The Book Nook

A Disturbing  Disappearance   In 2016 a charismatic American mysteriously vanished while traveling in India.  The events surrounding his disappearance prompted a journalist to investigate, resulting in a non-fiction that blends elements of biography and true crime. In his book “Lost in the Valley of Death – A Story of Obsession and Danger in the Himalayas”, Harley Rustad tells the story of Justin Alexander Shetler, an adventurous man searching for a higher level of spirituality.  He details Shetler’s life and presents readers with two mysteries that will remain unsolved:  what was Shetler’s motivation for choosing his lifestyle and what really happened to him? Shetler was raised in a Florida household that encourage spiritual exploration and was interested in nature from a very young age.  After his parents divorced he relocated to the western U.S. with his mother.  There he attended a wilderness awareness school where he learned survival skills and amazed others with his ability to survive with few resources. Also notable was Shetler’s outgoing personality, which helped him succeed in whatever career he chose.  He had a short stint as a wilderness teacher and became the lead singer in a successful rock band.  Working as a marketer for a tech start-up made him independently wealthy, but he would later become disenchanted with Western materialism and his own accomplishments. There were two things he seemed to enjoy – studying martial arts and pushing himself physically. Combining those elements with his love for travel would lead him to exotic and often remote places.  Increasingly, his travels centered on a search for what he called a more authentic life.  His monetary security allowed him to assume a nomadic lifestyle in his search for an indefinable something. He enjoyed sharing his travels via social media, frequently blogging about his philosophies, trips and dreams.  This earned him almost legendary status among his followers and many were impressed by how severely he challenged himself physically or with self-imposed restrictions that limited his access to food or civilization.  His growing scorn for owning objects grew to the point where he gave away nearly all his belongings and set off for India. One of the Instagram personality’s last public communications was in the summer of 2016.  Shetler, now 35, posted a selfie with a note that he had been living in caves in the Himalaya Mountains.  He was last seen traveling to a hallowed site in India’s Parval Valley called Mantalai Lake in the company of a holy man, who returned without Shetler.  The man later gave conflicting reports about Shetler’s actions and whereabouts. Those concerned about the travel influencer’s welfare started asking questions.  Was his sudden silence due to a conscious decision he made, had he been injured, or was foul play involved?  Some felt Shetler was simply fulfilling a wish he’d expressed to drop off the grid.  Some wondered if he’d fallen victim to the social media trap of obtaining validation by taking unnecessary risks.  Others thought he might have suffered an accident or became a victim of crime. No definitive answer was found, and Shetler became another statistic in an area that’s been dubbed the “Backpacker Bermuda Triangle”.  In the last 35 years, dozens of backpackers have vanished without a trace.  The terrain itself poses dangers, as one misstep could lead to a life-threatening injury or perilous plunge off a mountain.  There are also drug runners and growing operations that pose threats to anyone who inadvertently stumble into their area.  Another risk is the thieves who kill others for their possessions. Those concerned about Shetler’s welfare raised alarms, with some friends and family members traveling to India to plead with authorities to investigate.  The results were inconclusive and unsatisfying.  Rustad also visited India in an attempt to determine Shetler’s fate.  He located witnesses, reviewed police reports, interviewed those who knew Justin and searched through social media posts.  Again, a decisive answer was as elusive as Shetler’s searches for self-enlightenment. Rustad suggests that Shetler based his trip, and possibly his adult life on a model from Joseph Campbell’s book “A Hero’s Journey”.  It’s a story about man who embarks on a quest for adventure and returns transformed.  Rustad’s experience as a solo traveler to India brings a personal feel to readers as he follows Shetler’s story and chronicles other backpackers who have also disappeared. He explains the country’s attraction to those seeking enlightenment and the psychological effect of “India Syndrome”, a phenomena in which travelers experience a break-down during their visit.  The number is so high that foreign embassies have hired specialists to help the affected. Some readers took issue with the author withholding crucial information until near the end of the book, claiming it eroded trust that the biographer reveal investigative details at the time they’re discovered.  Whether it was done purposefully to heighten suspense or build empathy for Shetler is unknown.  It is clear that Rustad researched many aspects of his subject’s life and presented it in a strong and clear narrative.  The only unanswered question is what really happened. Rustad is a Canadian journalist and magazine editor who authored another novel called “Big Lonely Doug: The Story of One of Canada’s Last Great Trees”.