A View of the Valley

by Linda Schwanke In a recent (August 7) issue of the Home News, Dan Ouimet wrote a Letter to the Editor about a comment River Valley School Board member Jeff Maier made at the board’s June meeting about the cost of the referendum for people. Jeff said, “I know a lot of them are saying, well, it’s going to raise my taxes too much. It really is not a significant tax increase.” Jeff is a good school board and community member from everything I’ve seen. It surprised me that he apparently doesn’t understand how many of us in the school district are barely making ends meet. I talked briefly to Loren Glasbrenner, district administrator, about it and asked if the board members are informed of how many kids are economically disadvantaged (about 24 percent) and he said yes, they are. That doesn’t even account for how many of us without kids are economically challenged, presumably the reason the school referendum questions lost. So why the disconnect? I think it’s a communication issue and all of us need to do better. The school set up a survey after the referendum failed in April. The first question was defeated by a margin of 1,757 (54 percent) to 1,498 (46 percent). The second question failed by a wider margin, with 2,153 voters (66 percent) voting no, and 1,090 (34 percent) voting yes.  The questions, in case you’ve forgotten, were: Question 1: 46% YES, 54% NO “Shall the River Valley School District, Sauk, Iowa, Richland and Dane Counties, Wisconsin be authorized to issue pursuant to Chapter 67 of the Wisconsin Statutes, general obligation bonds in an amount not to exceed $19,500,000 for the public purpose of paying the cost of a school building and facility improvement project consisting of: renovations at the Elementary, Middle and High Schools; construction of safe and secure entrances/offices at the Elementary and Middle Schools; construction of an addition for a replacement gymnasium at the Middle School, to create a single River Valley School District campus; building infrastructure, site improvements, ADA accessibility updates and other associated work; and acquisition of furnishings, fixtures and equipment?” Question 2: 34% YES, 66% NO “Shall the River Valley School District, Sauk, Iowa, Richland and Dane Counties, Wisconsin be authorized to issue pursuant to Chapter 67 of the Wisconsin Statutes, general obligation bonds in an amount not to exceed $14,500,000 for the public purpose of paying the cost of a school building project at the High School consisting of: construction of a performing arts center addition and a safe and secure entrance; remodeling and ADA compliance updates, including to the performing arts commons and stage areas; site improvements and other associated work; and acquisition of furnishings, fixtures and equipment?” The survey respondents, the majority of whom voted yes, left comments about why they voted the way they did. I think it’s worth digging into here to see what was said. It’s available on the district website (rvschools.org under the school board tab, July meeting 11 board meeting packets, item 3) but this is probably easier. If you voted “no” on Question 1, please indicate the possible reason(s) Answer choices: It would raise tax dollars too much; this would create a financial burden. 66.07% The items requested for ADA compliance were unnecessary. 13.10% The items requested for safety & security were unnecessary. 8.93% The items requested for facility maintenance need to be embedded in the annual budget. 45.83% I don’t think you need additional gymnasium space. 58.93% I don’t think a single campus is necessary (Plain should remain as a school building). 45.24% I don’t think a single campus is necessary (we should not transition students to the high school). 44.64% I don’t agree with the design plan. 25.60% Comments, excluding the multiple comments that simply said voted yes: More money needs to go for tech classes before I vote yes on anything. This should have been a question of items that are needed not just wants. I would have then voted for it. Because #2 made me angry so i voted no on both voted yes, but felt conflicted about additional gym space Music Theater addition isn’t needed is why I mainly voted NO. Spending seems to be out of control. Instead of a fancy stadium perhaps that money should have been used for upgrades. We continue to have ongoing operating referendums which continue to raise taxes. This needs to be addressed/figured out before adding additional cost to tax payers. From my understanding, there is money available to make some of the “necessary” upgrades (ADA) without needing to have had this referendum. The ask was too big. It was never going to pass and now it jeopardizes the ops referendum coming up All for safety and security for our schools I don’t want to put more money in an old building. Build a new HS move MS to the current HS Poor appropriation of previously apportioned funds. Dollar amount seemed really high don’t feel funding was used well in the past, prioritizing football field over ADA is irresponsible Put all items line by line w/ dollar amount and then prioritize what tax payer are willing to pay for If safety and security are truly a concern, and children and staff have been unsafe, you should have already upgraded the existing entrances in the 4 existing buildings to meet desired safety and security measures. The items requested for ADA compliance and safety & security should never have been lumped in with other desires the way they were in the April referendum. The school board and administration only put our students more at risk by mixing in desires that tax payers will not support. You must be more trasparent and thoughful to this community and the safety of our children. Let us vote on safety and security measures aside from the fluff. Families were not comfortable with 7th grade at the high school. District is too top heavy. A reality check is needed. We put big salaries for athletics ahead if education for the few kids with the right last name that might get to play. Some upgrades I agreed with but not a majority If the question was strictly for school security and nothing else I would have voted yes. School security is and always will be priority 1. I believe that the focus should be on that before you start asking for money on all these other things you want. Price of inflation is tough enough