The Book Nook
New look at an old way
American author Kristin Hannah says her latest novel was inspired by the sacrifices made by those in the military. “The Women” is a dramatic look at the Viet Nam war and provides a female perspective in an unflinching look at a polarizing time in American history.
Readers follow the 20-year journey of Frankie McGrath, a White woman who recently graduated from nursing school. The story starts in 1966 and her brother has just enlisted in the Navy. At his going-away party, she hears words that surprise and later inspire her to follow him. Her lack of experience cause most of the military branches to reject her, but she persists and soon is sent to Vietnam.
Her initial reactions and sheltered upbringing show how ill-prepared she is, but others help her overcome her fear and deal with deplorable conditions. She moves from a scared unqualified novice to a professional who can work amid chaos.
The first half of the book focuses on her wartime experiences and includes danger, gory hospital scenes and heart-pounding action. Friendships and romance make life more bearable, but there’s also heartbreaking loss. Once her tours are done she’s ready to return home, but while she knows many Americans are indifferent to the war she’s unprepared for the hostility her uniform provokes.
This is only one of the many battles she’ll fight after returning to civilian life. She has trouble controlling her emotions and is frequently angry. Even more frustrating is being denied the help she needs because no one believes women were sent to Vietnam. Feeling misunderstood and hated, she seeks refuge in all the wrong places and is soon in a constant battle with her demons. And she’s losing. The question is whether she can find the strength to fight for her life.
As in many of Hannah’s novels, the protagonist has a long list of tragedies thrown at her. Some of the events felt contrived and the ending was easy to guess. I would have preferred more details about the secondary characters and less drama, particularly with the romance angle.
Those complaints were mostly overridden by the highlights, such as a compelling story and well-researched details. For centuries, people knew war could negatively affect the human psyche, but there was little in the way of effective treatment. It wasn’t until Frankie’s time that the term Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) was coined and efforts made to treat it. Its obvious research was done to provide insight into the disorder, the war, and public opinion.
To show how difficult it was for women who served in Viet Nam, Hannah uses women’s viewpoints to deliver her messages. She interviewed nurses who served in Vietnam to provide authenticity and to foster her theme of friendships. She also talked with Red Cross workers and a pilot to lend authenticity to her characters. This helped to make the story more accessible and give readers a better understanding of what service people faced.
Other topics include sacrifice, patriotism and the lasting impact on those involved in conflict. The author is a good storyteller who knows how to imbue her fiction with hope in spite of tough topics. I enjoyed the exposure to facts I’d been unaware of and learning more about this chapter in our country’s history. Today many of us thank soldiers for their service, but those who served in Vietnam received little gratitude. In an interview, the writer noted how horrible that felt and that she hoped to effect change. Frankie’s story is a small picture in a larger tapestry of historical events that delve deeply into emotional issues. She also finds parallels between those in combat situations and medical workers who were on the front lines of COVID, thanking the latter in the book’s dedication.
There’s a wide range of content warnings for this book and listing them all would lead to spoilers, but I will say that those who avoid triggers for depression, alcohol and other drug abuse may want to pass on this book. For those who prefer listening to stories, I heard that the audio version had excellent narration by Julia Whelan.
Hannah has written over two dozen novels and a few have been optioned for films, including this one. Many of them fall into the historical or romance genres and “The Women” is a coming-of-age novel that can claim both categories. This dramatic tale is an engaging and edifying historical fiction with good imagery. It’s a book the author has wanted to write for a long time, and reading her notes at the end of the book will give readers an appreciation for her work. It also serves as a reminder that we can learn from the past.


