Sauk Prairie falls just short
It was a great day for Sauk Prairie senior second baseman Brenden Larsen to celebrate his 18th birthday with his teammates.
Larsen reached base in all four of his plate appearances and made a sensational diving catch in the top of the seventh inning for the host Eagles in the inaugural Badger West Conference championship baseball game.
But senior left fielder Luke Thompson ruined the party with a clutch, two-out bases-loaded double to lift Madison Edgewood to a 5-1 victory over Sauk Prairie last Saturday at Chuck Hall Memorial Field.
“A win would have been a little icing on the cake there,” said Larsen, who had two hits and also drew two walks to pace the offense for Sauk Prairie (13-9), which finished first in the Badger West north pod.
But Thompson, who was trying to call time out before the 1-1 pitch from senior right-hander Noah Frey, came through with one of the biggest hits of the season for Edgewood (14-4).
“I was calling time, but I didn’t get it,” said Thompson, who also drove in a run in the first inning. “I looked back at the pitcher, and the ball was coming down and I said, ‘okay, here we go’, and cranked it out to left.”
Thompson turned on a fastball from Frey and cleared the bases with a rocket to the left-field gap to stake Edgewood to a 4-1 lead.
Senior center fielder Ryan Drumm then followed with a double to center field to score Thompson to add an insurance run.
“They’re a really good team for a reason,” Sauk Prairie manager Darin Pape said of Edgewood, which finished first in the Badger West south pod. “They’ve won a lot of baseball games. They’re fast, they’re athletic, they don’t hurt themselves and they got the hits they needed at the right time today. That’s how baseball goes.”
Edgewood jumped on Frey for a run in the top of the first inning. Leadoff hitter and senior shortstop Jackson Trudgen reached base on an infield single, stole second, and moved to third on senior right fielder Joe Hartlieb’s infield out.
Thompson then hit a ground ball up the middle, but Trudgeon beat Frey’s throw to home plate for the only run either team could muster through the first five innings.
Edgewood loaded the bases in the top of the second inning when junior catcher Leo Keonig reached base on an error, freshman third baseman Preston Yaucher singled to right field and junior second baseman Jacob Sheahan reached on a bunt single.
But Frey retired Koenig at home plate on Trudgeon’s ground ball up the middle and then fielded Hartlieb’s grounder and threw to senior first baseman Kurtis Price for the third out to stymie the Crusaders.
Frey proceeded to retire 15 of 16 batters to keep the Eagles close.
“I have trust in my defense,” said Frey, who threw 21 first-pitch strikes and scattered seven hits with one intentional walk and four strikeouts in pitching a seven-inning complete game. “I knew we could get out of it if I just let them put the ball in play and let my defense make the plays. I kept that mindset the rest of the game.”
Pape said Frey was at the top of his game following the shaky start.
“He was absolutely hitting his spots and mixing it up and keeping them off-balance and doing all of the things you want your pitcher to do, limiting the walks,” Pape said of Frey, who threw 90 pitches, including 64 for strikes. “He pitched to contact when we needed him to. He did everything you need to do to win.”
Meanwhile, Edgewood sophomore right-hander Henry Bishop matched Frey pitch for pitch, allowing just four baserunners through the first five innings.
Bishop gave up five hits and an unearned run with four walks and three strikeouts before reaching the mandatory 100-pitch limit in the seventh inning.
“I was just looking to throw strikes and let my defense work behind me,” Bishop said. “I couldn’t ask for anything better.”
Sauk Prairie had Bishop on the ropes, though, in the sixth inning when the Eagles loaded the bases with no outs.
Larsen led off with an infield single and moved to second when senior third baseman Eddie Breunig ripped a single down the left-field line. Senior shortstop Quinn Baier then reached base on an infield error to set the table for the Eagles.
Bishop retired senior left fielder Spencer Alisch on a pop-up before Price followed with a sacrifice fly to right field to score Larsen and tie the game at 1-1.
After junior right fielder JJ Denny was intentionally walked, Bishop escaped further damage when he induced senior center fielder Adam Hutter to pop out to Yaucher at third base for the final out.
Madison Edgewood manager Rich Newton said the Crusaders made a few adjustments that proved to be successful after Sauk Prairie prevailed with a walk-off 3-2 win when the teams met on May 17.
“He threw strikes, pounded the zone, and mixed it up,” Newton said of Bishop. “We faced them on Tuesday, so we had a good idea of what they do offensively. So we tried to counter that with some off-speed stuff.
“I thought Henry did a good job. (Steffen) Mello, another sophomore, pitched well against them on Tuesday. Bishop pitched well for us today.”
That set the stage for the Crusaders to break the game open against Frey and the Eagles, who had won 10 of their 13 previous games.
“My fastball and slider were definitely working for me,” Frey said. “I struck three guys out on the slider, so I kept going back to that.”
But the tide turned for the Eagles after Frey retired Koenig on a ground ball to open the top of the seventh inning.
