Book Nook
Powerful story of a winner
Three timelines, five voices and a ton of research work to create an immersive historical fiction spanning nearly two centuries. “Horse” by Geraldine Brooks is a compelling narrative featuring a Thoroughbred who became a racing legend. She draws from history to look at past and present exploitation of people and animals via subjects such as slavery, horse-racing and art.
The book starts in 2019 when Theo, a Black art-history student, finds an old painting on his neighbor’s curb. He’s unaware that Jess is a scientist who just discovered the skeleton of a famous equine tucked away in a forgotten part of the Smithsonian museum. Their paths will eventually cross on a shared exploration of the past.
We’re transported back to the 1850s where we meet Jarret Lewis, an enslaved Black teen who witnessed the birth of a Thoroughbred. His father is a skilled trainer who willingly shares his knowledge with the boy, who is put in charge of the foal’s care. The animal is dubbed Lexington and shared an amazing bond with Jarret. One person fascinated by the animal-human connection is Thomas J. Scott, a real-life equine artist. Scott’s diary broadens our understanding of the special relationship between Jarret and Lexington.
Next we move forward one hundred years to meet Martha Jackson. She’s an art gallery owner whose past was greatly influenced by her mother’s love of riding. That loved was passed down to her and one steed in particular stands out in her memory. One day she’s asked to appraise a painting and is amazed not only by the quality and value of the artwork, but also by its personal connection to her own family.
From this point on, the stories progress together. Jess and Theo investigate the mysterious ties between the skeleton and painting, learning about the important role of Blacks in early American horse-racing and the racism that led to their exclusion. They’ll also discover the circumstances that led to the end of Lexington’s career, with details provided by Jarret’s narration.
While the connection between Jarret and Lexington is strong and life-long, it will be tested by greed, deception and cruelty. Many of Jarret’s experiences provide danger and excitement as he works to protect himself and Lexington, who by now has become a crucial part of his life. This is particularly true during the Civil War when many lives hung in the balance at a time when the country was in chaos.
As the lives of Jarret and his contemporaries unfold, it’s contrasted against those of Jess and Theo. Brooks uses examples of ill-treatment to view bigotry with a critical eye. Despite living in different times and having opposing personalities, Theo and Jarret faced identical problems. The author handily demonstrates that while slavery was abolished, oppression lives on. One reader noted slaves working to buy their own freedom was similar to present-day people striving to pay off their student loans.
The same analysis is applied to modern-day race-horses, who continue to be treated as expendable commodities. Two of the characters highlight how little progress has been made in 175 years towards eradicating racial bias and mistreatment of animals. Readers should be prepared for tragedy, trauma and prejudice along with powerful writing and thought-provoking approaches in this skillfully-told tale.
The author did extensive research to provide facts that are informative and disquieting. While labeled a historical fiction, the narrative is securely embedded in truth. Brooks brings an acute depth to her characters, which made them more real to me, regardless of whether they were fictional or real. There were a few things I questioned about the narrative, such as the number of coincidences and Jackson Pollock subplot’s role to the narrative, but none caused me to stop reading. The narrative held my interest and I enjoyed her wonderful prose and how she intertwined complicated, multi-generational plots in a way that was simultaneously educational and entertaining.
After its publication, the novel quickly became a New York Times bestseller and won two prizes in 2023: the Indie Book Awards for Fiction and the Aisfield-Wolf Book Award.
Discovering previously unknown facts helped bring multiple aspects of history to life for me in this absorbing story. I learned that Lexington’s abilities made him the most successful sire of his time, and that many of his offspring went on to become notable winners. I also didn’t know that early races weren’t the quick sprints we see today, but exhausting four-mile events.
This far-reaching account of obsession and injustice provides insight into the motivations of the characters and shows us that bigotry continues to be a source of human suffering. Brooks uses her superb writing skills to deliver a cutting moral message that reminds us that time does not heal all wounds.


