant demeanor. Once he was old enough, his father encouraged Remy to travel to America, which he adopted as his second home. He reluctantly returned to India to attend his beloved father’s funeral, and made arrangements for others to help his mother before leaving. Following that he kept contact with her to a minimum although this caused feelings of guilt.
Years later, Remy knows he should visit his aging mother before it’s too late, but dreads the thought. He’s a successful advertising executive who is married to a wonderful woman named Kathy. They have a happy life that would be perfect if they could only have children. When offered a chance to adopt an infant in India, their impulse is to leave immediately, but Kathy’s commitments make that impossible. They decide Remy will represent them both in the adoption process and keep her updated by phone.
Once he arrives in Bombay, he arrives at his mother’s home to discover she’s now in a hospital after a long illness. Guilty that he wasn’t even aware he rushes to her side, where he finds her despondent and resigned to death. She even refuses to speak with anyone and Remy swears to help her recover, regardless of how long it will take.
While staying in his mother’s home he discovers a photo that demands explanation. What he learns shakes the foundation of everything he believed growing up. He’s overwhelmed by emotions of shock, anger and grief. Unexpected problems from other areas only add to his stress.
As he works through the problems he’s forced to reexamine his childhood and relationships in a new light. His world has tilted and he’s unsure of where the truth lies. But in piecing everything and meeting challenges, he receives unexpected gifts.
This engrossing tale looks at how distance, both psychological and physical can create damage that’s difficult to overcome. The protagonist provides entry into the immigrant experience with its constant baggage of feeling like a stranger. For Remy, it’s a double-whammy because he feels that way in both his native and adopted countries. His sense of estrangement is exacerbated by information he was never meant to uncover.
I had a few moments where the narrative felt stuffy, but those were more than balanced by the positive aspects. The distinct and elegant writing style was a joy to read in what is Umrigar’s ninth novel. Her moving account brings us along on a bumpy and affecting ride. Remy is someone that we can relate to in his search for answers. His hope of finding what he needs from life kept my interest.
As in previous works, the author’s characters offer interesting perspectives, imbuing them with believable humanity. She does a deep dive into family relationships, exploring a range of feelings and the impact of keeping secrets. I enjoyed her use of Kathy and Remy’s connection to depict the comfort derived from loved ones, particularly during stressful times. I also liked how Remy dealt with the various relationships, especially the difficult ones.
The writing style is occasionally irregular, but Umrigar is a talented storyteller who is unafraid of addressing tough topics such as bias, aging parents and familial secrets. The narrative is both plot- and character-driven, and is complex yet easy to follow.
Remy’s transformation from anger to understanding was handled well enough to be believable. Although he’s been an adult for a long time, his trip offers an opportunity to see he hadn’t fully matured. The open and somewhat surprising ending felt slightly contrived, but was satisfying. It’s obvious that the author is able to provide characterizations that show she understands people’s need to love and be loved, writing about it convincingly. Remy’s path of discovery show the power of empathy and forgiveness.
Published in 2023, this book is available in several formats from your library and the audiobook version received sound reviews. If you like good character development or a heart-wrenching storyline with an uplifting ending, this is a decent read.


