The Book Nook
Halloween--Part 1: Magic, Mystery and Adventure
This column kicks off a two-part series in honor of our spookiest holiday, with a total of four book reviews. Today’s books are two enchanting cozy fantasies which make for great escapist fiction with more fun than frights. If you prefer more chilling reads, the next Book Nook column will feature two mildly scary novels plus a list for those who crave more gore and horror.
In Rebecca Thorne’s 2022 novel, “Can’t Spell Treason Without Tea” Reyna is a woman with a difficult job and a dangerous boss. She’s a bodyguard for Queen Tilaine – a cold-hearted ruler who exudes less warmth than an iceberg and demands absolute loyalty. While thwarting an assassin attempt, Reyna discovers the Queen is indifferent to whether her faithful guard lives or dies. Furious, she flees the palace and her former life, not caring about the consequences.
For years she and Kianthe, her secret girlfriend, have dreamed of leaving the realm and opening a bookstore and tea shop. Kianthe is the most powerful mage and someone the Queen wants very much within her control. Reyna’s disappearance will be seen as desertion punishable by death, and Kianthe’s absence will further enrage the ruler, but neither care anymore about the queen’s vengeance and flee the realm.
They find a small town and meet the locals, giving false names to hide their true identity in the hopes of making a smooth transition into their new life. Some parts go well, but there will also be problems from outlaws and dragon attacks. And the Queen’s spies are everywhere, eager to find the pair.
In spite of the dangers, they’re not written in a way to put you on the edge of your seat. Sure, there are cranky beasts and a murderous sociopath on the throne, but they serve more as background for this gentle adventure that reads like a cozy romantasy. There are elements of mystery and a blossoming romance that’s more sweet than spicy.
Those who enjoy a small town feel with heart-warming characters and scene descriptions will find much to like. It’s a place where neighbors help each other and are willing to give newcomers a chance. The couple’s relationship is refreshing in the way they work through their differences and how they support each other.
With a lively and welcoming cast, it’s a nice addition to the relatively new genre of cozy fantasy. The ending was done in a way that felt like a sequel was in the works. Sure enough, a quick search showed that “A Pirate’s Life for Tea” is now available.
Those who loved “Legends and Lattes” by Travis Baldree will experience déjà vu with this novel. Thorne says she’d written her plotline before cozy fantasy became popular, and that reading Baldree’s story was eye-opening. It let her discover self-publishing’s impact on the industry and that large chain bookstores do indeed sell indie books. That was all the encouragement Thorne needed to flesh out her story. She says her books will always feature diverse and LGBTQIA+ characters and, whenever possible, dragons.
Contemporary cozy, witchy read
Moving from mages to witches, the next offering is “The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches” by Sangu Mandanna. Also published in 2022, this one features a woman who answers an unusual ad.
As the story begins, Mika Moon is in the company of other witches, an uncommon occurrence. That’s because their self-appointed leader firmly believes they should avoid each other’s company to avoid detection. Mika reluctantly complies while yearning for a less isolated way to living without raising suspicions about her magical talents. She can’t help flirting with danger by posting videos “pretending” to be a witch and her latest generates a vague message asking for her help as a tutor. Answering the request brings her to an old country manor dubbed “Nowhere House”, where she finds an odd collection of people, including a handsome man who is anything but welcoming.
Thus begins Mika’s journey into emotional territory that’s foreign to her and worries about getting too attached to her students. Mika can feel everyone’s anxiety about an upcoming visit from someone who dislikes the residents – someone powerful enough to upend all their lives. When a freak accident exposes a huge lie, Mika’s feelings overwhelm her and she finds herself alone – again.
This slow-burn romance is filled with charm, humor and whimsy, with quirky characters providing a solid framework and nice plot twists. Each is well-developed and realistic, not in spite of but because of their eccentricities. Most have painful pasts that prevent them from stating their feelings, which they show in other ways. Mika’s longing for family and stability are palpable as she tries to win over the one most resistant to her presence.
The plot is decent and easy to follow, with seemingly random pieces nicely pulled together in a well-handled and pleasing ending. The found family aspect is a warm-hearted look at love and connecting with others. Mandanna has written a few novels with characters who discover they’re stronger than they thought, lending an authenticity feel to how they resolve problems.
The popularity of cozies has led to a boom of mixed genre products that comingles fantasy with other genres such as romance, adventure and mystery, among others. Not all are great reads, but Mandanna’s novel lives up to the hype and boosts her reputation as a good storyteller.
In the next review we’ll look at Neil Gaiman’s “The Graveyard Book” and a popular debut by Tamsyn Muir called “Gideon the Ninth”, along with suggestions for even scarier reads.


