The Book Nook
Clever premise in fantasy series starter
The plot description for A. J. Hackwith’s novel “The Library of the Unwritten” is rather unusual – a demon, a muse and a librarian join forces to find a character that escaped from its book.
In this ambitious fiction, the central figure is Claire, who works in one of hell’s libraries and manages the Unwritten Wing, where unfinished books are housed. From the beginning we know she isn’t thrilled to be working in hell, but not why she’s there.
Most of her time is spent organizing and repairing books in the collection, but her most essential duty is to ensure restless characters don’t escape their books and leave the library. She’s helped by her subordinate, Brevity – a failed muse who is a very capable assistant.
Such an event has just occurred and the process of dealing with escapees is never enjoyable for Claire or Brevity, but necessary to avoid catastrophe. No sooner have they dealt with one such event when a junior demon arrives with an ominous message from Hell’s big boss - a book is missing from Claire’s section. That’s bad enough, but when she’s told it contained a suspected runaway, she knows her job is on the line.
Now it’s a race against time to find the fugitive and to avoid dire consequences, Claire must do whatever it takes to locate and capture the fugitive. This involves dealing with the red tape necessary for the “trip upstairs” to Earth. For this mission, Claire enlists the help of Brevity and the demon, who is an unknown factor in this incongruent trio.
Spoiler alert: they will find their target, but Claire’s confidence at managing problems will be tested multiple times. While pursuing their objective they’ll find themselves on a roller-coaster adventure teeming with obstacles, danger and a strange and fantastic cast of characters that include warring angels and demons. Part of their journey will involve a visit to Valhalla, where Claire has to participate in a demanding memory contest she’s almost certain to lose.
She needs to be at the top of her game at all times and will face many disheartening challenges. Even if she succeeds, it’s likely she’ll face unpleasant consequences. Throughout their journey there are pursuers, traps and a host of creatures bent on foiling their progress.
As someone who enjoys “librarians inside a book” tropes, I had hoped the writing would live up to the hype of the synopsis and blurbs. Unfortunately, the execution was disappointing at times and the story wandered off course in the middle, which was thankfully bookended by a strong start and finish. I found the broad focus to be somewhat distracting, but I did like the author’s lively imagination. Scenes related to political in-fighting were particularly well done.
One of the bright spots was the characters, most of which were nicely nuanced. Claire’s assistant Brevity was fascinating and I would have liked reading more about her. The relationship she shares with Claire added nice elements to the story. Hackwith gives us vivid characters with distinct personalities, and adds friction-inducing elements that ranged from minor chafing to life-threatening clashes. The vagueness of individual morality added a layer of complexity which improved the plot.
The story’s written in the third person but from differing points of view that added meaningful strength to the finished product. Claire’s attitude and references towards the big boss is amusing and provides several good moments. I also liked how relationships unfolded and that we were given insight into multiple characters, though at times I wanted them to be more compelling.
Hackwith also writes sci-fi romance using the pen name Ada Harper. Claire utters a line that shows the author’s willingness to poke fun at the genre and to try her hand at a new one. While this series kick-off gets off to a slow start, it has a packed second half that the author thankfully did not rush. We get imaginative premises, unpredictability and some wonderful prose.
While the story lacks something I’m unable to specify, I enjoyed much of the delivery. It’s an adventure packed with mostly solid action scenes and themes that pay homage to librarians and writers along with mythology references and witty banter.
Hackwith’s impressive originality and ability to impart details offers fantasy fans a world they may enjoy inhabiting. Those who like a fast-paced creative tale with colorful characters can try this as a standalone novel and if it appeals, the entire series is listed below with publication dates.
1) “The Library of the Unwritten” (2019)
2) “The Archive of the Forgotten” (2020)
3) “The God of Lost Words” (2021)


