The Book Nook
Twisty political intrigue
In the late 1990s and early 2000s Brad Meltzer became a new voice for political conspiracy fans. For each book he focused on a different branch of the government, such as the White House or Supreme Court. In his 2011 novel, “The Inner Circle” he spotlights an agency of the government that gets little press – the National Archives and Records Administration.
The main character is Beecher White, who works at the archives in Washington, D.C. He loves that he’s privy to the hidden stories of our country’s history – stories that are largely unknown to the public. The young man gets a thrill working with the documents that provide context to our country’s past. His job has been keeping him afloat since the breakup with his fiancé, which left him unmoored and despondent. He’s fortunate to have an ally at work keeping an eye out for him.
Life seems less dismal when a childhood acquaintance unexpectedly appears. Clementine Kaye has sought him out because she needs his help in locating information about a person. Beecher is more than happy to help, for reasons readers will discover as the plot unfolds.
Eager to impress his guest, Beecher sneaks her into a special room where Presidents visit to review top-secret material. It’s not a wise decision given the high level of security protocols necessary to protect the POTUS, but Beecher neatly rationalizes his actions. They’re thrilled after they accidentally discover an artifact that was obviously meant to stay hidden. The item may have even belonged to George Washington, an exhilarating thought.
Beecher’s excitement cools quickly when a nearby guard mysteriously becomes ill and dies. There’s a plausible explanation for his death, but something seems off. Security staff are questioning everyone, but Beecher seems to be getting extra attention. When other strange events start, he suspects a link between the man’s death and the newly discovered item.
This leads to the discovery of the Culper Ring – a small group of people that the current President can trust. The original group contained real-life people who were major players in the American Revolution, acting as America’s first spy ring. Some believe that without them we would have lost the Revolutionary War. Meltzer’s premise assumes this group continued to exist throughout history to the present day.
Another discovery is that the item contains a puzzle about a dark secret which spells danger for many, particularly the young archivist and Clementine. He’s able to find the information she seeks, but both are shocked by his discovery. From here, life becomes a tangle of intrigue, deceit and murder. The plot speeds up as Beecher scrambles to help Clementine, hide his mistakes and keep the artifact hidden. It seems his every move is under scrutiny as he’s inevitably pulled into a dangerous intrigue. As he’s running for his life, he isn’t sure who he can trust.
While the story relies on events from the past, it’s definitely a modern novel that mixes the old with the new. The downsides for me were a far-fetched opening scene and a sometimes convoluted plot. There wasn’t enough character development for me personally, making it more challenging to guess who to trust. Meltzer did provide quite a maze of deceit and conspiracy as Beecham tried to determine friend from foe. Those who love a quick pace and lots of action scenes. Some felt a bit obvious until I realized that Meltzer was drawing on his comic book skills to depict them.
The protagonist is a somewhat nerdy 20-something whose portrayal as an average guy was marred by his tendency to complain. I still rooted for this somewhat reluctant hero, though. Meltzer makes good use of Beecher’s insecurities to propel the plot and provide a connection with readers.
The ending wasn’t as satisfying as I’d hoped and left me wondering about details I assume were answered in the sequels. The best part of the novel was the idea propelling the plot, which was a decent premise. Also enjoyable was how the author worked historical facts into the story and I would have welcomed more background on the Culper Ring and the National Archives.
Even Meltzer fans agree this isn’t his best, preferring works such as “The First Conspiracy” or “The Lightning Rod” instead. I will say the author provides plenty of intrigue and twists, however implausible. This one may suit travelers looking for a fast read, political history fans or those who like intrigue fantasies that are light on political details and heavier on action. For those who enjoy more detail, I’d suggest Steve Berry, Alma Katsu or David Baldacci.
If you enjoy this one, the next installments are “The Fifth Assassin” and “The President’s Shadow”, published in 2013 and 2015, respectively. And for those curious about the Culper Ring, you can’t go wrong with “George Washington’s Secret Six” by Brian Kilmeade.


