The Sauk County Gardener
Choosing the
Right Seed
“Don’t judge each day by the harvest you reap but by the seed you plant.”
--Robert Louis Stevenson
If you’ve been in garden supply stores or perusing various seed catalogs lately, you may have noticed the different types of seeds available. I’m not talking about all the different varieties of beets or tomatoes. I mean organic, heirloom, and hybrid seeds. There are pros and cons to all three kinds – organic, heirloom, and hybrid; and if there are certain things you are looking for in your garden, it’s important to know the difference.
Heirloom seeds have been passed down from one generation (for about 50 years or more) to another without any crossbreeding. They are typically pollinated naturally by air, animals, and various pollinators; this is known as open-pollinated. It also means if you plant heirloom seeds from the tomato your great grandpa planted and enjoyed many years ago, you should be able to harvest a tomato that tastes and grows the same. There are a number of pros to growing heirloom seed. Heirloom seeds help preserve genetic diversity by maintaining a wide range of genetic traits within a plant species. Most heirlooms have unique flavors and appearance; these can be lost during hybridization. If you save heirloom seeds can be saved from one year to the next, you will get the same plant year after year. You can also help save money by saving heirloom seeds. This all sounds great, but there are also some cons to heirloom seeds. Many heirlooms have lower yields than their hybrid cousins. Heirlooms are typically more susceptible to pests and diseases. Some heirlooms are not well-suited to the climate they have been moved to and grown. That tomato your grandpa grew down South may not be well-suited for our Wisconsin summers.
The next consideration is organic seeds. Organic seed production avoids the use of synthetic chemicals and fertilizers which can protect ground water and beneficial insects. Organics are typically focused on heirlooms to help promote and maintain genetic diversity. However, it’s important to note that heirloom seeds are not always organic. Organic seeds are grown using organic farming techniques, such as composting. Composting can help improve soil quality over time if done properly. Organic seeds also align with sustainable farming methods. As with heirlooms, there is a list of cons to organic seeds. Organics are typically more expensive because they have stricter production standards and generally lower seed yields. Typically, there are fewer varieties to choose from and the ones you find may have lower crop yields.
Hybrids are designed to offer the best of a seed’s offerings. Many are developed to offer increased crop yields and/or larger fruits and vegetables. Some are designed to be disease resistant. Once again, think of tomatoes – the true diva in our gardens. There are so many diseases that affect tomatoes that many people grow hybrids just so they can get a good tomato crop. Another benefit of hybrids is the uniformity of the plants or their fruits’ size, maturity time, and overall appearance. Some hybrids have been developed to grow well in different climates and growing conditions. Of course, there are cons to hybrids as well. For one, you can’t save the seeds from one year to the next. For example, I love to grow ‘Sunsugar’ tomatoes. They are little golden yellow, delicious bites of tomato yumminess that is resistant to cracking. However, they are hybrids so if I save their seeds, I will not be able to grow the exact sample plant and expect to get the same kind of fruit. Cost is another consideration. A lot of money goes into developing hybrids and those developers have to recoup their costs. They will be more expensive than your saved heirloom seeds. Another consideration is that you may lose some of the flavor if the plant was developed primarily for great yield or improved disease-resistance. Finally, hybrids can reduce the genetic diversity of our gardens.
There are pros and cons to all of these types of seeds. Do your research, figure out what is most important to you, and plant the type(s) of seeds that are best for your garden.
This week’s article is written by Jeannie Manis, a Wisconsin Certified Sauk County Master Gardener Volunteer. If you have any gardening questions, please contact the Extension Sauk County by emailing to trripp@wisc.edu or calling the University of Wisconsin Madison Division of Extension Sauk County office at 608-355-3250.


