Geiger Counter
Human life can pretty much be divided into two periods: There is the yet phase, followed by the anymore epoch. During the first part of your life, you can’t do most of the things you want to do yet. During the second and final chapter, you can’t do them anymore.
You can’t drive a car yet. You can’t use the stove yet. You can’t drink beer yet. You can’t watch a rated R movie yet. You can’t stay up all night yet. This is pretty much the only thing children hear, all day.
Then, one day, they will wake up inexplicably old and discover they must now live purely on organic kale, probiotic supplements and nostalgia. You can’t run past/climb/leap over most things anymore. You can’t stay up all night anymore. You can’t remember where you put your keys/glasses/hat/dog/child anymore. You can’t drive a car anymore.
Some rare things, like diapers, make appearances in both phases of life. You are not out of diapers yet, will inevitably be followed by, You cannot leave the house without diapers anymore.
Sometimes, as you live out what you hope is your middle age, you find yourself mid-air, leaping from one to the next, with no solid ground beneath your feet - the brief time when you can do all the things you want to do. We rarely do. Instead, we middle-aged people tend to complain, extra loudly, so the young people can hear us while they are on their phones, and so the old people can, well, hear us.
Hearing is another thing that falls into both categories. When you are young, you are always told you can’t hear certain words and stories yet. The swears, along with conversations about heavy topics, are something grownups like to keep for themselves. Eventually, most old people simply cannot hear much of anything anymore.
Because of a severe neurological illness that damaged my brain and ability to hear, I have been deaf in one ear since I was a teenager. Along with not being able to hear, I also have a constant ringing in my right ear that, if I pay too much attention to it, prompts me to descend into the gaping maw of madness. And that’s not all, folks! Luck, or whatever gave me encephalitis, threw in bouts of dizziness and vertigo, too, which many people with damaged hearing experience. The result is that I always walk like I’m doing an over-the-top impression of Jack Sparrow, or like I am a little drunk.
So being able to hear, sleep soundly, and not tip over are all things that quickly and unexpectedly moved from the yet phase of my life to the anymore one. It seemed like one day, I was a toddler who couldn’t walk without falling down yet, and the next I was a 17-year-old who couldn’t stay upright anymore. The best thing to do with this affliction, and most afflictions, I assume, is to just ignore it. I sometimes yearn for a day when the ringing in my ear will be silenced, only to remember that will only happen when I die. I sometimes hope for the ability to hear a little better, only to realize that, with every passing day from now until I do perish, my hearing will probably get a little worse, and I will someday look back and yearn for the ability to hear as well as I can right now. “I can’t hear like that anymore!” I’ll say. Today, I will probably hear better than on any subsequent day of my existence. Today, to quote the late 20th century philosopher Ice Cube, is a good day.
There is no faster way to anger people in 2024 than to make this claim. That today is a good day. That we are lucky to be here, now. I never understood the roots of this malaise, which seems to be felt most deeply by the most privileged people in society, until I came across an incredible article written by the Belgian philosopher Maarten Boudry and published by the magazine Quillette. It’s called “The Seven Laws of Pessimism: If Life is Better Than Ever Before, Why Does the World Seem So Depressing?” In it, he makes sense of our species’ weakness for irrational pessimism.
Boudry, whose philosophical work often aims to dismantle pseudoscience, makes an array of inarguably true points about the fact that we live in one of the best times in human history, if not the best time in human history. And yet, people seem to spend most of their time weeping and gnashing their teeth.
Boudry points out that, according to research by Joe Hasell, Max Roser, Esteban Ortiz-Ospina and Pablo Arriagada, over the past 30 years, 130,000 people have escaped extreme poverty every day. But hardly any media outlets or social media influencers ever talk about this. If one of those millions of people sees their home swept away in a flood or burned to a crisp in a wildfire, however, our media diets will be flooded with images of it.
He also points to the work of Steven Pinker, who has documented “the steady decrease in violence over the past centuries.” However, as our species becomes so much safer, we constantly inflate our concepts of violence so that we eventually define any conflict - or even mild intellectual or emotional discomfort - as forms of violence today. Today, it is hard to find any category of thing or idea that someone has not labelled as “violence,” which would probably be a confusing trend for someone who was actually being crucified, burned at the stake or drawn and quartered not all that long ago.
