The Book Nook

Inventive premises   Here are two suggested reads about women coping with intense problems and untenable situations.  Both are exquisitely-written novels that invite us to look at life and humanity in different ways.   Dystopian Hope and Angst Fans of Margaret Atwood’s acclaimed novel, “The Handmaid’s Tale” will find similarities in a disquieting and brilliant study, “I Who Have Never Known Men” by Jacqueline Harpman.  Published in 1995, this short, futuristic tale asks many questions without providing answers.  That said, I found reading the introduction helpful before diving into a powerful story that offers introspective opportunities for readers and characters alike. The heartbreaking narrative is told by an unnamed protagonist at an unknown point in the future.  She’s the youngest of many women living in a crowded, windowless environment.  Food, water and discipline are delivered by silent sentinels who thwart any attempts to engage them.  Their impassive muteness adds to the eerie atmosphere and the women’s unease, who constantly wonder about their circumstances and their future. No one can tell the girl the date or where they are living.  Each woman recalls a vague global disaster, but not how they reached their present location.  Details about the catastrophe and the aftermath are hazy, although they can remember their previous life.  As they reminisce about the past, the girl struggles to understand.  She lacks context for the items they describe or experience that make concepts such as home or family relatable to her. Because of her youth she’s granted extra leeway by some, but not all of the women and is sometimes at odds with them.  She attempts to engage the guards, partly to avoid insanity caused by the mind-numbing boredom.  When an unforeseen calamity occurs, monotony is forgotten as survival becomes everyone’s new goal. The only constant element in the characters’ new life is uncertainty.  Readers are left as clueless as the character, who must navigate an alien environment.  Harpman’s use of details and evocative scenes create a potent narrative that invites contemplation on multiple levels. Solitude is an almost oppressive presence as the novel see-saws between moments of despair and hopefulness, but we’re never tricked into believing that will change.   Instead, we’re invited to think about humankind’s chances for survival once everything familiar is removed.  The lack of information may bother some, but serves to shift focus away from the unknowns and onto the women’s journey. There are no chapter breaks, which may mirror how difficult marking the passage of time was for the women.  You’ll find good character studies here, along with themes of loneliness and hope.  Content alerts include suicide and euthanasia.  Some may find this slim book bleak and haunting, and those seeking tidy endings will be disappointed.  However, it holds great appeal if you enjoy speculative fiction or a skillfully written exploration of humanism.   Clever Alternative History   Kelly Barnhill takes a more humorous approach in her 2022 novel, “When Women Were Dragons”.  The outlandish premise offers much to consider in this vivid and lively historical novel.  Please note this review contains spoilers. The setting is 1950s America when suddenly several hundred thousand women around the world spontaneously transformed into dragons, sprouting scales and wings before taking to the skies.  The event was dubbed “dragoning”, and officials responded with drastic damage control tactics.  They barred any scientific or journalistic investigations, forbade mentioning it in school curriculums and banned any discussions of the event.  Those who witnessed the bizarre incident were told it never happened.  End of story. Most adults accepted the censorship, but not children.  When four-year-old Alex wondered why her Aunt Marla transformed but her mother didn’t, she was shushed and firmly told she never had an Aunt Marla.  While confused by this denial of reality, she was distracted by a larger problem.  Her beloved cousin Beatrice had lost her mother and Alex felt a fierce need to protect the orphaned girl. Alex struggled with the consequences of the changes and finding truth among so many lies.  One parent became over-protective while the other made unrealistic demands.  Worse yet was Beatrice’s obsession with dragons, which Alex became conditioned to hide.  This caused anxiety that continually gnawed at her, although she would find potential allies to smooth her path.  But finding the truth was challenging, and when some of the dragons return, society was again turned upside-down.  The result would change Alex’s life and her ability to speak the truth in the book’s bittersweet ending. There was some uneven language and message repetition along with unanswered questions, such as what happened to the dragons after their departure.  Although it was a global event, there was a missed opportunity by not including other cultures and by limiting the role of men in this daring story.  Barnhill includes multiple formats which added interest to the plot, yet lacked style differentiation.  Alex’s vignettes about what she’s seen moves the story along in a very fulfilling way. Also enjoyable were the author’s creative use of metaphors and allegory to explore long-standing societal issues as she nimbly captured Alex’s frustration at irrational restrictions and the reframing of reality.  Ironic prose and atmospheric descriptions painted an unusual coming-of-age story with themes of loss, misogyny and anger.  There’s good use of one character to represent freedom. Barnhill is an award-winning American author of children’s literature, fantasy and science fiction.  This is her first novel aimed at adults, which she says was inspired by a true sexual assault case muddled by victim blaming.  The result is a complex and lively speculative story that honors women and their right to be heard, with a nice nod to librarians regarding choice and information suppression. Tongue-in-cheek humor is used well as issues of patriarchy and hypocrisy are addressed in this inventive satire.  The timely, heartwarming story is sometimes painful as Barnhill underscores the problem of forcing people into roles we want them to play.  Her gripping book helps us see that if we expect others to accept us for who we are, we should do the same for them.