The Book Nook
Popular cozy mystery
When “The Maid” by Nita Prose was published in 2022 it won awards and made several bestseller and book club lists. Perhaps that’s due to the odd yet lovable protagonist, or because Prose provided creative twists to the classic whodunit format in this tale of deception. Another possibility is that the readers found something not often associated with murder mysteries – a sweet and uplifting read.
The plot hinges on Molly Gray, who is generally content with her life but is currently battling loneliness. She has an obsession that meshes well with her job as a maid at a high-end hotel, although some of her coworkers find their duties a tedious slog. Not Molly - she loves the Regency Grand Hotel and is enthusiastic about returning each room to a state of perfection.
She’s finding life is hard after losing a loved one, and things will take a turn for the worse after she discovers the body of a prominent guest while cleaning his room. Just before fainting from the shock she glimpses someone leaving the dead man’s room. It’s obvious he was murdered, and everyone has a theory about who did it.
Due to Molly’s job, she’s all but invisible most of the time, but her discovery of the body instantly elevates her status. The police descend with multiple questions, and normally maids who have found bodies are quickly questioned and dismissed. Molly’s happy to cooperate, but on her own terms, which eventually leads to her being a suspect in the case.
A major factor is that she doesn’t do well in social situations and frequently misinterprets other’s intentions, leading to misunderstandings and problems. In this case, her peculiarities and misplaced trust could prove to be her downfall as the investigation progresses. She has good reasons for withholding information, but doing so puts her on a fast track to disaster and danger. The one person she could always count on is unable to help, but she’s determined to find the real murderer.
The plot is divulged via alternating current and past events as it examines what it’s like to be both the same as yet different from others. Being different make her the target for snarky nicknames, duplicity and victimization. She’s portrayed as a sympathetic person whose gullibility causes her pain and costs her more than she can afford to lose.
A few things felt a bit off to me, such as disclosures that didn’t gel with events and actions or the handling of some of the cast. I also found it easy to guess the murderer fairly early. None of this was enough to justify giving up on the book, especially considering it was a fairly intricate debut novel. I did find much to enjoy, such as straightforward prose, good quotes and the complexity and evolution of the main character.
Also enjoyable were the twists were fun and how the action geared up in the final third. Molly’s moments of realization and her reaction to being wronged made me laugh, as did other humorous scenes. There was a decently-crafted plot that breathed new life into the locked-room murder setting, especially if you don’t take that term too literally. Another plus was the heartwarming angle of others coming to Molly’s aid.
Color featured heavily in people’s names and in descriptions, allowing us to see the world through her eyes and making it easy to imagine the settings. Use of the first-person narrative made the protagonist seem more accessible. She may be imperfect and odd, but her kind heart and caring nature made it easy to cheer for her. Other motifs included invisibility, which was explored via Molly’s job and her eccentricities.
Nita Prose is a Canadian author and book editor who started by writing for magazines. “The Maid” was published in over forty countries, resulting in over a million sales worldwide. The film rights were quickly sold and rumor has it Florence Pugh has been cast as the lead. Because so few books actually make it to the screen, we’ll have to wait and see with this one.
The author has penned two sequels to her “Molly the Maid” series: “The Mystery Guest “and “The Mistletoe Mystery”, published in 2023 and 2024 respectively. She’s also been a ghost writer for several celebrity memoirs.
This is a good pick for those who dislike mysteries that are too creepy or have unreliable narrators. In spite of some implausible aspects, the story has good pacing and entertainment value. Overall, it’s a charming tale of growth with decent depth and an ending as neat and tidy as Molly’s rooms.