Another reason, I suspect, is that people tend to conflate misery and pessimism with brooding intelligence. People think depressing pessimists must just be cracking under the weight of all their wisdom, while anyone who dares smile or laugh is some kind of Quixotic fool. In truth, however, there is much to be happy about. There is wonderful news all around us; however, it is not as flashy as its macabre counterparts.
“Have we just lived through one of the best years in human history? As we look at 2023 through the rearview mirror, I think that’s a defensible claim,” writes Boudry. “In fact, the same thing could have been said at the end of pretty much every year since the beginning of the millennium (with the exception of the disastrous pandemic years of 2020 and 2021). Never before have so many people lived in affluence, safety, and good health.”
“And yet, it doesn’t feel that way,” he admits. “There’s so much horror and misery in the world—look at the situations in Ukraine, Gaza, Sudan, and Yemen alone—that it is hard to believe that, on average, this past year was probably the best year ever. So, if life is better than ever before, why does the world seem so depressing?”
One culprit, he says, is media. Ever since the invention of “the news,” everyone has known that, “If it bleeds, it leads.” The news outlets and influences who focus on horrifying and negative things make more money than ones that publish positive or uplifting content.
Boudry offers a wonderful list, the aforementioned “Seven Laws of Pessimism.”
“Hopefully, this list will work as an antidote whenever excessive news consumption makes you feel despondent,” he writes.
I contacted Boudry and he was kind enough to say he doesn’t mind if I share his seven laws with you. If you want to fully understand them, of course, it’s easy enough to read the full article on quillette.com.
1. The Law of the Invisibility of Good News: Progress happens gradually and imperceptibly, while regress happens all at once and immediately grabs our attention. “Breaking news is often quite literally about things breaking down or being broken,” he points out.
2. The Law of The Velocity of Bad News: Nothing travels faster than the speed of light, except bad news. “No matter how much progress the world achieves, there will always be enough catastrophes to fill the evening news,” he writes. “If you rummage through a large enough haystack, you’re bound to find a few needles. And because our brains rely on the availability heuristic—i.e., we tend to estimate the probability of an event based on how easy it is to bring similar events to mind—we massively overestimate the occurrence rates of carjackings, terrorist attacks, brutal murders, shark attacks, and pretty much every catastrophe. For a more realistic perspective, Johan Norberg recommends only following local news, in order to shrink your frame of reference back down to the size it would have been before the age of telecommunication: “Since they only cover a very small geographical area, it is more difficult for them to find horrible stories.”
3. The Law of Rubbernecking: The more gruesome the news, the more we lap it up. “It’s not that we’re perverts or sadists; it’s just that we have been programmed by evolution to pay attention to really bad things, especially if they invoke what psychologists call “dread risk,” because they affect large numbers of people at the same time (examples include plane crashes and terrorist attacks),” Boudry writes.
4. The Law of Conservation of Outrage: No matter how much progress the world is achieving, the total amount of outrage remains constant. “As societies become safer and more prosperous, we demand more of them, and gradually raise the bar for what is considered ‘safe’ or ‘prosperous,’” he explains. “As a result, even though fewer disasters are happening than ever before, people still have the impression that the world is going downhill.”
5. The Law of Awful Attraction: If you don’t find bad news, bad news will find you. “In real life, if you pay attention to cute puppies while taking a walk, you will not be followed by hordes of cute puppies on your next walk,” he writes. “If you can’t resist rubbernecking a horrible car accident, you will not go on to see more horrible car accidents further down the road. But this is exactly what happens on social media when your attention is drawn to either cute puppies or horrific accidents.”
6. The Law of Self-Effacing Solutions: Once a solution has been achieved, people forget about the original problem (and only see further problems). “As Eliezer Yudkowsky has pointed out, progress has a way of rendering itself invisible: we simply raise our standards to accommodate the new normal,” he writes.
7. The Law of Disinfecting Sunlight: The freer a society, the more ugly things will surface. “People like to bite the hand that feeds them, provided it will not slap back—and in a free and tolerant society, it won’t,” he adds. “As the Dutch-Somali writer Ayaan Hirsi Ali told journalist Avi Lewis in a 2007 interview: ‘You grew up in freedom, and you can spit on freedom because you don’t know what it is not to have freedom.’”