for most families and with asking for that kind of money up front you will be pushing families to leave the district. You have to remember, we are not Dane county. We are a bunch of small communities. I understand the cost of remolding changes but I would have liked to see a more detailed remolding plan with estimated costs. I would have also liked to see the plans for additional things that would have been addressed if funding allowed. Based on the research of our demographics and likelihood of attracting new students, it seemed unnecessary to spend money for district that is and will be shrinking. The large amount for tech Ed that was not specific Internal budgeting could be reviewed 30% of kids are at grade level, I would rather see this number rise before requesting tax money. Education is more important than extra a facility. There is government funding for security measures as well as ADA compliance. Grade 3 &4 should NOT be with 5&6; grades 7&8 should NOT be at high school level; way different mindset and maturity level as well as too much age gap. There should NOT be “family bathroom” in a high school that locks. That is asking for trouble. Gender neutral bathrooms I don’t think additional gym space is necessary when we had many more students in the past and did just fine with the dimensions of the gym and the space hen I agree with the safety updates but wasn’t the secure building entrances included in the last referendum and just never done. The rest of the stuff was unnecssary There was just a big ask not long ago when lone rock and arena Elementary schools were closed, followed by the stadium field which was unnecessary. There was going to be a lot of money spent to move kids to buildings not designed for their age group. There is no amount of remodeling that would make the middle and high school appropriate for the age groups being proposed to move. Need more documentation on needs, pictures, reports Do some fund raising and look for donations If you are going to have a referendum, you need to sell it, hire someone that can do this. We heard very little on the projects. A couple of meetings just didn’t cut it.no real answers at the meetings. Not a very good sell job at the meeting I voted yes. I do think a lot of people felt blindsided by the proposed ELC closure after Arena and Lone Rock, especially as the wording of the question felt like it was shoehorned in there so people wouldn’t notice. Everybody is feeling a financial squeeze so bad timing to have anything but absolute needs. The language provided on the RV Forward said a secure HS entrance, but it already has one. Decline in student enrollment - it is well known that many rural schools are losing numbers. based on current bond rates this is not a good time to borrow this amount of money. bad bang for the buck I’ve worked inside the RVMS and vehemently disagree that “it has good structure”. There is too much bundled together. Enrollment is declining and we shouldn’t have issues fitting people. I will never vote YES for any school referendum. Unnecessary spending by all levels of government have put everyone in a fiscal pinch. Can barely afford fuel and groceries for a family of 5. 3 years ago we were able to have extra money available but not any longer. Don’t put money into your MS. You have an elementary that is ready to be built on to. Your HS is able to take on your 7th and 8th grade students. Make the HS a 7-12, make your Elementary a K-6, stop putting money into the oldest building on your campus. Think Long Term with your declining enrollment. I voted yes (question 4) but the survey would not advance me to question 6 unless responded to question 5. I voted yes to the school renovations and school safety but I do not like the closing of the 5/22/2024 10:31 AM school or the new grade levels in each school. I’d like to see a K-8 building so that in the next 20 years we aren’t needing to consolidate again. Our kids deserve amazing facilities, not a partially remodeled building from the 60s. Community members from Plain, Arena, and Lone Rock had their Elementary schools shut down. Should we shut Spring Green’s down too and create a K-8 facility to solve this problem for the long term instead of the short term? Enrollment has declined 15% per decade the last two decades. More space is not required to host the smallest class sizes in the last 25 years. There are ADA compliant locker rooms in the addition that was completed in 1999/2000 that are for “athlete only” use and it is appalling that completely able-bodied athletes couldn’t make due with the downstairs locker room (or share locker rooms with everyone). I don’t have space for more but over the next weeks and maybe months, I want to share the rest with you. There is plenty of time between now and 2025 when some kind of referendum question(s) is asked for us to figure out how to improve communication between the school board and all the people who live in the Valley. I truly believe we can figure out how to get our kids what they need if we work together.  The Home News has early deadlines for Labor Day, as always. All deadlines move up one business day making the deadline for news Friday, August 30, at 9 a.m. for the Wednesday, September 4, issue.  Stay in touch. My phone number is (608) 574-3159 – call or text me anytime. You can also email me at homenewseditor@fingerpub.com  Visit our website at homenewsrv.com The news deadline is now 9 a.m. on Mondays.  Get in touch with Gwen for sports or features at homenewssports@fingerpub.com If you need a display ad, Dave Pronold can be reached at homenewssales@fingerpub.com or by calling him on his cell at (608) 588-4777. The deadline for display advertising for the Buyer’s Guide is 1 p.m. Wednesday. The deadline for display ads for the Home News only is 10 a.m. Friday. Classified rates are $13 for the first 10 words, then 30¢ per word for each additional word. Call (608) 767-3655 or email classifieds@fingerpub.com The classified ad deadline for the Buyer’s Guide and Home News is noon on Thursday. Email legal notices to legals@fingerpub.com The deadline is 12 noon on Fridays.  Call the FingerPub central office at (608) 767-3655 for subscriptions, past issues. and all other information Monday through Thursday from 8:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. Closed Fridays. Write to us at P.O. Box 286, Black Earth WI 53515.