The Book Nook

Imagery enhances tale of revenge   Westerns are gaining popularity and most novels in this genre have plots filled with horses, gunfights and strong, quiet men.  Landscapes play a crucial role as harsh environments to be tamed or vast open areas that create an atmosphere of freedom and/or isolation.  All of these characteristics and more can be found in Chase Pletts’ book “The Loving Wrath of Eldon Quint”. This stark yet layered tale is told from the perspective of two men.  The time is 1883 and the title character is a farmer doing his best to provide for his family on the Dakota frontier.  Like many settlers in the Old West, Eldon’s family discovered the difficulty of living in a land that can grind you down.  Exhaustion and starvation were real threats that claimed countless lives. Eldon’s goals are simple: provide enough food to keep his family alive and ensure his sons never experience the brutality that scarred his own upbringing.  So far he’s been able to eke out a living from the land, but the goal of shielding his sons is about to get a lot more complicated. The other man mentioned is the first we meet, and he’s in perilous situation.  He goes by the name Jack and is hoping today isn’t his last on earth because he’s caught in a punishing winter storm pursued by armed men. When Eldon and Jack meet it’s clear they’re not strangers.  Readers quickly learn the link they share and more will be revealed slowly throughout the dramatic and tragic plot.  We see two vastly different men caught up in a complicated and tangled relationship filled with rancor.  The gulf between them is widened by a catastrophic event that fills one with remorse and the other with a rage so strong it can only be satisfied with vengeance.  There’s lots of history to unpack between these two and each recalled memory adds a new piece to the puzzle.  Theirs is an estrangement with almost no chance for reconciliation, yet shared hardships of the past provide a tiny strand of hope. Following a horrible tragedy Eldon is doggedly determined to find peace by taking on a monumental task.  His job will get more difficult thanks to the motley cast of characters he’s about to meet.  One is a woman named Minn Barker who plotted a daring escape to pursue a closely-guarded dream.  Her addition adds to an already intense storyline while those bent on foiling her plans escalate the danger to a heart-pounding level. The strained relationship between Eldon and Jack is a driving force, providing flawed characters readers may love or hate, but can’t ignore.  These details shape a gritty novel that melds gunfights with a meaningful look at trauma.  Heavily threaded in the narrative is the theme about the fear of and need to connect with others.  There’s an offbeat and appealing feel to the pulpy yet thoughtful writing.  Pletts succeeds at portraying the rough and tumble feel of the Old West with its harsh climate. In an interview the author said he wanted to give the book a lyrical feel and many agree he succeeded.  There’s also an intensity that defies the traditional minimalism that marks the genre, and the author is pleased he set a higher literary bar for himself.  The result is a profound look at loyalty and love in the face of loss. Western fans will note less resemblance to works by Larry McMurty or Louis L’Amour and more to those by Charles Portis, who wrote “True Grit”.  Known for characters who struggle with internal flaws, Portis had a gift for capturing the cadence of Western speech.  Chase Pletts has a similar flair for language, drawing on his songwriting experience.  Pletts noted Portis’ influence on his writing, along with non-Western authors such as Annie Proulx and Cormac McCarthy.  The Los Lobos tune “Will the Wolf Survive” was a major influence on this book, with the song’s opening lines forming the basis for the novel’s first chapter. The many gunfight scenes are detailed without being overly gory, but readers who shun violence or cursing may not enjoy this book.  Those seeking an award-winning debut novel will be rewarded with an unusual Western about revenge and forgiveness. Following its publication in 2021, the book received honors for traditional novel and first novel from the Western Writers of America’s Spur Awards.  This is a wild ride filled with adventure that features a complex plot that’s remarkably easy to follow.  The characters add much to the flavor and the shared history and diametrically opposed personalities of the two protagonists provide ample reason for their animosity.  But at the heart is a family-driven story that’s heartbreaking yet hopeful.