The Book Nook

Light read mixes hope and humor   Lucy Gilmore’s “The Lonely Hearts Book Club” is a good summer read option, especially for people who like feel-good contemporary novels or who believe in the power of literature.  This entertaining yarn features a decent premise and an eclectic cast who form an unusual club. Following the death of her sister, Sloane’s life has been lonely.  She’s in a relationship that’s OK, but not great.  Brett is likeable, but more predictable than passionate and she hopes that eventually she’ll feel a spark of love.  She senses she shouldn’t let him and his family make all the decision about her future, but her inclination to please others and a lack of energy keep her mired in place.  The two things she does enjoy is reading and her job at a small-town library in Idaho, particularly interacting with the patrons.  Well, all but one. Arthur’s appearance in the library causes staff to run or hide before he sees them.  He’s a demanding, irritable man who belittles employees, even when they’re helping him find the items he wants.  Sloane is the only one able to tolerate his presence, fending off his insults with wit and patience.  Over time she realizes they’re both enjoying the banter, a fact confirmed when he times his visits to coincide with her shifts. When Arthur’s outings to the library suddenly end, Sloane is concerned.  As time goes on without an appearance, she wonders if she should risk violating library policy to check on him.   You can probably guess her choice, which leads to a series of life-altering events.   The people she meets along the way are an instrumental part of her transformation and reader’s entertainment.  More fun comes from Sloane’s discoveries while sleuthing the reason behind Arthur’s disappearance.  If you anticipate a happy ending you won’t be disappointed. The author works to connect us to the characters, a varied group of individuals who tell their story in succession.  We get a good sense of each one as they lend different voices to the narrative.  All have an interesting backstory that’s woven into a sequential and easy to follow timeline.  All are also dealing with their own set of difficulties that are rather realistic.  They also recognize their problems without dwelling on them, which prevents readers from being overwhelmed by collective woes. For me, the weakest points related to the plot, which felt occasionally slow and easy to guess.  Predictability isn’t unusual in novels that play to our emotions and they’re generally more enjoyable by focusing on the overall journey rather than details.  I didn’t always believe such a diverse group would bond so quickly and closely, but I did like their wordplay and discussions.  Also enjoyable was the focus on how intergenerational relationships foster unexpected and rewarding connections.  Sloane’s verbal jousts with Arthur added amusing moments, although his negativity grated at times. More positive aspects are the messages about found family and overcoming troubles.  Sloane is obviously a people-pleaser in a relationship even she recognizes isn’t ideal for her.  To her credit, the author avoided stereotyping Sloane’s partner as a bad guy.  In fact, everyone in the cast is accorded introspective moments.  Each intuits their need for help and all are willing to take chances to alter their life.  All of this lends a positive tone as the individuals seek solutions. Many of the club’s chosen titles will be familiar to book lovers and I liked how the author used titles to reflect events in the characters’ lives.  It was also fun to follow the budding romance between two of the characters.   This is an emotional novel with themes of friendships and authenticity.  There’s also an exploration of community and loneliness.  Friction is added when Arthur’s nemesis makes an appearance, with some amusing scenes of Arthur’s reactions and interactions. Gilmore has published seven works, including her Service Puppies series and a couple of contemporary romances, one of which is titled “The Library of Borrowed Hearts”.  In that book, the protagonist also works in a library, but it’s a standalone novel and shouldn’t be considered a sequel to today’s featured read. If you prefer audiobooks, please note that some listeners found it challenging to distinguish between some of the secondary character’s voices.  They suggested paying attention to the name given at the beginning of each chapter as a better way to identify the speaker. Sloane’s journey is an adult coming-of-age tale of someone who gives freely to others and receives more than she expected.  Many readers liked being charmed by an eclectic group who reinforce the power of books without being dragged into a deep literary experience.  It’s a heartfelt story about lonely people who are brave enough to change their life.  As they reap the rewards, readers are given a story that lets them feel good about the world.