The Book Nook

To thine own self be true   What do Charlie Chaplin, Walt Whitman and Sigmund Freud have in common?  They join others who believe William Shakespeare did not create the marvelous plays and sonnets attributed to him.  Jodi Picoult runs with that theme in her latest novel, “By Any Other Name”, a lively, well-thought out story with dual intertwining timelines about ambition, determination and identity. The plot features two women – one fictional and one real, separated by centuries and united in their love of writing.  Melina Green is a young playwright in contemporary New York whose insecurities prevent her from living an authentic life, particularly after a scathing incident deeply scars her spirit.  She’s frustrated that her work is ignored and leans on her best friend Andre, who not only lets her vent but tries to help.  When she’s finally given a chance, it’s due to a case of mistaken identity. Green agonizes over whether she should correct the error or stay silent.  If she speaks up, she could be rejected again, and she’s desperate to see her play performed on stage.  But keeping quiet makes her untrue to herself and she agonizes over what to do.  The result is a tense comedy of errors that brings both anxiety and joy, along with a kaleidoscope of emotions fueled by the bitterness of betrayal. The other protagonist is Emilia Bassano, a real historical figure who lived in England during Shakespeare’s time.  After being orphaned at a young age, her life depended on the goodwill of others.  Gratitude turned to rage when, in her teens, she was sold to an older man. Being someone’s property forced her to be adaptive, and while she couldn’t summon feelings of love for a man 43 years her senior, she was thankful for his kindness.  He understood and encouraged her interest in writing, taking her to London’s theaters.  She met people such as the now-famous playwrights Christopher Marlowe and William Shakespeare, but what intrigued and enthralled her was the seeing the affect written words had on the audience. This further fueled her passion for writing, but restrictions banned women from being published, however great their talent.  You may see where this is leading, and Picoult weaves a plausible story of how Bassano could have penned works credited to Shakespeare. The narrative has three distinct voices – the perspective of both female protagonists and from a script Melina is writing about Emilia’s life.  All three are crucial to this meticulously-researched work that weds a dramatic historical story to a modern tale filled that includes humor and romance.  The timelines dance together flawlessly and multi-dimensional characters are brought to life, particularly Emilia. The story felt slightly long, perhaps because Picoult is introducing us to an unknown historical figure and wants to give details showing who she was and how she lived.  Bassano’s character is outspoken and determined, while Melina’s serves to show how slowly attitudes towards women in the arts have changed.  The upsides definitely won me over as the author is a talented storyteller who writes beautifully.  The relationships felt authentic and readers noted appreciation for her handling of Jewish culture. I could feel her passion for the subject and later learned that it came from personal experience.  She and her daughter, Samantha van Leer have encountered barriers in getting their plays in front of audiences and that frustration was ably communicated via the two central characters. Themes include discrimination, classism and misogyny.   The intricacy of ethnic heritage is explored, as is the importance of advocating for yourself.  This story is a departure from the author’s usual work, although she generally provides variety from one book to the next.  It’s her first attempt at historical fiction, and her dedication to accuracy gives readers a good feel for the times.  Shakespeare enthusiasts will love the references cleverly worked into the novel, although such knowledge isn’t needed to enjoy it.  There were also robust endnotes that heightened my reading experience. The Shakespeare authorship question was raised over a century ago, with some claiming the bard’s humble prohibited him from writing such brilliant and enduring works.  Many names have been proposed as candidates, and while Picoult isn’t the first to suggest Bassano’s name, she makes a plausible case.  Bassano is the first known English female to publish a substantial book of poetry.  In it she paid homage to women she hoped would become patrons of her work.  She was also a renowned musician in the queen’s court and educated well beyond most women of her time. While the debate may never end, Picoult uses her protagonists to encourage us to be true to ourselves and our dreams.  In an interview, she commented on gender discrimination in the arts by saying “A lot has changed in 400 years…but a lot more hasn’t.”   As always, she gives us food for thought in this immersive and bright historical fiction.