The Book Nook

Real and imagined sea adventures   Following are two suggested reads that share a common theme of water.  One is a compelling non-fiction about an 18th century shipwreck while the other is about a strange adventure on a mysterious vessel.  Please note this review contains spoilers. The first is “The Wager” by David Grann, who wrote the popular book “Killers of the Flower Moon”.  In 1740 few could dispute that Spain ruled the high seas, a fact that sparked competition among other countries eager to profit from exploration.  The title refers to an actual ship that was part of a small fleet the British hoped to use as a secret weapon in the war against Spain.  The central character is David Cheap, a seaman who longs to captain his own ship.  After an odd series of events he’s puts him in command of the Wager, a small British war ship sent to capture a silver-laden galleon known as “the prize of all the oceans”.  While trying to navigate a deadly passage near Patagonia, horrendous high seas forced everyone aboard to abandoned ship after they hit a rock.  The shipwrecked sailors found themselves marooned on an inhospitable island with dwindling food supplies. The odds of long-term survival were slim and Cheap’s command of the men deteriorated for a variety of reasons.  A power struggle ensued, splitting the crew into two factions.  Survival remained everyone’s top priority, but was second only to the need to return to England and defend their actions.  That’s because each group accused the other of mutiny – an offense punishable by hanging. Thus began a race not only to find enough sustenance to survive, but to get off the island and find a way home.  They faced nearly impossible conditions and risked captivity as they tried to stay alive, with appalling actions and losses. What started as a grand quest ended in a military court to decide each survivor’s fate, a task made more difficult by conflicting accusations of deceit and treachery.  It’s impossible to know exactly what happened and this gripping read attempts to give answers to an old mystery. This well-researched chronicle is based on first-hand accounts in the form of journals, letters, logbooks and court-martial evidence.  The author doesn’t favor one party over another, instead presenting the facts in a direct manner as he speculates on the subject of truth.  Threaded into the story are his comments on how slavery and colonialism were justified to advance a nation’s goals and their effect on affected people and countries. You don’t have to be a history buff to enjoy this well-written tale of deceivers and heroes.  As the author explores human nature, he provides a glimpse into the grim and deadly conditions sailors endured, with illustrations and maps helping to complete the picture.  Content warnings include cannibalism, death, racism, slavery, starvation and violence. “Challenger Deep” by Neal Shusterman brings us forward a few hundred years, but the waters here are much murkier.  My plot description is intentionally brief to avoid ruining reader’s enjoyment of discovery. The protagonist is Calvin Bosch – a 14-year-old with a rich fantasy life.  He’s a sharp high school student whose behavior is becoming strange enough to attract notice.   To please his parents, he agrees to sign up for an after-school activity and uses the time to explore his thoughts.  Thoughts that lead him to an odd ship crewed by outlandish people led by an even stranger captain who demands total loyalty.  As his confusion deepens, Caden struggles with conflicting impressions as he’s drawn deeper into a disquieting voyage filled with abnormal dangers.  As we follow his journey we get a sense of what Caden’s experiencing and how that feels. At first I found this a difficult read due to the profound and uncompromising thoughts that at first seemed totally random.  But the fascinating story pulled me in quickly and it didn’t take long to determine the premise.  Readers who needs clear-cut, linear stories will find clarification in the next paragraph, but to avoid the book’s major spoiler, I’d suggest skipping skip to the last paragraph. Shusterman bases the story partly on the experiences of his son, who battles schizophrenia and who drew the book’s illustrations.  Together, they describe his struggle to distinguish reality from fantasy and his recovery in the hopes of making this misunderstood illness easier to understand.  It also delves into the insight of how frightening it is for both the sufferer and their family.  The author handles a complex condition with sensitivity to give a thoughtful sense of the disorientation people with the condition experience.  His notes at the end was also helpful and informative. I enjoyed the connections made between the ship and the protagonist’s personal experiences.  It was refreshing to read a book about a young person’s mental health issues that didn’t require a love interest to foment a cure.  Also gratifying were the messages about mental illness and emotional acceptance. This character-driven story won the 2015 National Book Award for Young People’s literature and, while intended for teens and young adults, can be enjoyed by older audiences.  Those who like plumbing the depths of a challenged mind will find a deeply personal story told in short chapters and heartfelt prose.   The August 29th issue of the Star News incorrectly titled that week’s Book Nook. It should have read: “A new look at an old war.” The Star New regrets the error.