The Book Nook

Frankenstein Reboot   “The Children on the Hill” by Jennifer McMahon draws on inspiration from Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein” to give us a story of modern-day monsters.  It might not be scary enough to keep you awake at night but the book has gotten enough praise to make it a serious contender as a gothic horror classic. In 1978 Dr. Helen Hildreth is considered an excellent psychiatrist who sometimes achieves miraculous outcomes for her patients.  To Eric and Violet, she’s just Gran – the woman who provides a loving if unusual home.  Disdainful of public schools, Gran has created her own curriculum, providing guidance as the children shape their own educational experience.  Their free time is spent creating a book about werewolves, shapeshifters and other creatures they’re convinced are real. Gran’s house is on a property in Vermont that includes the Hillside Inn, a private psychiatric hospital where she works.  The kids have strict orders to stay away from the hospital which only heightens their curiosity, particularly about the patients.  But Gran refuses to share anything about the inhabitants, unaware that Violet’s heard rumors about sinister events that occur behind locked doors. The two worlds mesh when Gran moves a girl named Iris into their home from the treatment center.  This is unexpected since they thought the center was only for adults.  Also surprising is that Gran assigns them to help Iris assimilate into their family.  Not an easy task with a traumatized girl who doesn’t speak and seems more feral than human.  But Violet and Eric are used to unusual or challenging assignments.  They invite Iris to join them and as they try to discover more about her, Violet wonders if she’s the mysterious patient mentioned in a secret journal she “found”. The story jumps ahead to 2019 where Lizzy Shelly is a researcher who does consulting work on a TV production about monsters.  Her paranormal podcast “Monsters Among Us” is gaining popularity as she travels around the country in search of legendary beings such as Bigfoot.  She got a lead about someone who uses these legends as a screen while abducting young girls and she’s determined to find the truth.  The tip takes her to Vermont where her instincts say the disappearances are somehow linked to the Hillside Inn.  As the creepiness factor ramps up, readers will encounter several twists while untangling clues from the past and present. This novel is told via alternating timelines and various perspectives.  We hear from all the major characters, including the monster and excerpts from a tell-all book about the hospital.  Using multiple narrators can be tricky, but its use here only enhances the storyline.  Readers can examine the tale from different points of view and the stylistic changes complement each other and enhance the storyline. The plot is clever with touches of the supernatural to keep our attention.  Some readers disliked the final reveal while others felt it was handled well.  Similar comments were made about the pacing, although a little probing showed they were more related to personal reading preferences. McMahon is good at providing atmosphere in both timelines, using a slow-release approach to clues that are well-timed and make sense.  Her writing is evocative and contains twists that make sense yet are unexpected.  Violet’s curiosity and the cat and mouse game between Lizzy and the monster provide several suspenseful moments that make it easy to keep turning pages. This work joins other modern fiction that defies being put into one category.  It could be considered a horror story, a drama or a psychological thriller.  In fact, the author seems to have carved a niche where female protagonists deal with past legends or secrets that pose real dangers.  Her debut novel “Promise not to tell” was considered part ghost story and part mystery/thriller.  A dozen of her novels have been published since 2007, many of which are set in Vermont where she lives. McMahon notes that while she was repeatedly told to “Write what you know”, she developed her own mantra which she sports as a tattoo:  “Write what scares you”.  She’s been compared favorably with American horror/mystery writer Shirley Jackson, who readers may remember for her famous ghost story “The Haunting of Hill House”. Like the author of “Frankenstein”, McMahon invites readers to ponder the definition of monster and how precarious memories can be.  She offers a classic tale of science and ethics that tackles a controversial subject.  This one may disappoint those who enjoy being terrified or gore-seekers.  However, it’s well suited for young adult or older readers who prefer the milder side of the horror genre and fans of psychological thrillers infused with mystery elements will find a good read here.  I hope Mary Shelley would agree.