Geiger Counter
True of all things
We used to watch Orson Welles movies together. Mostly “Chimes at Midnight,” in which a big, fat, jolly Welles channels Shakespeare’s John Falstaff, guzzling wine while munching on juicy roasted capons and philosophical dialogue. I loved the wordplay, the lyricality, the crackling of the old black and white film. The bombast and moments of brooding shadow contrasted with mirth and laughter. My daughter was too young to protest, too small to demand that we watch Taylor Swift instead, and she liked the movement and sound while understanding almost none of it. And, I like to think, she enjoyed the simple fact that we were together.
Welles was one of the rare American celebrities whose intellect and artistic vision actually merited the fame he garnered. He is famous for sending the country into a panic with a “War of the Worlds” radio broadcast so believable everyone thought it was real. He made “Citizen Kane,” probably the greatest American film ever. And he changed the way people all over the world would tell stories for hundreds, if not thousands of years to come.
And of course, because we live in the year 2024, he is mostly remembered today by younger generations as the guy who got absolutely hammered while filming commercials for Paul Masson champagne, or as the fellow who argued about etymology and diction with the directors of a commercial for frozen peas. If Citizen Kane is the greatest thing ever put to film, those outtakes are a very close second.
“I take directions from one person under protest, but from two, I won’t sit still for it,” he says to the directors of the frozen peas ad.
Another clip of Welles is from an interview with a French journalist. In it, Welles speaks in flawless French, yet it’s amazing how recognizable his baritone remains, even in a different language. He says: “I don’t know how you feel about it, but I detest the word, ‘Professional.’ Every actor who goes: ‘I’m professional. I’m a pro.’ What is this? Is there a sadder word? Because the word ‘Amateur’ comes from the word ‘Amour.’ You must do things out of love. Otherwise, it’s stupid.”
The things we do, we should do for love. We should not be horses spurred by hate or pride or mercenary obligation. We should do things simply as an expression of our adoration for the relentless beauty and splendor of the worlds and lives perpetually unfolding in front of us. We should do things because we love to do them.
Otherwise, as someone much smarter than me once said, it’s stupid.
Hermann Hesse reminded us that: “This day will never come again and anyone who fails to eat and drink and taste and smell it will never have it offered to him again in all eternity. The sun will never shine as it does today.”
Yet under today’s shining sun, most people whittle away the hours doing things for every other reason. They do things because of a sense of commitment. Or out of guilt, or convention, or boredom.
But, as the theologian and mystic Thomas Merton once wrote, a tree is known by its fruits, so something created with love will be lovely, while a seed planted as a chore will flower into something markedly lesser.
This year, my daughter no longer watches Orson Welles movies with me. She is 10. She is in fifth grade, and I have no language to explain to her that most of the things that seem important right now – social standing, grades, pop culture fads, politics – will eventually reveal themselves to be profoundly forgettable and unimportant. The vast majority of today’s trends will look preposterous in hindsight, nearly as silly as the Skids, Pumps, Snap Bracelets and Michael Dukakises and Dan Quayles of my childhood. Every once in a while, some genius will transcend time and place – a Shakespeare, an Orson Welles, a Peter the Great. But most will ultimately be either ridiculous or forgotten. And in time, even the ridiculous and ingenious will be forgotten, too.
But it’s best not to worry about that right now. The gaping maw of oblivion might not be quite as interesting as we suspect, anyway. Perhaps the road we travel to death is the thing that matters, and perhaps it’s best if we don’t worry too much about our destination.
We live in what is sometimes called the “Information Age.” But even if we do have a lot of information at our fingertips, this is certainly not the Wisdom Age. Knowing a lot of things and knowing what to do with the things you know are two totally different skills. Probably because even the least wise of us can now search for any tidbit of information on our phones, we mistakenly think that knowing a lot of things is important. We yearn to be professional knowers of things. And on our way to this daily grind of a profession, we forget to do things out of love.
There is another interview with Orson Welles, this one in English but with the same remarkable cadence. In it, the interviewer asks him: “What I’d like to know is where did you get the confidence from to make the film [Citizen Kane] with such…”
“Ignorance. Ignorance. Sheer ignorance,” Welles replies. “You know, there’s no confidence to equal it. It’s only when you know something about a profession, I think, that you’re timid, or careful or…”
“How does this ignorance show itself?” the interviewer asks.
“I thought you could do anything with a camera that the eye could do or the imagination could do. And if you come up from the bottom in the film business, you’re taught all the things that the cameraman doesn’t want to attempt for fear he will be criticized for having failed,” he says. “And in this case I had a cameraman who didn’t care if he was criticized if he failed, and I didn’t know that there were things you couldn’t do, so anything I could think up in my dreams, I attempted to photograph.”
“You got away with enormous technical advances, didn’t you?”
“Simply by not knowing that they were impossible. Or theoretically impossible. And of course, again, I had a great advantage, not only in the real genius of my cameraman, but in the fact that he, like all great people, I think, who are masters of a craft, told me right at the outset that there was nothing about camerawork that I couldn’t learn in half a day, that any intelligent person couldn’t learn in half a day. And he was right.”
“It’s true of an awful lot of things, isn’t it?”
“Of all things.”


