Letters to the Editor

By Jeff Seering    Secrecy to the bitter end. That’s the best way to describe the process that ended with the Sauk County board voting 18-13 to sell the county’s nursing home, the Sauk County Health Care  Center, at a special meeting this month. The process toward the sale started last November when board chair Tim McCumber proposed a 2024 budget amendment.The sale of the nursing home was not included on the meeting’s agenda, which meant the public had no clue such an idea was to be considered. Eventually the county’s attorney ruled the motion out of order, as it was a major policy decision. After that ruling, McCumber told the board it would be on the agenda for the Dec. 18 board meeting, which it was. The resolution, which was passed then, included the following two conditions required of a sale: “The potential buyer shall demonstrate a history of 5-star care ratings in the senior health care industry. The potential buyer shall retain existing staff subject to job performance.” Medicare’s star system for rating nursing homes, based on regular inspections and citation history, is similar to the ABCDF grade system used by schools. Five star is much above average, 4-star is above average, 3-star is average, 2-star is below average and 1-star is much below average.  The five-star condition was interpreted my most to mean that the county would seek a private buyer that has a history of high quality of care similar to that provided by the county nursing home, which had a 5-star rating at that time. That was the county’s official public position concerning the sale up until Sept. 10, 2024 when the board voted to approve the a sale to Aria, a business that operates several nursing homes. In the motion that passed this month, all of the conditions in the December resolution were superseded by the sale contracts approved that evening.  Reasons put forth for selling the nursing home included the fact the county is spending an average  $2 million a year to subsidize the nursing home operation at a time when private nursing homes are operating without subsidies, operating a county nursing home is not mandated, the building is not being fully utilized, and that the county could better redirect those dollars to add services to the Aging and Disabilities Resource Center (ADRC) and Veterans Service Office.  Those opposing the sale cited the fact the Health Care Center has a history of top-quality care that is an asset to the county, that privatization would likely lead to cost cutting such as lower staffing that could reduce care levels, and likely lead to a loss of staff due to cuts in benefit and pay.  The current Health Care Center was built in Reedsburg in 2009, replacing a huge rural four story building that was oversized for the number of residents, had building issues due to its age and didn’t meet modern accessibility guidelines such as the width of resident room doors. All other discussion concerning the sale by the board was done out of public view in closed sessions held on March 28 and July 22 and another closed session that preceded the public discussion of the sale on Sept. 10. Before the March meeting, where McCumber announced publicly after the closed session that three firms had submitted acceptable proposals and the county had chosen one to negotiate with, the Property Committee send out a request for proposals for a broker to assist the county with the sale and the board approved hiring the broker. The request for proposals included information on the conditions set in December resolution. The broker sent out a sales brochure to potential buyers with an asking price of $8.5 million but it did not list any of the conditions set in December. The information sent out by the broker was almost certainly reviewed by someone in county leadership. My guess is that the broker told those county leaders that if the conditions set in the December resolution were followed, the county would get no interest from prospective buyers. Only about 10 percent of nursing homes in Wisconsin have five-star care ratings.  In mid-June, Aria Healthcare of Sauk County LLC filed incorporation papers with the state, listing the Clark Street, Reedsburg address of the Health Care Center as its business address. That was the first indication that Aria, which actually would use two different Aria LLC names in its final purchase, was the buyer. In the next few weeks word of Aria being the buyer started to leak out though the county officially would not acknowledge that. Through an Open Records request I filed, I learned the county’s insurance replacement value on the nursing home is over $19 million. An information sheet the county published earlier this year placed the value of the nursing home property and assets at $6,484,700.  No one in county government gave an explanation why the county chose to deal with just one potential buyer. However selling a nursing home is a detailed and expensive process, involving working out how to continue operating smoothly and serving residences through the change of ownership. That’s the likely reason. Though the board chose to deal with just one buyer, it did not release the buyer’s name. I filed an Open Records request following the March meeting seeking the name of the buyer, which was denied by the county’s attorney. His rationale is that negotiations could break down and a second party might be contacted, which could hurt the county’s negotiating position.  On July 22 the board held its second closed session concerning the sale, with the agenda listing the possibility of the board acting on a sale that evening. The board’s only action out of closed session was to say negotiations with the still unnamed buyer would continue.  Two days later reporter John Gittings of the Baraboo News Republic reported that Aria has filed the LLC with the state in June, the first reported public naming of the buyer. On the Medicare website concerning nursing home ratings, three Aria nursing homes are listed in Wisconsin, all in north Milwaukee suburbs. Two had one-star ratings and one had a two-star rating. Those ratings translate to much below average and below average.  