Wisconsin Heights Assistant Principal/Activities Director resigns over being “unaligned” with school board
A rare public instance of public frustration and discontent with the board over recent departures at the administrative level of the district came about at the Wisconsin Heights school board meeting on January 8th. Wisconsin heights resident Tasha Severson spoke for several minutes at the board about her concerns with the latest departure, Middle School/High School Assistant Principal and Athletics and Activities Director Kindra Zuberbuehler, who resigned effective January 7th.
Wisconsin Heights has seen some administrative staff departures in the wake of District Administrator’s Jordan Sinz’s resignation last summer. Scott Moore, former Elementary Principal, accepted a position with the River Valley School District in August. Dale Green stepped in and now serves as Elementary Principal and has applied to be the new District Administrator. Cheryl Knowles, the Business Manager, also left during the summer. The district hired a consultant and a someone from CESA to assist them with the business side of things and the budget. Finally, Matt Greene retired at the end of last school year; the district internally promoted Kelly Santell to Director of Student Services. That leaves Middle School/High School Principal Liz Dostal and Green as the sole remaining administrators from Sinz’s tenure.
In addition, the board’s initial selection to replace Sinz didn’t work out, leading to a reset and the hire of Interim District Administrator, Craig Gerlach. With the district helmed by Gerlach, the board set about to choose its next District Administrator, which it is on the threshold of doing. Severson voiced her complaints just 24 hours before the community met the four final candidates for the leadership job.
Both Severson, in her public comments, and Zuberbuehler, in her letter of resignation, touched on the same thing. A “disconnect,” to use Severson’s words, or being “unaligned,” to use Zuberbuehler’s words, with the school board. “Over the past several months the school board and I have become unaligned,” wrote Zuberbuehler.
Severson’s in person comments had a bit more color, and included personal attacks against board members. She raised her voice and punctuated her words. She opened by saying it was “sad day” for the district, and that the assembled board members were “laughing” at her. “I can see on your faces that none of you even care or respect that I’m talking,” she added. “Nobody has a backbone to stand up to other people on the board.”
“And I don’t even know why Kindra is resigning,” continued Severson. “[In my business] we make it work for the better of the business. That’s what I feel you guys are not doing. For the better of the school.”
The board quietly listened to her when she spoke.
Board President Barb Statz had the following to say about the comments: “It was disappointing. Public input during our open meeting serves as a platform for constructive dialogue and we expect a level of decorum and respect for one another. Personal attacks only serve to create division and hinder collaborative efforts needed to address the challenges we face.”
Statz added, “I’ll also say, public service humbles you. It’s a privilege and opportunity to create a positive impact on the lives of our students and the community as a whole, while also recognizing that our decision making impacts different individuals and groups in various ways. We understand decisions may be met with criticism, disappointment or even frustration, but It’s our duty to carefully weigh the consequences and make choices that prioritize the greater good and benefit all students.”
Statz said the following about Zuberbuehler’s resignation:
“The past few months the school board, along with the help of our interim superintendent, has been diligently working to hire our next district leader. We have prioritized gathering feedback from all of our stakeholders in order to identify areas needing improvement. We have had tough conversations regarding our upcoming referendum in order to develop a budget which will allow us to pay our quality staff members what they deserve, and, most importantly to identify how we can best serve the needs of our students and their educational experiences. At the end of the day, the board is aligned to make decisions based on what’s best for our students, as it’s at the core of what we do. We wish Mrs. Zuberbuehler nothing but the best in her future endeavors.”
Zuberbuehler’s position--Middle School/High School Assistant Principal and Athletics and Activities Director—was also a topic of conversation on an agenda item at the meeting, as the board has been discussing an administrative restructure for the next school year. Part of that restructure will involve splitting that position into two: a separate Activities Director and Dean of Students.
In regard to the combined position that Zuberbuehler held, Gerlach said at the meeting “It’s a revolving door,” explaining that its not just Wisconsin Heights that has seen turnover at that position. “It’s a challenging position,” he said, describing it as a “stepping stone” in one’s career.
The combined position entails a lot. Gerlach describes: “The Athletic Director schedules all athletic events, hires and supervises coaches, manages athletic events and crowd control, and is the main liaison between the school and WIAA. This is a very general list.” He continues, “The Assistant Principal is an integral part of the Middle School/High School student service team that works very closely with students regarding but not limited to: student behavior, student mental health, staff evaluation, and building culture and climate. Again, this is a very general list of duties that are very demanding as well as challenging.”
In Zuberbuehler’s absence, Gerlach said “We will meet the needs of our athletic programs by utilizing current staff for the remainder of the year. Much of the work preparing for next year is done, however, it will result in additional responsibilities for a number of staff that have experience with managing athletic events for the next semester. Principal Liz Dostal and I will be involved in any necessary hiring of coaches.”
As for splitting the position into two next year, Gerlach said:
“The split of the Athletic Director/Assistant Principal position has been discussed for several years. It is a difficult position balancing the needs of athletics and student service needs. It is not unusual for this position to put in 60 hours per week. Additionally, it has been a position of high turnover.”
Gerlach spoke more generally about Wisconsin Heights’ more recent staffing changes:
“Staffing today in public education continues to be a challenge. Building and sustaining a strong administrative team has a significant impact on quality education. As you are aware, we have experienced administrative turnover which is an increasing theme throughout the state and country. I believe the national tenure of a school superintendent is around three years and the state [average is] five years. Much like the NFL, gone are the days of educators (players) staying long term in the same school district (team). We have lost an administrator over the past year as a result of retirement, a change of career path interest, as well as stress of the job. This has been an unintended consequence of Act 10. With that said, I am confident that we will build a strong team that will continue to provide great leadership for Wisconsin Heights.”
Finally, the snow-day delayed candidate forum for the four finalists to be Wisconsin Heights next District Administrator was held last Wednesday. A good-sized crowd from the community gathered in the Middle School Step Room amidst the smell of fresh broccoli and cauliflower to listen and question for three hours. The four finalists—Dale Green, Michelle McGrath, Duy Nguyen, and Garrett Zimmerman—gathered before the crowd for a question-and-answer session quietly and professionally emceed by Mazomanie’s Garry Harrop. He quickly hit upon the idea of having the community members ask their same question of each candidate, in order to establish a baseline of sorts.
There was, in the end, several themes to the questions asked: how will you aid in talent recruitment and retention? Why Wisconsin Heights? What will your relationship be with the local library? How will you help with diversity, inclusion and also culture? What is your background in school finance?
The board scheduled an extra session to further discuss the finalists and an announcement is expected soon.


