The Book Nook
Drama and Mystery
The previous Book Nook column suggested two books featuring mother/daughter relationships. Coincidentally that’s the case again today, but instead of fantasy works, the first is a drama which follows a girl from grade school through her late teens, while the second is a thriller about family secrets.
Climbing to maturity
Allegra Goodman has written several novels, and in “Sam”, she offers a character-driven story of a white girl’s coming of age. Sam lives with her step-brother Noah and Courtney, their loving but overworked mother. Filled with regret that her jobs only pay for the basic necessities, instead of frills she urges them to study hard to avoid her path of having to work multiple low-wage jobs.
Sam feels the pinch of a low-income family most frequently at school, where not having the “right” brands of clothing is noticed. She understands her mom’s situation and knows her dad, Mitchell would do more if he could. He’s a sweet non-conformist who battles with issues that make him an unreliable parent. Sam loves him with all her heart but longs for him to be a bigger part of her life.
She’s happy to embrace his love of rock climbing, showing an early talent for the sport, which pleases him. She clings to the hope that doing well will motivate him to spend more time with her, but over time, frustration at empty promises pushes her from disappointment to resentment. The passing of time will bring struggles with changing hormones and dealing with a tragic event which sparks bitterness and guilt. Good and bad decisions ensue as Sam is torn between pleasing others and listening to an internal voice urging her towards a different path.
I had mixed feelings about this coming-of-age tale. Having only Sam’s viewpoint felt restrictive at times when I wanted more background, but the biggest negative for me was when serious issues were glossed over. Perhaps this was done to move the plot more quickly but I felt the lack of missed opportunities for negative issues.
On the up side, this is a good story featuring mostly positive relationships that presents mood shifts realistically. The narrative starts out easy and straightforward, a reflection of Sam’s tender age. As she matures the language becomes more complex, which I felt was a nice addition. The author did well at capturing Sam’s feelings and highlighting her struggle at deciding which paths to follow, providing nice conflict. I also liked how rock climbing was used as a metaphor for growing up.
The brief chapters and emphasis on dialog will be appreciated by those seeking a quick read with a frequently believable story, which contains profane language and sexual situations.
Searching for the truth
Prepare for an emotional journey in Christina McDonald’s family suspense novel “The Night Olivia Fell”. Please note this review contains spoilers, but not the big reveal.
The book starts with a parent’s worst fear: a middle-of-the-night phone call with bad news about their child. When Abi Knight is wakened by such a call, she rushes to the hospital where she’s told her daughter Olivia fell off a bridge.
The prognosis is horrible: Olivia is brain-dead and will never wake up or recover. She’s also pregnant and is legally required to stay alive until the baby is close to full term. Once that happens, Olivia will be taken off life support and Abi can’t believe her beloved daughter will soon be gone forever. She’s also in shock about the pregnancy, considering the closeness of their relationship. How could Olivia have kept such a huge secret from her? Why didn’t she notice the girl was pregnant?
The police quickly rule that the fall was an accident but Abi doesn’t agree, pointing out bruises she noticed on Olivia’s wrists. Furious when they refuse to investigate further and close her daughter’s case, she embarks on a quest to get answers.
In an attempt to reconstruct events leading to Olivia’s fall, she unearths discrepancies that keep her from getting the complete picture. Some of the people in Olivia’s life have their own secrets, making everyone a suspect. Like Abi, readers must determine who is telling the truth and who is lying in this thriller.
We get two narratives – one from Abi in the present and the other via flashbacks from Olivia’s past. From the powerful opening, the simple writing style complements a quickly moving storyline. One minor grumble I had at first was the cliché use of a teen keeping secrets from an overprotective parent. However, McDonald satisfied that aspect in her explanation of Abi’s need to safeguard the girl.
The authors’ so good at describing her characters’ feelings that readers may find themselves pulled along for the ride. Her interlacing developments between mother and daughter are done in a way that adds an emotional layer which rounds out the story nicely. There’s no lack of plot twists and McDonald makes us doubt much of what we see on the surface. Before it’s over we’ll have a broad field of suspects, although some will be able to work it out before the final chapters.
Although we know Olivia’s fate shortly after starting the book, McDonald makes her a sympathetic enough character that I’d recommend having tissues at hand. From the ominous cover to the bittersweet ending, readers may find the short chapters and fast-moving plot make this a quick and satisfying story they’ll want to devour in one sitting.


