The Book Nook
Pie a la Murder
Baking and blackmail are featured in Misha Popp’s “Magic, Lies, and Deadly Pies”. This debut mystery is immensely readable and can compete with many of the recommended romance, thrillers and memoirs recommended on this year’s summer reading lists.
Popp’s book poses the question, what would you do if you suddenly discovered you could magically create food that changed people’s lives? Would you use it for good or evil?
That’s a question Daisy Ellery faces every day. That’s because in her family some of the women inherit a magic trait. They don’t know what form their “gift” will take and no two women receive the same one. Daisy never thought twice about her talent for baking until the day she discovered a single slice of her pie could actually change people’s lives. No special ingredients or incantations were used but the results were amazing. Scary amazing.
The power of that first pie turned her world upside down, forcing her to flee the life she knew and loved. Living on the run was hard, but eventually she was able to give up her nomadic existence and work towards a more stable life. Deciding how to earn a living was easy – keep baking delicious pies. The next question was where. She found a small Massachusetts community with a thriving farmer’s market, a college campus filled with hungry students and a diner owner willing to sell her pies.
She now has a growing number of loyal customers, and her life is at a point where she’s willing to trust in herself and others again. Tentative forays into friendships go well enough that each day is a little easier than the last.
While hiding out she mulled over the event that triggered her flight, concluding that her gift exceeds the boundaries of what other Ellery women received. Asking for guidance wasn’t an option while she worked through the emotions caused by her newfound powers.
She may not understand how the magic works but she’s determined to use it to help others, although her unusual and sometimes illegal methods puts her at great risk. She set up very strict rules for self-preservation and to limit damage control, which has served her well. When Daisy learns someone’s been sneaking around her home she doesn’t worry because there’s nothing incriminating to find.
Then a blackmail note threatens to destroy everything she’s worked so hard to achieve. The extortionist claims to know her secret, making demands that set her teeth on edge. Infuriated and fearful, her only hope is to find clues from the note and go from there. While working to discover the blackmailer’s identity, her friendships are threatened by a careless betrayal, bringing a painful sense of loss. So, she’s on her own – alone again. Or is she?
A pie contest, revenge and unexpected twists flavor this delectable and humorous tale filled with danger and wronged women. The majority of Daisy’s pies serve as aids or tonics for people’s woes, but some are deadly, so you’d better stay on her good side. The magical aspect is more of a plot device and is kept to a minimum. Daisy’s moral battles are explored as she uses persuasive arguments to justify her tactics.
The result is a story that isn’t totally contained in a cozy mystery box, but spills over into the thriller category spiced with tinges of romance. In spite of deadly serious subjects, the witty dialog and wild plot brings a playful feel to this page-turner. The writing is crisp and straight-forward with short chapters and an easy to follow plot. Popp fleshes out her characters well enough to make you curious for more details without feeling something is missing. Bakers will appreciate her kitchen scenes and food descriptions.
This book kicks off a series called “A Pies Before Guys Mystery”, an intriguing phrase that’s explained in the book. The plot reminded me of the TV series Dexter, so those who enjoy vengeful justice will be rewarded. Popp joins other authors of books featuring food and magic, such as Sarah Addison Allen, Mary Maxwell and Ellery Adams. Their fans will likely eat this one up and look forward to a second helping, although they’ll have to wait a bit.
When I contacted the author about her next book, she said the sequel will be called “A Good Day to Pie” with a slated release date of February 7, 2023. She also shared that it’s being pitched as “murder at the Great British Bake Off” and will feature more “baking, banter and blackmail”. In it, Daisy will again try to solve a murder while competing in a baking competition. I’d like to thank Misha Popp for taking the time to provide this information and wish her luck in her future writing endeavors.
If you find yourself wondering how those pies taste, the author thoughtfully provides recipes, including one for pie crust with easy to follow instructions. Grab your fork and get ready to dig into this deliciously wicked mystery that makes for a fun summer thriller. Reading it’s as easy as pie.