I filed an Open Meetings complaint against the county board, arguing that if the county was dealing with a firm with one and two-star ratings, it was changing the policy of seeking a five-star buyer that was set at the December resolution. My complaint was rejected by the Sauk County District. Attorney’s office, noting that officially the name was still secret and also said that office conferred with the county board’s attorney about my complaint. I found out since Sept. 10 the DA’s office was right in rejecting my complaint. With negotiations over, the reason for keeping secret the closed session discussions of the board was moot. I asked a county board member if the star ratings of buyers were discussed in the closed sessions on March 28 and July 22 and was told they had not. Was that deliberate by county leaders? That’s a question only they can answer.  On Sept. 10 the board held another special meeting concerning the Health Care Center, which included another closed session. As at the July 22 meeting, several people spoke in public comment, with the vast majority opposing the sale, citing the low care ratings of Aria as well as the rumored low selling price for the nursing home. Some read negative Google reviews of Aria Wisconsin nursing homes. The agenda for the meeting again did not list the name of the buyer nor a sale price. The first official indication from the county that Aria would be the buyer was when shortly before going into closed session, McCumber announced an Aria representative would be among non-board members allowed to attend the closed session. After the two-hour closed session, only 45 minutes of public discussion of the sale followed by the board since December, McCumber’s motion to approve sales contract to Aria passed 18-13. Ironically, and perhaps typically, the actual sale price of $5.1 million was not mentioned during that discussion though it was announced in a county news release the following day. Much of the board debate was similar to what was said at the December meeting that started the process. A couple board members said that though 1,300 people signed a petition opposing the sale, there were 64,000 other people in the county to be considered and money saved by selling the Health Care Center could provide services to them while the private sector met the nursing home need. During the closed session, the Aria representative made a persuasive presentation, explaining Aria’s star ratings and promising continued high-quality care at the nursing home. From what one board member stated, the rep explained that the nursing homes had low ratings when Aria purchased them and it takes two or three years to raise the ratings up, which would happen through low citation rates and several good inspection reports. No one from the general public heard that presentation, which board member Valerie McAuliffe said convinced her to switch from voting no to yes for the sale.  During the open discussion, even some board members who supported the sale admitted the process involved in leading to the sale was flawed. Some said some of the public speakers that night gave wrong information.  Supervisor Smooth Detter said directly to the people from the public who stuck around after the two-hour close session ended, “I really wish you could have all been here for the meeting,” referring to the closed session presentation by Aria, suggesting incorrect information could have been avoided.  That was pretty ironic since there was nothing that prevented the county board from hearing the Aria presentation in open session except the board itself. The board could have invited the Aria representative to speak during the open session and put it on the agenda. But county leaders chose not to do so. Six board members did vote against the motion to go into closed session. By having it in closed session, the board denied Aria the opportunity to publicly defend its health care record against criticism leveled against the business since late July when its identity as a buyer was publicly known, despite the county’s refusal to admit it.  Video of the open session parts of the Sept. 10 meeting can be viewed on the Sauk County website, clicking on Government and then the Meeting videos on Granicus tab.  The normal practice for actions by the county board involving expenditures, sales and purchases is to include a fiscal note that outlines the expected finical impact of a resolution. That didn’t happen with the Sept. 10 meeting. The $5.1 million sale price was not revealed until the following day nor has a tentative closing date been announced. There remain several questions concerning the sale of the county nursing home including: Why did the county board accept a sale figure that is $3.4 million less than its original asking price and also less than what it cost to build the current Health Care Center in 2009? What will the final net financial gain be from the sale? It will be less than $5.1 million as three more years of bond payments are due from the 2009 building project. Then there will be unused vacation pay owed to employees at the time of the closing and the need to pay a bookkeeper to take care of bills and revenues that will come in after the closing date. The county stated on an information sheet it gave out last December that it has averaged $2 million in taxpayer subsidies to operate the nursing home, a number contested by sale opponents. During discussions public discussions by the board, it was suggested that those funds would be better spent through adding services to agencies such as the Aging and Disabilities Resource Center and Veterans Service office and benefit a greater number of people than the nursing home serves. However any services added obviously are not mandated or they would be offered now. What specific new services are being proposed?  Why during open board discussions on the sale in November, December and September did no board members ever mention the possibility of cutting the property tax levy if it saves money by closing the Health Care Center? One of the rationales for selling the Health Care Center is that operating a nursing home is a non-mandated county effort. Will the county board be considering cutting other non-mandated parts of its operations such as the parks department, UW-Baraboo, the Great Sauk Trail, economic development efforts, the Spring Green County Forest and the Tri-County Airport near Spring Green?