Kalscheur getting her kicks

Like mother, like daughter, Emma-Ray Kalscheuer isn’t afraid to try new things.
A junior who competes in basketball and soccer for the Wisconsin Heights Vanguards, Kalscheuer has become a trailblazer of sorts for the school’s eight-man football program.
She tried out for the team in August and quickly took over as the team’s placekicker and kickoff specialist. And through four weeks, Kalscheuer is 19-of-23 on extra points, including a six of seven effort in Heights’ 48-14 victory over North Crawford last Friday.
“Ever since I was little, I always wanted to play football,” Kalscheuer said. “But it’s a big thing that girls play football. When I was old enough to understand, my mom explained that she, too, played football. But she was a kicker.”
Kalscheuer said she played youth soccer and basketball and never considered playing football until she was in eighth grade.
“I got interested in doing that at some point in high school,” she said. “I guess it took a lot of convincing by my friends and the coaches who were super awesome and reached out to me that I should really try it.”
That included Heights’ co-head coaches Dustan Baldassari and Jay Kuenster, who did their best to alleviate any reservations Kalscheuer had about using her soccer skills on the football field.
Kalscheuer’s mother, Jessica (nee Wagner), was a placekicker at Middleton High School during the 1997 season, which also inspired her daughter to follow her dreams.
“My mom’s senior year, they didn’t have a club soccer team in the fall for girls at the time,” Kalscheuer said. “They didn’t have a kicker on the football team, so I think she just thought it would be cool to try it. It would keep her in shape, and she could kick it hard and far.”
Taking the plunge
The COVID-19 pandemic wiped out the 2020 fall football season, and Kalscheuer concentrated on playing varsity soccer last spring when the Vanguards opted to compete in football in the alternate fall season. But as her junior year drew near, Kalscheuer knew she had a decision to make.
“My goal was to play three sports in high school ever since the beginning,” she said. “I tried cross country in eighth grade, and that was not for me. Volleyball, I tried in middle school, too, and that was not for me either.
“So just knowing that my mom kicked in football and that it was a fall sport kind of made it easier. I found my third sport to fill in, and I really like it.”
Baldassari said he initially encouraged Kalscheuer to give kicking a try.
“We had a pretty good kicker last year in Trevor Dimpfl, but the spot was open,” said Baldassari, who will also coach girls varsity basketball this upcoming season. “Emma-Ray showed some interest, so we said come give it a try and quickly realized she had an accurate leg and could get the ball through the uprights.”
Kalscheuer quickly proved she belonged during her varsity debut when she made four of five PATs in the Vanguards’ season-opening 36-34 loss over St. Mary Catholic/Valley Christian on Aug. 28. But she admitted having a case of pre-game jitters before making her debut.
“I was very much freaking out at the beginning because the day or two before, one of my kicks hit our center, Jaeger Shoenemann, in the back,” she said. “It did not go well. It was ‘oh my gosh, what if I do that in a game’ moment?”
But Kalscheuer’s teammates quickly assured her that she had nothing to worry about.
“All the guys were like, ‘you’ll be fine, you’re not going to be doing that in a game. But if you do, it’s not going to be that big of a deal,’ ” she recalled.
Kalscheuer said once she delivered her first kick, she was able to relax and focus on the game.
“Once that first kick went up, all the pressure was off of me,” she said. “It felt really good. I realized I can do this.”
However, Kalscheuer wasn’t the only female on the field for that season-opening game.
“St. Mary’s actually had a girl kicker, too,” Kalscheuer said. “They were awesome. It was, ‘Oh, my gosh, there’s two female kickers.’ They were cool about it.
“Other teams, when we shake hands at the end, and they see my helmet’s off and that I’m a girl, they are surprised.”
Filling a role
Kalscheuer said her soccer teammates have strongly supported her efforts on the gridiron this fall.
“Her soccer teammates have started some chants at the games, like ‘Go Ray-Ray’, which has been awesome to hear,” Baldassari said. “It has been cool to see the fans’ reactions for her, too.”
That includes Vanguards’ student-athletes in other sports, Kalscheuer said.
“A lot of the girls, like the volleyball girls, I’m close friends with them, my best friend plays volleyball, and they all come and support me,” she said. “The stands are full. The best feeling is when I walk on the field and they’re chanting my name. It’s awesome.”
Kalscheuer hasn’t attempted a field goal through four games. But she has converted 19 of 23 PATs, with two of the misses being blocked kicks.
“She’s been doing great, I’m so proud of her,” Jessica Kalscheuer said of her daughter. “My only advice was to make sure it was something you could do before jumping in. Her and I practiced a little while and she said she wanted to do it. I said, ‘Go for it, you’re doing great. Go for it.’ ”
Emma-Ray Kalscheur has also gotten some reps in some junior varsity scrimmages as a position player.
“I got to play cornerback and made some tackles,” said Emma-Ray Kalscheuer, who lists gym as her favorite class and also takes a strength and conditioning class first hour that is taught by Baldassari. “But in a real varsity game, I haven’t had to.”
Baldassari said he had no concerns over how Kalscheuer would be treated by her male teammates on or off the field.
“I wasn’t too worried about it coming into this season,” Baldassari said. “Her junior class is very tight between the boys and girls. They all get along very well. She’s a real easy person to talk to and to get along with.
“But it went better than I expected. The guys have totally embraced her and made her part of the team. There is zero ostracizing of any kind. In some ways, she’s just one of the guys. And in other ways, they’re not afraid to poke fun of her at being a girl once in a while. It’s all in good fun.”
Emma-Ray Kalscheuer said her teammates have been welcoming and made her feel part of the team despite her gender.
“Everyone has been very supportive,” she said. “One of the guys, a junior, is my cousin, Kaden Wagner. We’ve known each other since we were little and it’s something I’ve always wanted to do, and he’s been super supportive of it.”
Senior wide receiver/defensive back Gavin Warner said Kalscheuer has played a key role in the Vanguards’ 3-1 record this season.
“Emma-Ray had a big role to fill with Trevor (Dimpfl) graduating, and she stepped up and made a really big impact on the team right from the beginning,” Warner said. “It was really brave of her to come out and follow in her mom’s footsteps. I’m really glad she is part of the team this year.”
Blazing a trail
Kalscheuer said she never thought much about being a role model of sorts, but was more concerned on how her classmates and friends would take to her trying something new.
Knowing that her mother was a three-sport athlete in high school, also competing in basketball in soccer along with football, provided her the impetus to give it a try.
“For me, joining (the team) was difficult,” she said. “It was more about the social take on it. How it would affect me socially at school, and how would people react to it? Finally, I just pushed that aside and realized what I wanted to do, and didn’t care. I’m so happy I did it.”
Kalscheuer admitted she has plenty on her plate this fall, also playing for a Wisconsin Heights U-18 club soccer team that plays in the Madison Area Youth Soccer Association (MAYSA) league.
“On Tuesdays and Thursdays, I head over to soccer practice, and we have games on the weekends,” she said.
But Kalscheuer said now that she has taken the plunge and given football a try, she hopes other girls will follow.
“I hope that other girls, if they are debating on playing, don’t worry about the dumb things like if would people be friends with them, will the guys just want to be friends,” she said. “They should just play because they want to because it’s definitely worth it.”