Yaucher and Sheahan hit back-to-back singles and with the duo in scoring position at third base and second base, respectively, Pape opted to intentionally walk Trudgeon to load the bases and set up a force play.
The strategy nearly worked when Hartlieb lined an 0-2 pitch toward right field that Larsen made a spectacular diving catch on to his left. Larsen quickly recovered and fired a strike to Baier at second base to attempt to double up Sheahan.
“It was a hell of a play,” Frey said. “That’s why I have to trust my defense because they make plays like that all of the time.”
But Sheahan was ruled safe and three pitches later, Thompson delivered his game-winning double to break the Eagles’ hearts.
“It’s a game of inches,” Newton said. “We got that break and then the next guy gets a big hit.”
Pape agreed.
“Our guys thought they got them,” Pape said on the close play at second base. “Brenden (Larsen) has made some incredible plays the last couple of games. He’s made plays he shouldn’t make. That diving catch was not a whole lot different from one he had in Platteville. He’s been playing great defense.”
Although Larsen was clearly disappointed, he quickly moved on.
“I think if that double play gets called, we come back and win that game,” he said. “It was a great game for everybody, and I think we can do a lot more this postseason for sure.”
Pape said Edgewood simply found a way to win.
“We didn’t get the big hit like they did when we needed it,” he said. “We had our chances. It’s a credit to them. They made the pitches when they needed to when it was time.”
Sauk Prairie wasn’t finished quite yet, though, when Frey and Larsen drew back-to-back walks off Bishop with one out in the bottom of the seventh.
Trudgeon then relieved Bishop and walked Breunig on a 3-2 count to load the bases.
But Trudgeon retired the next two batters to earn a save.
Frey said the Eagles — who were picked by Badger West Conference coaches to finish seventh in a preseason poll — will use the setback as extra motivation for the playoffs.
“This was a big game,” Frey said. “We would have liked to win, but it’s not the end. We’ve been in playoff mode since mid-season.”
Added Larsen: “It’s always nice to be the underdog. We believed in ourselves from day one, even before those rankings came out. It’s definitely nice to prove them wrong. The playoffs definitely change the atmosphere because every game is do-or-die. It’s going to be a lot more fun.”
• Sauk Prairie 3, Madison Edgewood 2 — Brenden Larsen singled to left field to score junior catcher Grant Sorg with the winning run in the bottom of the seventh inning to lift the host Eagles past the Crusaders in a Badger West Conference game on May 17. Eddie Breunig had three hits, including a double, while JJ Denny drove in two runs to pace Sauk Prairie’s attack.
• Sauk Prairie 8, Platteville 0 — Junior right-hander Landon Ballweg threw a complete-game shutout and struck out five to help the Eagles blank the host Hillmen in a non-conference game last Thursday. Quinn Baier and Noah Frey each had two hits and drove in two runs, while Adam Hutter added a double and an RBI to pace the Sauk Prairie offense. The Eagles had 11 different players reach base.
• On deck: Second-seeded Sauk Prairie hosts seventh-seeded Platteville in a WIAA Division 2 regional semifinal game at Chuck Hall Memorial Field on Thursday at 5 p.m. The winner then faces the winner of sixth-seeded Lodi at third-seeded River Valley in a regional final on Tuesday at a time and site to be determined.
May 17
Sauk Prairie 3,
Madison Edgewood 2
Edgewood .. 100 100 0 — 2 7 2
Sauk …….. 000 200 1 — 3 8 0
Pitchers (ip-h-r-er-so-bb) — ME: Steffen Mello (L: 6.1-6-3-3-5-4), Henry Gill (0.0-2-0-0-0-0); SP: Phillip Enerson (W: 7-7-2-2-3-1).
Leading hitters — ME: Ryan Drumm 2x3; Luke Thompson 2x3. SP: Eddie Breunig 3x3, (2B); Quinn Baier (2B).
May 19
Sauk Prairie 8, Platteville 0
Sauk …...... 005 000 3 — 8 7 1
Platteville ... 000 000 0 — 0 3 0
Pitchers (ip-h-r-er-so-bb) —SP: Landon Ballweg (W: 7-3-0-0-5-2); P: Keegan Coffey (L: 2.1-2-5-5-1-6), Derek Digman (4.2-5-3-2-2-5);.
Leading hitters — SP: Quinn Baier 2x3; Noah Frey 2x2; Adam Hutter (2B).
May 21
Madison Edgewood 5,
Sauk Prairie 1
Edgewood .. 100 000 4 — 5 7 1
Sauk ……. 000 001 0 — 1 5 2
Pitchers (ip-h-r-er-so-bb) — ME: Henry Bishop (W: 6.1-5-1-0-3-4), Jackson Trudgeon (S: 0.2-0-0-0-0-1). SP: Noah Frey (L: 7-7-5-5-4-1).
Leading hitters — ME: Preston Yaucher 2x3, Jacob Sheahan 2x3, Luke Thompson (2B), Ryan Drumm (2B). SP: Brenden Larsen 2x2.


