A View of the Valley
by Linda Schwanke
As you are hopefully aware of by now, there’s an election coming up next Tuesday, April 4. We will be electing town chairs, supervisors, clerks, treasurers and village presidents and trustees. It’s nice to see that there are contested races in the Valley because having a choice is a big deal. I sent questions to all the people who are running for office in the towns and village of the Valley. Not everyone answered. That’s disappointing but I know people are busy. I’m not at all disappointed, in fact I’m happy, that two classmates of my kids, Pam Gauger and Sara Carstensen, are on the school board. All the connections of living in a rural area are really nice. We all know each other, at least to some degree, and it is one of the things I value about our community.
There are two candidates running for the Wisconsin Supreme Court, which there has been a ton of noise about. Which is good because it, too, is a big deal. I had profiles of the candidates earlier this year so I’m not repeating them. What I haven’t had in the Home News yet is information about statewide referendums. The Nonpartisan Iowa County Election Education Team submitted a really great article, which I thank them for, about the referendums which I’m sharing with you. Here is what they sent:
“Understanding Statewide Referendums in the April 4th Election
With so much attention being focused on the race for Supreme Court Justice, you may be surprised, when you step into the voting booth on April 4th, to find three referendum questions on your ballot.
The first two questions propose an amendment to the Wisconsin State Constitution regarding the setting of bail. A referendum to amend the constitution must first receive a majority vote in two consecutive years in both houses of the legislature before being placed on the ballot. This type of referendum is called a binding referendum because the legislature is bound by the will of the voters.
The third question on the ballot, asking about job search requirements for public assistance, is an advisory referendum. As the name implies, this type of referendum is a gauge of public opinion. It takes a majority vote of both houses of the legislature, just one time, to place an advisory referendum on the ballot. The outcome of the vote on an advisory referendum will not change any law or require any action by the legislature.
Constitutional Amendments and Advisory Referendums are the only two types of statewide referendums permitted in Wisconsin. Both have to be initiated by the state legislature. Of note, twenty-six other states have provisions by which citizens may initiate a referendum to create, amend, or repeal a state law or constitutional provision. To do so, they must collect petition signatures from a minimum number of registered voters. If the change proposed in the referendum is approved by voters, it becomes law. This is not an option in Wisconsin.
The Referendums
State of Wisconsin Conditions of Release Before Conviction Referendum - Question 1
QUESTION 1: “Conditions of release before conviction. Shall section 8 (2) of article I of the constitution be amended to allow a court to impose on an accused person being released before conviction conditions that are designed to protect the community from serious harm?”
This amendment is just a tweaking of this section of the constitution. It would change the current wording “serious bodily harm” to “serious harm.”
State of Wisconsin Cash Bail Before Conviction Referendum - Question 2
QUESTION 2: “Cash bail before conviction. Shall section 8 (2) of article I of the constitution be amended to allow a court to impose cash bail on a person accused of a violent crime based on the totality of the circumstances, including the accused’s previous convictions for a violent crime, the probability that the accused will fail to appear, the need to protect the community from serious harm and prevent witness intimidation, and potential affirmative defenses?” Under current law, a judge can only set bail to ensure that defendants will appear in court.
State of Wisconsin Welfare Benefits Referendum - Question 3
QUESTION 3: “Shall able-bodied, childless adults be required to look for work in order to receive taxpayer-funded welfare benefits?”
What makes this referendum unusual is that this is only the second time in three decades that a statewide advisory referendum is being held. In April 1993 there were five referendums on the ballot, all related to legalizing gambling in Wisconsin. In November 2006 there was a referendum about the death penalty. Advisory referendums can be included in the spring nonpartisan elections or the fall partisan elections. (Source: Wisconsin Legislative Reference Bureau.)
Arguments in Support of and In Opposition to the Referendums
With regard to the bail amendments to the Wisconsin State Constitution, those who support the bail amendments argue that to keep the public safe, the wording in the constitution needs to be changed. They want to make explicit that in setting bail, judges are permitted to consider a wide range of circumstances in addition to flight risk, thereby giving judges more discretion. Opponents point out that since the factors that make someone a flight risk are often the same factors that make them a safety risk, the proposed constitutional amendments are not necessary. The opponents also claim that the bail amendment perpetuates an injustice in the bail system. A suspect who can afford high bail fees could still be released on bail, while a person of low income who can’t post bail will remain in jail awaiting trial, even if both persons are accused of identical crimes and pose the same flight or safety risk. Incarceration for a poor person could result in loss of a job and other extreme hardships for that person and their family.
Turning to the advisory referendum on a job search requirement for public assistance, opponents point out that this referendum is not necessary since that requirement already exists for those applying for unemployment benefits and food stamps. Supporters of the referendum in the legislature, citing concerns about labor shortages in the state, believe the referendum is necessary to send a message to the federal government that it should allow such a requirement for recipients of BadgerCare (the state’s health care program for low-income residents).
Issues with Referendums in General
Referendums pose special challenges to voters. Often the wording of a referendum question makes it difficult to fully understand the issue. The issue is often complex, but the referendum questions must be simple and short; a question about a complex issue can be difficult to answer with a simple Yes or No answer. Sometimes the wording intentionally tries to elicit a specific response.
There are other factors as well that may affect the accuracy of advisory referendums as gauges of public opinion. For example, the result of an election with a small turnout may not reflect the opinions of the voting population at large. Or the outcome of an election where other items on the ballot attract large numbers particular groups of voters might may give a false impression of the extent of support for a referendum. These limitations of advisory referendums, along with the fact that they cannot change any laws, may account for why they rarely appear in statewide election ballots.
Other Items on the Ballot
If you don’t want to find other surprises when you enter the voting booth on April 4th, here are three ways to preview what local races and referendums will be on your ballot:
1. Go to myvote.wi.org to apply for a mail-in ballot. One will be sent to you in advance of the election.
2, Go to myvote.wi.org where sample ballots for every locality is listed prior to an election.
3. Visit your local clerk’s office where a sample ballot will be posted.”
The Iowa County Election Education Team is a group of local citizens dedicated to providing nonpartisan education to Iowa County residents about local and statewide elections that affect our lives in our community. Follow us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/IowaCountyElectionEducation
Stay in touch. My phone number is (608) 574-3159 – call or text me anytime. You can also email me at homenewseditor@newspubinc.com
Visit our website at homenewsrv.com
The news deadline is 12 noon on Mondays.


