The Book Nook

Clever Cozy Mystery   If you’re looking for a character-driven mystery that’s gentle and funny, you can’t go wrong with “The Thursday Murder Club” by Richard Osman.  This debut is filled with original characters, good twists and tons of wit.  There’s added depth with themes of friendship and people coming to terms with who they are.  Please note this review contains spoilers. The plot centers on a small group of residents of a British retirement village.  They’ve retired from work and now work to remain active and useful.  They meet every Thursday, but not to play cards or engage in sedate activities associated with the elderly.  This ensemble discusses cold police cases in the hopes of solving them. There’s a nurse, a union activist, and a psychiatrist.  There’s also Elizabeth, who, if not their leader, is certainly the group’s core and motivator.  We don’t know her line of work before she retired, but there are murky hints at a role in intelligence.  That might explain why she’s such a capable and sometimes formidable person.  She does have an unusual set of specialized skills. They all live at Cooper’s Chase, an upscale community that offers a variety of food and activity choices.  It’s a lovely spot in the English countryside that sits on the grounds of a former convent, including a graveyard for the nuns who departed life for their bit of heaven.  It’s a place where visitors can walk or enjoy the peace and quiet from a park bench.  But the serene beauty masks a place with dark secrets. What isn’t a secret is the group’s opinion of the big boss at Cooper’s Chase.  He’s a local developer with a patronizing attitude and a “profits before people” philosophy on life.  His latest scheme to increase his wealth includes a new development for the area.  This means getting rid of the cemetery, and few are fooled by his promise that the good sisters’ bones will be relocated respectfully and lawfully. But before old bodies can be addressed, there will soon be a new one.  The club members witness an argument between two people, one of whom is later found dead.  The group is eager to beat the police in solving the case, utilizing their expertise to gather information and clues.  While the local authorities are not depicted as the clueless bumblers found in some mysteries, they seem to be a step behind the club’s clever minds.  And the race is on. Some of the narration is in the third person present tense, which can be challenging to write and is growing in popularity among writers.  There’s also first-person journal entries that serves multiple purposes – lending a different voice and helping us see things through their eyes while providing important background information. The popularity of cozy mysteries is growing, although not everyone sees eye to eye on how they’re defined.    Some claim they’re just shorter than a standard novel while others say cozies feature only female or amateur sleuths.  Other assertions are that only small-town or rural locations are used, or that the characters are likeable.  Most agree they’re the gentlest cousins of the crime family: they lack gore and view people as being more good than bad. This one hits most of those marks with the added benefit of being funny.  It’s British humor done in a way that translates easily for Americans and is smart without being off-putting.  The storyline is cleverly done, offering multiple plot lines with unforeseen twists to keep readers guessing.  The writing style offers a breezy mix of sleuthing and friendship at a steady pace with few lags. There’s attention to friendships and the possibility of creating new ones late in life.  I enjoyed that the writer avoided using stereotypes when depicting his characters.  While I didn’t always buy how much information the police were willing to share with “outsiders”, I felt the writer’s use of Elizabeth’s shrewdness covered some aspects of that problem.  Also enjoyable was how the author took care to flesh out so many of the characters, with teasers about some that hinted at future installments. Those hints became reality when three more books followed in as many years.  The order with publication dates is:   1) The Thursday Murder Club (2020)  2) The Man Who Died Twice (2021) 3) The Bullet That Missed (2022) 4) The Last Devil to Die (2023)   Osman is a British quiz show host and guest who is beloved by many in his country.  He’s also known for being a comedian, a television producer and an author.  As a crime devotee and trivia expert, he draws on his knowledge and blends it with a unique style to give cozy fans a fun read.